March 11, 2011

Give Up Familiar Light Bulb? Not Without Fight, Some Say
By EDWARD WYATT
NY Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/12/business/energy-environment/12bulb.html?ref=business&pagewanted=print


WASHINGTON — American protests against the encroachment of government 
have been spurred by many causes — tea, of course, and guns, frequently. 
The latest catalyst: light bulbs.

A 2007 bill, passed overwhelmingly by both houses of Congress and signed 
into law by George W. Bush, will make the familiar incandescent bulb 
subject to strict efficiency standards next year.

The effect will be to make current 100-watt bulbs obsolete — and that 
has sent conservative lawmakers, libertarians, some environmental 
activists and owners of Easy-Bake Ovens into a frenzy of activity to get 
the law repealed or, at least, to stockpile the bulbs before they 
disappear from store shelves.

“I do care about my carbon footprint, not to mention my light bill,” 
said Dana Carpender, a cookbook author in Bloomington, Ind. “But unless 
something dramatic happens to bring down the cost of alternatives, I 
will be stashing away a pile of incandescents.”

The law does not outlaw incandescent bulbs or dictate that consumers 
must use the spiral-shaped compact fluorescent lights that have become 
increasingly popular in recent years. Rather, it sets standards for the 
amount of light emitted per watt of power used. Current 100-watt bulbs 
must become 25 percent more efficient, and makers are designing new bulbs.

To Representative Joe Barton, the Texas Republican who has sponsored a 
bill to reverse the new guidelines, that nevertheless means Congress is 
dictating what types of light Americans can use in their homes.

“From the health insurance you’re allowed to have, to the car you can 
drive, to the light bulbs you can buy, Washington is making too many 
decisions that are better left to you and your family,” Mr. Barton said 
when he introduced his bill in January.

Opponents of the regulations say the fluorescent bulbs are too 
expensive, flicker annoyingly and are health hazards because they 
contain mercury.

While they are not unanimous on the issue, some environmental activists 
counter that by saying the mercury in a single fluorescent bulb is less 
than what some power plants throw into the atmosphere while generating 
the electricity it takes to light one incandescent bulb.

Makers of appliances and light bulbs, meanwhile, support the federal 
standards because they do not want to have to make scores of products to 
meet individual state regulations.

But to many Americans, the 100-watt bulb has become a cause célèbre.

Tea Party campaigners have adopted it; Representative Michele Bachmann 
of Minnesota, who introduced a bill to repeal the light bulb law in 2008 
and again this year, talked about the issue in her response to the 
president’s State of the Union message in January. And this week, 
Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky said not only did he resent the light bulb 
standards but he also blamed the government for poorly working toilets 
in his house because of the regulations on how much water they should use.

The light bulb regulations already have affected the American economy. 
Last fall, General Electric closed its last major United States plant 
producing the old-style incandescent bulbs, in Winchester, Va.

Nearly all compact fluorescent bulbs are made in Asia, although some 
United States manufacturers are retooling former factories to make other 
energy-efficient bulbs.

Several companies in the United States are working on light-emitting 
diode, or LED, bulbs, and on energy-efficient halogen incandescent 
bulbs, which use a halogen element enclosed in a traditional glass bulb.

The Energy Department says the energy savings are significant. Kathleen 
Hogan, deputy assistant secretary for energy efficiency at the 
department, told a Senate committee this week that by meeting the new 
lighting standards, consumers could save nearly $6 billion in 2015.

A household that upgrades 15 current incandescent bulbs could save about 
$50 a year, Ms. Hogan said, even after accounting for the higher cost of 
the fluorescent bulbs, which average above $1 each, versus about 35 
cents for incandescent.

Halogen incandescent bulbs now cost about $1.50 each, and LED bulbs, 
which have only begun to be introduced, can cost $20 or more each, 
though they can last 10 years or more. Three-way bulbs, appliance bulbs 
and a few other specialty products are excluded from the new standards.

All of which serves to convince some people that the government should 
not dictate light bulb standards.

Amy Ridenour, president of the National Center for Public Policy 
Research, a conservative group, said she already had about 100 old-style 
incandescent light bulbs stored in her basement in Laurel, Md., and she 
hoped to have several hundred by the time the new standards go into 
effect on Jan. 1.

Ms. Ridenour said that she opposed the government interference, but that 
her hoarding was primarily driven by concerns about the mercury in the 
compact fluorescent bulbs. Her middle child, a 10-year-old son, is 
autistic, Ms. Ridenour said. “He’s knocked over quite a few lamps,” she 
said, and broken plenty of light bulbs in the process.

The Environmental Protection Agency issues detailed instructions on how 
to clean up a broken fluorescent bulb because of the potential for 
spilling mercury. Each bulb contains about four milligrams of mercury, 
compared with 500 milligrams in old-style glass thermometers.

Nevertheless, the E.P.A. recommends recycling used fluorescent bulbs 
rather than disposing of them in household garbage.

Unknown, so far, is the economic impact of the retooling of the 
Easy-Bake Oven, the source of an unimaginable number of forced smiles 
summoned by parents after tasting a child’s cookies and cakes. The oven, 
a member of the National Toy Hall of Fame, uses a 100-watt bulb as its 
heat source, so Hasbro must give it a makeover. This fall, it will 
introduce the new Easy-Bake Ultimate Oven, which will use a different, 
so far undisclosed, heating element.

_______________________________________________
Medianews mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.etskywarn.net/mailman/listinfo/medianews

Reply via email to