OCTOBER 8, 2008, 3:25 P.M. ET Dish-TiVo Partnership Seen As Spat Winds Down
By Ben Charny and Roger Cheng DOW JONES NEWSWIRES http://online.wsj.com/article/BT-CO-20081008-714959.html SAN FRANCISCO (Dow Jones)--With four years of litigation between TiVo Inc. (TIVO) and Dish Network Corp. (DISH) winding down, the relationship between the companies might be entering a less-contentious phase: partnership. Earlier this week, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear an appeal of a 2006 verdict that found Dish had infringed on several of TiVo's patents. The high court's decision effectively ended an original lawsuit filed against Dish by Alviso, Calif.-based TiVo in 2004. With the lawsuit behind them, the two companies will now figure out a way to work together, many analysts say. They say the two companies have complementary technology that could enhance their respective business models. "We continue to believe the case could lead to a licensing deal with Dish," noted BMO Capital Markets analyst Leland Westerfield, who holds an outperform rating on Tivo shares and a $20 price target. He doesn't rate Dish. A deal would likely focus on licensing TiVo's recording technology, which allows users to record programs and watch them at their leisure, to Dish. That would help Dish market its satellite television service, which is falling behind competitors including DirecTV Group Inc. (DTV). It would also give TiVo access to the Englewood, Colo.-based company's 13.7 million subscribers, possibly opening a new and large stream of revenue. TiVo and Dish representatives declined to comment for this report. But TiVo executives have previously suggested the company, which is in the midst of changing its business model to one stressing partnerships rather than direct sales, would consider some sort of deal with Dish. TiVo Chief Executive Officer Tom Rogers, who took over in July 2005, has de-emphasized the company's standalone direct-sales model, which was expensive to maintain because it required the company to shoulder the costs of marketing its product. More than ever before, he's cut deals with cable and satellite providers, which use TiVo as a lure to get subscribers. Those companies pay part of the marketing costs. The companies have to clear several hurdles before they can pursue an agreement. For example, Dish still owes TiVo $104 million that it has kept in escrow since losing the original case in 2006. That includes an award of $73.9 million, as well as interest. Dish has said it will soon turn the money over. Dish still faces a potential contempt charge in Texas that springs from a workaround Dish devised after it was found to have infringed on TiVo's patents in 2006. TiVo challenged that workaround. A decision could come as early as this week. If the court finds in favor TiVo, Dish could owe TiVo an additional $300 million in penalties, according to some estimates. That would be more than twice analysts' estimates for TiVo's revenue in fiscal 2008, which ends in January. Recently, TiVo shares were up 4.2% to $5.97, while Dish shares rose 7.1% to $18.15. A ruling against Dish might also prompt the company to cut a deal with TiVo more quickly. That's because the ruling might require Dish to disconnect all of the digital video recorders it has sold since 2006 and force it to stop selling digital video recorders until it comes into compliance with the court. To be sure, Dish has a reputation for being combative. It has said it will continue to fight TiVo in two separate lawsuits. "Dish has been known to litigate and is not afraid of litigating," said April Horace, an analyst at Janco Partners Inc. Still, making nice might make the most sense. Dish has fallen behind its rivals and is looking for a way to catch up. In August, it reported the first quarterly net loss for a major U.S. satellite TV provider. It continues to lose market share to rival DirecTV, as well as cable providers and phone companies. Also, Dish could use future developments in TiVo's digital recording software to augment its service offering. The technology melds well with products from Sling Media, a unit of Dish sister company Echostar Corp. (SATS) Sling Media's products allow users to record and watch programs recorded at home over their computers. ================================================= George Antunes Voice (713) 743-3923 Associate Professor Fax (713) 743-3927 Political Science Internet: antunes at uh dot edu University of Houston Houston, TX 77204-3011 ******************************* * POST TO [EMAIL PROTECTED] * ******************************* Medianews mailing list [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews
