On Feb 8, 2012, at 4:51 AM, George Bonser <gbon...@seven.com> wrote:
> > >> From: Keegan Holley >> Subject: Re: UDP port 80 DDoS attack > >> It works in theory, but to get every ISP and hosting provider to ACL their >> edges and maintain those ACL's for every customer no matter how large might >> be a bit difficult. > > You don't have to ACL in most cases. RPF works for most. There will be a > few, relatively darned few, that you will need to ACL, but RPF takes care of > a large number of them. > RPF on the whole Internet would pretty much lead to an instant outage. What happens when you have two upstreams and one has an incoming route to you but your out going route for which ever of their customers talking to you doesn't agree? Instant outage. Multiply that by the entire table and then add churn. I'd give it a week before everyone turned it off, if you could even get them to enable it to begin with. > >> Also, what about non-BGP customers or customers that just accept a default >> route? > > I don't follow. The ISP still knows what traffic gets routed TO them. You > only accept FROM them what you route TO them, even if you hand them a default > route. > > >> Or even customers that just want return traffic to come in a different link >> for some reason. > > Still don't follow. I am not talking about having a firewall that is > stateful. I am talking packet by packet. If you don't route it to them, you > don't accept it from them unless you have made arrangements otherwise, which > will be a small percentage of your customers. Sure, some might be multihomed > but it is easy enough to verify that they have the networks in question > SWIPed to them or a call to the other provider can clear that up in a few > minutes. It isn't THAT hard. > > >> ISP's would suddenly become giant traffic registries. > > > No, we have registries to act as registries, the ISPs should be checking > them, and double checking. It isn't something that is going to change every > day or every week. Once you get it set up, it is going to be stable for a > while. Sure, it means a little more work in setting up a customer, but it > also means that if all your neighbors do the same thing, you field many fewer > calls dealing with stupid DoS crap. > >
