November 18, 2008

Mark Cuban Is Charged With Insider Trading
By MICHAEL J. de la MERCED and FLOYD NORRIS
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/18/business/18insider.html?_r=1&oref=slogin&ref=business&pagewanted=print


As anyone who follows the National Basketball Association knows, Mark 
Cuban, the Internet entrepreneur turned owner of the Dallas Mavericks 
basketball team, has never shied from a fight. But now the pugnacious 
billionaire is squaring off against his biggest adversary yet: the 
federal government.

On Monday, the Securities and Exchange Commission filed a civil suit 
charging Mr. Cuban with insider trading for selling shares of a small 
Internet search company in 2004, just before its share price fell.

Mr. Cuban saved himself a $750,000 loss, according to the complaint 
filed in United States District Court in Dallas.

Mr. Cuban swiftly fired back, accusing the regulator of “prosecutorial 
misconduct” and alleging that he was the victim of a political vendetta 
by the agency in the waning days of the Bush administration.

“I am disappointed that the commission chose to bring this case based 
upon its enforcement staff’s win-at-any-cost ambitions,” Mr. Cuban said. 
“The staff’s process was result-oriented, facts be damned.”

Since he bought the Mavericks in 2000 with money he earned by selling 
his start-up, Broadcast.com, to Yahoo for $5.9 billion before the 
dot-com crash, Mr. Cuban has become one of the biggest lightning rods in 
American professional sports. From his seat behind the Mavericks bench, 
clad in his signature team gear, he has not hesitated in picking 
arguments, and has paid nearly $1.7 million in fines to the N.B.A.

(After once saying he would not hire the N.B.A.’s chief of referees to 
“manage a Dairy Queen,” Mr. Cuban paid a $500,000 fine — and spent a day 
at a Dairy Queen serving Blizzards to fans.)

But he also turned around a flagging franchise, attracting star players 
and helping to bring the Mavericks to the brink of an N.B.A. 
championship in 2006.

Mike Bass, an N.B.A. spokesman, declined to comment.

The charges could pose a problem for his dreams of a burgeoning sports 
empire. Mr. Cuban is widely reported to be the lead bidder for the 
Chicago Cubs baseball team, but he is thought to be too hot to handle by 
many of Major League Baseball’s current owners. The insider-trading 
lawsuit may only make his quest for the baseball team more difficult to 
fulfill.

At issue in the S.E.C.’s lawsuit is Mr. Cuban’s sale in June 2004 of 
shares in Mamma.com, a small Internet search engine based in Canada, 
whose corporate name is now Copernic.

Mr. Cuban had purchased 600,000 shares, or a 6.3 percent stake, just 
three months earlier as the stock was soaring. The share price tripled 
over a two-day period in early March on volume that totaled more than 12 
times the number of outstanding shares. That prompted an S.E.C. 
investigation that ended without charges being filed.

Scott W. Friestad, the S.E.C.’s deputy director of enforcement, said the 
investigation of Mr. Cuban’s trading began in early 2007, but declined 
to say what had set off the inquiry.

On June 28, 2004, Mr. Cuban called Mamma.com’s chief executive after 
receiving an e-mail message from the executive, who told him of a 
planned stock offering and asked if he would like to invest. Such 
offerings often depress share prices, at least temporarily.

According to the complaint, Mr. Cuban was told the information was 
confidential.

After the conversation, the chief executive wrote to the company’s 
chairman in an e-mail message: “As anticipated, he initially ‘flew off 
the handle’ and said he would sell his shares (recognizing that he was 
not able to do anything until we announce the equity).”

But within minutes of the call Mr. Cuban began selling his shares, and 
completed the sales on June 29, according to the lawsuit, fetching an 
average of $13.24 a share. The next day, after the offering was 
announced, Mamma.com stock opened at $11.89, sparing him a $750,000 
loss. By July 8, the shares had plummeted to $8. On Monday, the stock 
closed at 28 cents.

“Mamma.com entrusted Mr. Cuban with nonpublic information after he 
promised to keep the information confidential,” Mr. Friestad said. “Less 
than four hours later, Mr. Cuban betrayed that trust by placing an order 
to sell all of his shares. It is fundamentally unfair for someone to use 
access to nonpublic information to improperly gain an edge on the market.”

In a press release (and in a post on his blog), Mr. Cuban accused the 
S.E.C. of being “infected by the misconduct of the staff of its 
enforcement division,” but did not discuss details of the suit.

A person close to Mr. Cuban provided what he said was one of a series of 
e-mail messages from Jeffrey B. Norris, an S.E.C. lawyer in Fort Worth, 
who accused the billionaire of being unpatriotic for helping to finance 
a movie named “Loose Change.” In the e-mail message, Mr. Norris 
described the movie as a “vicious and absurd documentary” that “posits 
that President Bush planned the demolition of the World Trade Center as 
a pretext for going to war against Iraq.”

In the e-mail message, sent from his S.E.C. e-mail address, Mr. Norris 
said he was informing Christopher Cox, the chairman of the S.E.C., of 
Mr. Cuban’s actions.

“If this upsets you, I wonder how George Bush feels,” Mr. Norris wrote. 
“I assume that Mr. Cox would view your involvement with ‘Loose Change’ 
much as I do. After all, he served his country as a Republican 
congressman from Orange County for nearly 20 years and was appointed by 
President Bush.”

An S.E.C. spokesman said that Mr. Norris had no role in or knowledge of 
the Mamma.com investigation, which was handled by the S.E.C. in Washington.

He said the e-mail matter was “referred for disciplinary action,” but 
did not say what action, if any, was taken against Mr. Norris. Mr. 
Norris did not return a phone call.

The S.E.C. spokesman said Mr. Cox had recused himself when the 
commission voted to approve filing the complaint. The S.E.C. has the 
authority to bring only civil suits, not criminal complaints. The 
Justice Department can file criminal insider-trading charges, but does 
so only rarely and did not in this case. Mr. Cuban presumably could have 
settled the S.E.C. case by paying the $750,000 and perhaps an additional 
penalty, and accepting an injunction barring him from further violations 
of securities laws.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to