You are on your own.

You knew that would be the answer.  Be happy about it.

Dawid Czeluśniak <[email protected]> wrote:

> Hi OpenBSD community,
> 
> First of all, thank you for 6.7 release.
> 
> I am a huge fan of minimal and custom installations
> as I mostly use OpenBSD to host simple HTTP servers.
> I basically use vi to edit httpd.conf file,
> obtain a certificate from Let's Encrypt using built-in acme-client,
> then start the server and things just work.
> 
> I was wondering if I need the package manager in the minimal
> installation of the system as I only use built-in deamons (httpd, sshd)
> and UNIX utilities (vi, sed)? By package manager I mean
> pkg_* executables as well as its dependencies (most notably Perl).
> (The size of /usr/libdata/perl5 is about 50MB on my machine).
> I just want the minimal installation without any unnecessary
> scripting language. One way to achieve that could be
> to manually remove pkg_* executables and Perl from a machine,
> but it can easily end up with the broken system especially when
> done by unexperienced users. But then I thought about
> the second possible way: why not to extract pkg_* executables
> and Perl to the separate file set (pkgXX.tgz)?
> In this way, people who are not going to use the package manager
> could just simply not install it. Moreover, it could break
> the base installation free from the heavy dependence on Perl.
> 
> I would like to get your opinion on that.
> 
> So the questions to the OpenBSD community are the following:
> 
> 1. Is it possible, from the technical point of view, to extract
> pkg_* utilities, perlutil(1), any other Perl-dependent code
> and Perl itself from baseXX.tgz to the separate file set
> so that users that just want the *minimal* installation of OpenBSD
> don't have to remove it manually?
> 
> 2. Are there any other programs in the baseXX.tgz file set
> that depend on Perl other than:
>     - pkg_* utilities
>     - perlutil(1) (rather obvious)
>     - fw_update(1)
>     - adduser(8) (adduser and rmuser utilities)
>     - vi.recover script
>     - cvs contrib scripts
> 
> 3. Are there people among this community who think that
> the base installation of OpenBSD should not include Perl
> and Perl-dependent programs and utilities?
> Looking at FreeBSD for a moment it seems like Perl left the
> base system in May 2002 (18 years ago)[0].
> In a nutshell the rationale was more or less the following[1]:
> 
> > It appears that having Perl in the base distro has
> > the following problems:
> 
> > 1. It increases the distro image size.
> > 2. It forces everyone to use the same version of Perl.
> > 3. If someone tries to install over that version or just even patch it,
> > it can break stuff in BSD which needed the old version.
> > 4. Installing multiple copies imposes weird symlink tricks
> > or else breaks other stuff.
> 
> All comments and opinions are appreciated. Thanks!
> 
> [0] https://lists.freebsd.org/pipermail/freebsd-announce/2002-May/000823.html
> [1] https://bsd.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=32564&cid=3513689
> 

Reply via email to