# from Andy Lester
# on Wednesday 16 May 2007 09:31 am:

>On May 16, 2007, at 11:26 AM, Eric Wilhelm wrote:
>> Maybe for some value of "correct."  An equally likely answer is that
>> they are both wrong.  I've asked this question before and it doesn't
>> seem to have a good answer.
                  ^^^^

>Who can say what a right answer is?  "Yes, it's correct" is no more
>right or wrong than "No, it's not, it's supposed to be X", because
>there's no "supposed to be", and even if there was, it's not enforced.

(Thanks, I know how it works.  I would like it to be more consistent 
though.  We should make a "magic 8 ball" faq generator.  When someone 
asks a new question about some un-enforced CPAN policy, it makes a 
random decision and posts the result somewhere for future reference.  
Lots of people want guidance on a few simple things which would make 
CPAN more navigable, but they get an answer of "whatever you want" when 
it is actually a decision that was previously made (by somebody), so a 
better answer would be "follow the convention."  Yeah -- freedom, blah, 
blah, and etc -- I'm not saying you can't break from convention, just 
that it would be nice to have an easy way to deduce what the 
established convention is if one exists.)

By "good answer", I meant some form of concensus.  "Yes, No, Either, 
Neither, or Both" isn't that.  Because there is no enforcement, the 
only consistency comes from strong concensus, for which there is none 
in this case.  This implies that the App:: namespace is too ambiguous.  
If you want namespace to be some form of order (I do), using it for two 
things tends toward entropy.  If you wish to avoid chaos, the answer is 
not to use it at all.

Feel free to continue to ignore the bin::* suggestion.

--Eric
-- 
Speak softly and carry a big carrot.
---------------------------------------------------
    http://scratchcomputing.com
---------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to