And now:Ish <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: >Date: Mon, 14 Dec 1998 17:27:38 -0800 (PST) >From: Jackie Cabasso <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> >Sender: [EMAIL PROTECTED] >Subject: BIG LEGAL WIN AGAINST DOE! >To: [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED] >X-Mailer: Windows Eudora Pro Version 2.2 (16) >X-Sender: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > >FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Monday, December 14, 1998 P.1 of 2 >CONTACT: Jackie Cabasso, Western States Legal Foundation (510) 839-5877 > Marylia Kelley, Tri-Valley CAREs (925) 443-7148 > >"HOORAY!" BIG WIN BY 39 PLAINTIFF GROUPS!! > >GROUPS WIN LANDMARK NUCLEAR WEAPONS "CLEANUP" VICTORY; TO AVOID CONTEMPT >FINDING, ENERGY DEPARTMENT AGREES TO OPEN DATABASE, ANALYSIS OF LONG-TERM >STEWARDSHIP PLANS, $6.25 MILLION CITIZEN MONITORING FUND > >WASHINGTON, DC/SAN FRANCISCO, CA -- To settle a lawsuit brought by 39 >environmental and peace organizations including the Oakland-based Western >States Legal Foundation and Livermore's Tri-Valley Communities Against a >Radioactive Environment (CAREs), the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) has >signed a landmark agreement which will increase public oversight of its >efforts to address severe contamination problems in the nation's nuclear >weapons complex. > >The settlement, which was delivered to Federal District Court Judge Stanley >Sporkin today, ends nine years of litigation charging that DOE failed to >develop its "cleanup" plans properly. DOE faced a contempt of court hearing >before Judge Sporkin for not complying with a previous legal agreement in >the case. > >"From the perspective of protecting the nation's water, air and land, this >settlement is superior to the Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement >DOE originally agreed to prepare," said David Adelman, a Natural Resources >Defense Council lawyer who represented the plaintiffs. "We now have the >data, the resources and the processes necessary to make DOE's environmental >work more accountable to the public." The Washington, D.C. law firm of Meyer >& Glitzenstein provided pro bono litigation counsel. > >Key elements of the settlement include: > > Creation of a regularly updated, publicly accessible database including >details about contaminated facilities and waste generated or controlled by >DOE's cleanup, defense, science and nuclear energy programs, including >domestic and foreign research reactor spent fuel, listing characteristics >such as waste type, volume, and radioactivity, as well as transfer and >disposition plans; > > DOE funding for at least two national stakeholder forums to assure the >database is comprehensive, accurate and useful; > > Completion of an environmental analysis, with public input, of plans for >"long-term stewardship" at contaminated DOE sites to ensure protection of >the public and the environment; > More . . . > >. . . Continued, P. 2 of 2 > > Establishment of a $6.25 million fund for non-profit groups and tribes to >use in monitoring DOE environmental activities and conducting technical >reviews of the agency's performance; > > Payment of plaintiffs'legal fees and expenses incurred to litigate this >case; and > > Continuing federal court oversight to assure adherence to the agreement. > > "I'm really excited! This is a major victory both for the environment and >for public >participation," said Marylia Kelley, of Tri-Valley CAREs in Livermore, >California, one of 39 plaintiff groups." We have won access to the tools the >public needs to monitor DOE's compliance with the nation's obligation to >address the radioactive and toxic legacy of nuclear weapons production." >DOE's "cleanup" program is slated to become the largest environmental >project in U.S. history, with an estimated total cost of more than $250 >billion. > > "Since the mid-1980's we've been asking for a breakdown of DOE-generated >waste by program and facility," added Jackie Cabasso of Oakland's Western >States Legal Foundation, a plaintiff and communications coordinator for the >lawsuit. "DOE is currently gearing up its nuclear weapons research and >development