Kentucky Tests State's Reach Against Online Gambling

By Brian Krebs
Washingtonpost.com Staff Writer

Wednesday, October 8, 2008; 5:40 PM

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/10/08/AR2008100802870_pf.html


An effort by the state of Kentucky to seize more than 140 online gambling 
Web site names is raising novel legal questions about the physical location 
of digital property and the reach of local and regional governments on the 
global Internet.

Last month, a Kentucky circuit court judge granted a request by the 
governor to have 141 Web site names used by online gaming operations 
transferred to the state's control. The action was filed by a Chicago law 
firm on behalf of Gov. Steve Beshear (D), who was elected in part on the 
strength of a promise to bring casino gambling to the state.

The domains include some of the most popular online gaming sites on the 
Internet, including UltimateBet.com and FullTiltPoker.com. According to the 
state, residents spend roughly $170 million each year gambling at online 
casinos, potentially taxable revenue that might otherwise have been spent 
at the state's own gaming operations, which include regulated betting on 
horse racing and bingo.

Attorneys for the state convinced Judge Thomas Wingate that the gambling 
Web site names were tangible "gambling devices" that could be seized under 
Kentucky's gaming statutes. Wingate's order compels the entities that 
manage the registration of those domains, known as domain registrars, to 
transfer control over the Web sites to the state.

Jennifer Brislin, spokeswoman for the Kentucky justice department, said the 
state is seeking unspecified damages from the casinos, but that its primary 
goal is to force the Web sites to block Kentucky residents from visiting 
them. She said the majority of the registrars affected by the judge's order 
had "locked" the domains in question to prevent them from being transferred 
to another registrar pending the outcome of the case.

"We think it creates a tremendous disadvantage for our legitimate, licensed 
and taxed gaming interests, and there are some damages that are due to the 
commonwealth as a result," Brislin said.

Opponents of the decision say the Kentucky has no legal authority to seize 
the casino Web site names, as neither the individuals who registered the 
Web sites nor the registrars themselves are physically located there. All 
of the online casinos are operated outside of the United States. Many 
online gaming companies are lobbying on Capitol Hill to be legalized, 
regulated and taxed in the United States, which would allow them to market 
to U.S. consumers.

Bret Fausett, a domain name expert and attorney with the Los Angeles law 
firm Adorno, Yoss, Alvarado & Smith, notes that Kentucky's gaming 
regulations were written long before the advent of the commercial Internet, 
and make no mention of virtual casinos.

"This is a little bit like if the Home Shopping TV network was accused of 
fraud, and Kentucky decided to seize the show's cameras and set even though 
HSN's real location is nowhere near the state," Fausett said.

At least two domains, luckypyramidcasino.com and highrollerslounge.com -- 
both registered through Bellevue, Wash. based registrar eNom -- have been 
handed over to the state government. Enom did not respond to requests for 
comment.

Christine Jones, general counsel for GoDaddy.com, the registrar used by 20 
of the 141 domains named in the judge's order, said the company tried to 
walk a line between complying with that demand and defending the rights of 
their customers, noting that the casino site owners did not have an 
opportunity to present their side of the case at the hearing in which the 
judge ordered the transfer of the domains.

"We issued a registrar certificate to the state that says the court has 
jurisdiction over the issue, but it doesn't have control over the domains, 
other than the ability to exercise judgment so that when there is a final 
adjudication on the merits of the case or a settlement by the parties, we 
will honor that outcome," Jones said.

On Tuesday, dozens of trade groups, domain registrars and gambling 
advocates had an opportunity to tell Judge Wingate why the case should be 
dismissed outright.

One of those at the hearing was Michael Collins, executive director of the 
Internet Commerce Association, a trade group representing domain name 
investors and online advertisers. Collins said entire prospect of using the 
Internet -- not only for commerce but for free speech -- is at risk if one 
government or state decides they can freely seize domain names.

"What's to keep Iran or China from doing the same thing? Yet, even China - 
which tries very hard to control the Internet its citizens use - hasn't 
tried to do what Kentucky is trying to do here," Collins said.

Collins said that while the judge appeared to listen attentively to 
statements from those defending the online casinos, attorneys for the state 
presented the registrar certificates from GoDaddy as evidence that the 
court does indeed have jurisdiction to seize the casino domains.

Wingate is expected to decide within seven days whether to dismiss the case 
or allow it to proceed to a forfeiture hearing.

John Levine, author of "The Internet for Dummies" and co-founder of the 
Domain Assurance Council, a non-profit industry consortium, said the case 
is likely either to be thrown out or reversed on appeal.

"The state's legal arguments fail on so many levels that it's truly bizarre 
that the court didn't reject this case in the first place," Levine said.

A federal law passed in 2006 makes it illegal for U.S. financial 
institutions to process payments for online gambling sites. But the law did 
nothing to prohibit U.S. citizens from gambling at online casinos. Only one 
state - Washington - has passed a law that bars residents from placing bets 
online.

Critics of the federal law say U.S. citizens who wish to gamble online can 
easily find ways around the payment restrictions. For example, in a 
transcript of the oral arguments that Kentucky's lawyers made to the judge, 
investigators describe how they were able to gamble at various online 
casinos using a gift card issued by Visa.


=================================================
George Antunes                    Voice (713) 743-3923
Associate Professor               Fax   (713) 743-3927
Political Science                    Internet: antunes at uh dot edu
University of Houston
Houston, TX 77204-3011         

*******************************
* POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] *
*******************************

Medianews mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to