On Jul 27, 2007, at 6:14 AM, Lionel Elie Mamane wrote:
[...]
(And I've repeatedly heard that in the Netherlands, for some time
in the past at
least, the way the ISPs got rid of the lawful intercept obligation was
to have the AMS-IX send a copy of *all* the traffic to the government
black box. Not that they had to do that, but it was the easiest /
cheapest way.)
[...]
That is complete and utter nonsens. That never ever happend.
As everybody can see in the public member list [1] on the AMS-IX
website, the Dutch police (AS16147) is connected via 100Mbit/s port.
They are just another member, nothing more nothing less.
Encrypted and signed tapped traffic from lawful interceptions may be
send from the Dutch ISPs to the police via peering. That traffic may
go over AMS-IX indeed. The Dutch ISP are obligated to apply these
taps on *access-lines* after some form of legal order. They have to
have the the right procedures and equipment to do that (at their own
costs) [2].
-- Arien
--
Arien Vijn
Amsterdam Internet Exchange
[1] http://www.ams-ix.net/connected/?expanded=1
[2] (In Dutch) http://www.agentschap-telecom.nl/informatie/aftappen/
paginas/faq.html