activities -- the same kinds of activities that created this >environmental disaster. Now, for the first time, using DOE's own data, we'll >be able to demonstrate the link between cause and >effect, a powerful argument against any further nuclear weapons design and >production." > > Many of the groups first sued DOE in 1989, claiming that the agency must >conduct a thorough analyses before moving ahead with plans to address the >radioactive and toxic legacy of nuclear weapons production and modernize its >facilities. The next year, DOE signed a legal agreement promising a full >public review of its proposals. In 1994, however, DOE leaders decided to >abandon the Environmental Restoration Programmatic Environmental Impact >Statement process without consent of the plaintiffs or Federal Court Judge >Sporkin, who had approved the initial settlement. In April, 1997, plaintiffs >went back to Judge Sporkin seeking enforcement of the original agreement. > > In a series of court hearings, Judge Sporkin made it clear that he expected >DOE to abide by its commitments. Earlier this year, he ordered DOE to "show >cause" why it should not be held in contempt for failing to conduct the >environmental analysis. In depositions taken by the plaintiffs, former >Energy Secretary James Watkins and other former senior DOE officials >strongly backed plaintiffs claims. The discussions which led to today's >settlement were conducted at Judge Sporkin's urging. > >- - 3 0 - - > >Note: Representatives from Western States Legal Foundation, Tri-Valley >CAREs and other northern California plaintiff groups will hold a news >conference today, Mon. Dec. 14, at 12 noon at the San Francisco offices of >the Natural Resources Defense Council, 71 Stevenson, Suite 1825 (near >Montgomery Street BART at 2nd Street, south of Market Street in San >Francisco). Representatives from attorney of record NRDC will be available >by speaker-phone from Washington, DC. > > >* * * Copies of the settlement agreement are available on request. * * * > >PLAINTIFF ORGANIZATIONS >The Atomic Mirror, CA >Bay Area Nuclear (BAN) Waste Coalition, CA >Citizen Alert, NV >Citizens for Alternatives to Radioactive Dumping, NM >Citizens Opposed to a Polluted Environment, CA >Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety, NM >East Bay Peace Action, CA >Energy Research Foundation, SC >Friends of the Earth, Washington, DC >Greenpeace, Washington, DC >Hayward Area Peace and Justice Fellowship, CA >Lane County American Peace Test, OR >Lawyers' Committee on Nuclear Policy, NY >Livermore Conversion Project, CA >Los Alamos Study Group, NM >Nashville Peace Action, TN >Natural Resources Defense Council,Washington, DC >Neighbors in Need, OH >Nevada Desert Experience, NV >Nuclear Age Peace Foundation, CA >Oak Ridge Environmental Peace Alliance, TN >Peace Action, Washington, DC >Peace Farm of Texas >Physicians for Social Responsibility, Washington, DC >Physicians for Social Responsibility - Greater SF Bay Area, CA >Physicians for Social Responsibility, CO >Physicians for Social Responsibility, NM >Physicians for Social Responsibility, NY >Plutonium Free Future, CA >Rocky Mountain Peace and Justice Center, CO >San Jose Peace Center, CA >Seattle Women Act for Peace/Women Strike for Peace >Shundahai Network, NV >Sonoma County Center for Peace and Justice, CA >Tri-Valley Communities Against a Radioactive Environment, CA >Western States Legal Foundation, CA >Women Concerned/Utahns United >Women for Peace - East Bay, CA >Women's International League for Peace and Freedom - East Bay Branch, CA > > ******************************************** > WESTERN STATES LEGAL FOUNDATION > 1440 Broadway, Suite 500 > Oakland, CA USA 94612 > Tel: (510)839-5877 > Fax: (510)839-5397 > [EMAIL PROTECTED] > ********** Part of ABOLITION 2000 ********** > Global Network to Eliminate Nuclear Weapons > &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material is distributed without profit or payment ...http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml &&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& Tsonkwadiyonrat (We are ONE Spirit) Unenh onhwa' Awayaton http://www.tdi.net/ishgooda/ `"` `"` `"` `"` `"` `"`