www.chicagotribune.com/business/columnists/chi-sun-phil-rosenthal-16nov16,0,1422644.column

Sirius, XM hear a lot of static for merging their lineups

Phil Rosenthal
Chicago Tribune

November 16, 2008



A lot of people who subscribe to satellite radio received something of a 
shock when they tuned in on Wednesday, and not because of faulty wiring.

Sirius and XM Radio, married this summer into Sirius XM Radio, ended the 
honeymoon for listeners. They did what companies always do in mergers: 
eliminate duplicate operations to cut costs, this time wreaking havoc on 
their respective programming lineups. Each service lost channels, and 
some of the survivors were tweaked, renamed and/or moved.

To hear the most vocal of suddenly dissatisfied customers, some of whom 
left blistering comments on the Tower Ticker blog 
(chicagotribune.com/phil) item about the new lineup, it was as if 
someone had broken in while they slept, made off with some cherished 
possessions, hauled in inferior replacements and left things in general 
disarray.

Sirius listeners found such channels as Movin' Easy, Punk, Sirius 
Disorder, The Strobe, Boombox, Backspin and Universo Latino were gone. 
XM subscribers were without XM Sports Nation, X-Country, Fungus, Raw, 
Beyond Jazz, Fine Tuning, The System, Chrome, Viva, Aguila and Caricia.

It doesn't matter that those weren't the most popular channels.

For almost every channel out there, there's someone, maybe several 
someones, for whom it was a favorite, providing the soundtrack to the 
daily commute, relief from the grind or just a welcome distraction. And, 
poof, it was gone. Or messed with.

What looked to the corporate types as a redundancy, devoted fans saw as 
a reason for continuing to shell out $8 or more per month even as the 
economy put a hurt on the household budget.

Some of the dissatisfaction probably was unavoidable. Some of the people 
who went with XM did so because they preferred its service to Sirius, 
and vice versa, so they weren't going to be happy with any combination.

Compounding the resentment was that the best known channels on each 
service, such as Oprah Winfrey's Oprah & Friends on XM and Howard Stern 
on Sirius, are available to subscribers of the opposite service only if 
they pony up more cash.

Radio listeners are accustomed to abrupt format and personnel changes, 
though they complain loudly about them. Because people pay for satellite 
services, they feel a bigger stake and see these kinds of changes as a 
promise unkept, a broken covenant.

Those listeners say this will spell the beginning of the end for Sirius 
XM, but that ignores the fact that Sirius or XM had to be in pretty bad 
shape to get the feds to approve their merger in the first place.

The combined company said last week that its third-quarter losses 
totaled $4.88 billion after recording a sizable charge connected to a 
decline in its stock.

It expects to have 19.1 million subscribers by year's end and 20.6 
million at the end of 2009, but the economic slowdown, especially its 
effect on sales of autos that will come with satellite radios, can 
hardly help growth.

That says nothing of potential technological advances that could 
outstrip what satellite radio can offer.

Many of these problems are not unique to radio.

People respond viscerally to changes in the media they rely upon.

In television, where even the least popular programs on the broadcast 
networks have audiences the size of small cities, viewers get furious 
when their favorite shows are canceled, moved or adjusted, vowing 
boycotts and launching generally unsuccessful campaigns calling for 
decisions to be reversed.

When print publications move, eliminate or change features, comics, 
columns, even typefaces, readers go through denial, anger and all the 
other stages of grief Elisabeth Kubler-Ross laid out.

The need to reinvent business models and make do with less in the media 
industry has brought a lot of abrupt change in a short span, upsetting 
consumers who inevitably predict that these actions hasten, rather than 
forestall, demise.

That is the price to be paid for having developed a dedicated customer 
base in the first place.

The media can't afford to lose them, but it can't afford to please them 
all either.

-- 
================================
George Antunes, Political Science Dept
University of Houston; Houston, TX 77204 
Voice: 713-743-3923  Fax: 713-743-3927
Mail: antunes at uh dot edu

***********************************
* POST TO [email protected] *
***********************************

Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to