[More news of the weird: bankers behaving badly.]

March 11, 2011

U.S. Inquiry on Military Family Foreclosures
By DIANA B. HENRIQUES
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/12/business/12military.html?_r=1&ref=business&pagewanted=print


The Justice Department is investigating allegations that a mortgage 
subsidiary of Morgan Stanley foreclosed on almost two dozen military 
families from 2006 to 2008 in violation of a longstanding law aimed at 
preventing such action.

A department spokeswoman confirmed on Friday that the Morgan Stanley 
unit, Saxon Mortgage Services, is one of several mortgage and lending 
companies being investigated by its civil rights division. The inquiry 
is focused on possible violations of a federal law that bars lenders 
from foreclosing on active-duty service members without a court hearing.

Mark Lake, a Morgan Stanley spokesman, declined on Friday to comment on 
the investigation. However, in the fine print of a recent regulatory 
filing, Morgan Stanley disclosed that it was “responding to subpoenas 
and requests for information” from various government and regulatory 
agencies concerning, among other issues, its “compliance with the 
Servicemembers Civil Relief Act,” the law that governs the actions 
creditors can take against service members on active duty.

The investigation came to light in a document that Saxon’s lawyers filed 
on Tuesday in federal court in Grand Rapids, Mich., during a trial to 
assess damages against Saxon and two co-defendants after a federal judge 
ruled late last year that they had illegally seized and sold the home of 
Sgt. James B. Hurley, a Michigan National Guard member who lost his home 
while he was serving in Iraq in 2005. That case was ultimately settled 
on Thursday.

In the document filed on Tuesday, one of Saxon’s lawyers characterized 
the investigation as “merely a preliminary investigation based on 
unproven allegations, for which no liability or wrongdoing has been found.”

The filing also suggested that Saxon was negotiating a settlement, but 
neither Morgan Stanley nor the Justice Department would comment on any 
talks.

According to people present in the courtroom, the discussions of the 
Saxon filing indicated that as many as 23 military foreclosures were 
under scrutiny in the Justice Department investigation.

Under the civil relief act, a judge must hold a hearing at which the 
service member is represented before granting a lender the right to 
foreclose on the service member’s home, even in states where a court 
order is not required for civilian foreclosures. As early as 2005, 
advocates for military families were complaining that banks and other 
lenders were frequently violating the law.

Sergeant Hurley was one of the service members affected by a violation 
of the act. He returned from duty as a power generator mechanic in Iraq 
in December 2005 to find that Saxon had foreclosed on his riverside home 
outside Hartford, Mich., and sold it to someone else. He sued Saxon and 
two co-defendants, Orlans Associates, the law firm in Troy, Mich., that 
handled the foreclosure paperwork, and Deutsche Bank Trust Company 
Americas, the trustee for the mortgage involved in the foreclosure.

The case dragged on until late last year, when Judge Gordon J. Quist of 
United States District Court ruled that the foreclosure and sale of the 
Hurley home had violated the civil relief act and ordered a jury trial 
to determine damages.

On Thursday, the fifth day of that trial, Sergeant Hurley settled with 
all the defendants in the case for an undisclosed sum, according to Col. 
John S. Odom, a retired Air Force lawyer who represented the Hurley 
family. The terms of the settlement are confidential, Colonel Odom said. 
“But the Hurleys are well pleased,” he added.

Mr. Lake of Morgan Stanley said: “We are very pleased to have settled 
this matter with Sergeant Hurley. As we have said previously, Saxon is 
always willing to make reasonable accommodations to amicably resolve a 
matter, especially for our service men and women.”

John T. Gallagher, a spokesman for Deutsche Bank, declined to comment on 
the settlement itself. “As Deutsche Bank has repeatedly informed The New 
York Times, loan servicers, and not trustees, initiate and manage all 
foreclosures,” Mr. Gallagher said.

He emphasized that Saxon, as the servicer on the Hurley mortgage, “had 
the sole interaction with Mr. Hurley’s representatives regarding the 
loan. No employee of Deutsche Bank had any involvement in the underlying 
facts.”

The settlement came two days after the brief courtroom drama on Tuesday 
that led to the disclosure of the Justice Department investigation.

It began when Colonel Odom unexpectedly served a subpoena on Saxon’s 
general counsel, Gregory Smallwood, who was present in the courtroom.

Saxon’s trial lawyers immediately filed a motion arguing that the 
subpoena should be quashed because “the court has ruled inadmissible any 
reference to the D.O.J. investigation for which plaintiffs have 
suggested Mr. Smallwood’s testimony would be probative.”

The motion also argued that “the fact that Saxon may be negotiating a 
settlement of the investigation is also inadmissible” and that “any 
reference to the investigation, the negotiation of a consent decree, or 
the allegations that are the basis for that investigation, would also be 
unfairly prejudicial to Saxon.”

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to