On Thu, Oct 21, 2021 at 03:12:33PM -0700, Chris Cappuccio wrote: > Emiel Kollof [em...@kollof.nl] wrote: > > Chris Cappuccio schreef op do 21-10-2021 om 07:56 [-0700]: > > > > > This appears to be a totally different failure than found by Avon. > > > It's also on a different class of hardware. > > > > Is it? The errors seem very similar. Also, Avon's dmesg suggests he's > > using amdgpu as well. I wonder why he deletes all the amdgpu firmwares > > only to copy over the radeon firmwares. For me, that would break > > xenocara. > > > > The errors are totally unrelated in my view. Other than having the > same formatting, as they are both generated from the amdgpu framework, > they appear to be completely different. > > Anyways, I didn't even catch that I recommended the wrong firmware. > I'm trying to get some traction here so that someone who actually > knows more about amdgpu might find a useful report. (A driver bug > report with no dmesg is no report!) > > Under radeondrm, some cards require firmware, most don't. With > amdgpu, seems like at least this card doesn't. > > Avon if you want to try older amdgpu firmwares, > > 7.0: http://firmware.openbsd.org/firmware/7.0/amdgpu-firmware-20210818.tgz > 6.9: http://firmware.openbsd.org/firmware/6.9/amdgpu-firmware-20201218.tgz > 6.8: http://firmware.openbsd.org/firmware/6.8/amdgpu-firmware-20200619.tgz > 6.7: http://firmware.openbsd.org/firmware/6.7/amdgpu-firmware-20190312.tgz > > This is not important at this point, it's just another data point > in your bug report to know which firmwares succeed and which fail. > The right place for the report, including dmesg, is b...@openbsd.org. > > Chris
Greetings Chris, My AMD machine was built by me in August 2018. OpenBSD -current was the first OS installed and has been updated every 1-2 weeks since. It caused me random grief from the time that amdgpu firmware was introduced until I removed it the other day (, assuming my memory is still A1-ok). Alas, occasionally it was a number of days between freezes which may be a 'track it down' complication. Considering my August 2018 build date, I will install the 6.7 firmware first and work upwards through the amdgpu firmware, and stop testing them as soon as one creates a freeze. I am sure they all did in the past. Over the next 2-3 days as time permits, I will collate any related information that I can find and submit it to bugs@ as you have suggested. Thanks and regards, Avon -- aer
