An important note:

If you do any of that and subsequently encounter a problem, you must

1. Assume you created that problem for yourself
2. Not file a bug report
3. Not complain to others on OpenBSD mailing lists.

If that is an acceptable tradeoff, go ahead, make a mess.


Philippe <[email protected]> wrote:

> On 19/05/2020 22:19, Dawid Czeluśniak wrote:
> > Hi OpenBSD community,
> > 
> > First of all, thank you for 6.7 release.
> > 
> > I am a huge fan of minimal and custom installations
> > as I mostly use OpenBSD to host simple HTTP servers.
> > I basically use vi to edit httpd.conf file,
> > obtain a certificate from Let's Encrypt using built-in acme-client,
> > then start the server and things just work.
> 
> 
> As the others already told you, you're on your own for this.
> 
> 
> That being said, there are a few leads to get what you're asking.
> Remind you that a good part of the actual size of the base install comes
> from the kernel objects (almost 350 MB on my install), since they are
> required for KARL, meaning you won't get a 10 MB install unless you drop
> this functionality (and I guess nobody will recommend that).
> Applications from the base install mostly do not take too much place.
> 
> Let's get a taste of what an actual OpenBSD looks like, size-wise:
> 
> # du ...
> 3.7M    /usr/local/bin/
> 6.5M    /bin
> 21.2M   /sbin/
> 22.7M   /usr/sbin/
> 41.7M   /usr/share/man/   # almost 42 MB just for manuals
> 149M    /usr/bin/         # mostly unused programs for my use
> 253M    /usr/lib          # thanks to C++, for a good part
> 349M    /usr/share/relink/kernel/
> 
> So yes, there a lot we can remove for a minimal install, not just Perl.
> (and one may argue that it's required for a few important things, we
> may don't really want to remove it with the current OpenBSD code base)
> 
> For people running several instances of OpenBSD there is no point having
> 10 times the same files. Yes, snapshots could be a good thing to solve
> the problem, but let's try other approaches.
> 
> 
> For the first solution, you can get a simpler base system by compiling a
> release of you own.  To achieve that, read at least mk.conf(5) and the
> FAQ about making a release [1].  I didn't play a lot with this, but I
> successfully removed compilers and a few programs.  Here is what I did.
> 
> # In file /etc/mk.conf
> # Remove games, compilers (and a few other things with gnu/), manuals
> # and a few applications.
> # You can remove other applications, just add directories to the list.
> SKIPDIR= games \
>   gnu \
>   lib/cxx \
>   share/man \
>   share/snmp \
>   usr.sbin/ospfd usr.sbin/ospf6d usr.sbin/ospfctl usr.sbin/ospf6ctl \
>   usr.sbin/ripd usr.sbin/ripctl
> 
> (This was just a test, there a lot more to remove to get a minimal
> install)
> 
> I would like to drop the single core kernel since I don't need it, but
> I'm not entirely sure it could be achieved by adding "GENERIC/" in the
> above list. That's not super relevant either, since it won't be
> installed on the system, so there is not much to care here.
> Besides, I guess we could add an option in /etc/mk.conf for the size:
> `CFLAGS=-Os`.
> The good part of this solution is that it _completely_ works as the
> upstream OpenBSD. You end-up with installation medias and sets, you have
> the installer… that's kinda great.
> 
> 
> Another solution could be resflash [2]. Resflash is a tool to create
> OpenBSD images designed for flash storage.  I don't like this solution
> much, because it changes a bit the way the system is used.  However, you
> can probably learn from it.
> 
> 
> Finally, I think crunchgen(8) could be a good lead if someone truly
> wants to get basic image with the size of Busybox (or toybox) coreutils.
> The whole point is to get several applications into a single one.  It
> sounds a bit retarded, but I'm sure there is a legit use to it,
> somewhere in the wild.  That's the last step to get _the_ smallest
> install, I guess. Of course, this is not really _just_ to get a minimal
> install, but more to get openbsd working on ISP routers with just a few
> megabytes of RAM and disk. That's a bit experimental.
> 
> 
> Food for thoughts: on FreeBSD, there is NanoBSD [3] which can be
> configured to remove up to everything except the kernel and init. This
> tool is used to create appliances, and I guess it could be nice to have
> something like that on OpenBSD. I would use it for sure for minimal
> installs on RPi-like boards.
> 
> 
> I hope it will help!
> Have a nice day everyone.
> 
> [1]: https://www.openbsd.org/faq/faq5.html
> [2]: https://stable.rcesoftware.com/resflash/
> [3]: https://www.freebsd.org/doc/en_US.ISO8859-1/articles/nanobsd/article.html
> 

Reply via email to