On 01/05/13 22:36, Aleksander Morgado wrote:
>
>>>
>>> Would a transition from 'registered' to 'idle'/'searching' considered a
>>> 'service' loss from the connection manager's perspective (e.g. the service
>>> disappears and then reappears in connection manager)? In practice, a
>>> +CEREG change may not necessarily mean that the service disappears. But I
>>> guess such a glitch can be smoothed out in the connection manager layer
>>> instead of the modem manager layer. I'm happy to update the logic as
>>> suggested if that's the expected behavior.
>>
>> Idle might be, searching probably wouldn't be. For Searching I think we
>> wanted to do the 15 or 30 second timer thing and only terminate if the
>> modem didn't reacquire the network within that window? If the device is
>> 'idle' though, I'm pretty sure you're hosed and we should shut the
>> packet data connection down. If the device is 'idle', then it's not
>> looking for a network, and it's not registered, so you have nothing.
>
>
> I'm fine with the 15s timeout when we are connected; but when not
> connected, a change from registered to either idle or searching should
> probably get notified in the DBus interface, that's the change I'm
> suggesting.
>
Thinking it twice, what I think we should have is the following:
* 3GPP registration changes are notified always *right away* (no
timeout) in the 3GPP DBus interface ("RegistrationState" property),
regardless of whether we are connected or not.
* Same for 3GPP2: CDMA1x and EV-DO registration changes are notified
always *right away* (no timeout) in the CDMA DBus interface
("Cdma1xRegistrationState" and "EvdoRegistrationState" properties),
regardless of whether we are connected or not.
* The 15s timeout to report unregistered should be set up only when the
modem is connected; and the logic should be applied in the Modem
interface, and only for the "State" property (so applicable to both 3GPP
and 3GPP2).
Some example cases:
1) If the modem *is not* connected and we get a 3GPP registration
update from MM_MODEM_3GPP_REGISTRATION_STATE_HOME to
MM_MODEM_3GPP_REGISTRATION_STATE_SEARCHING, "RegistrationState" in the
3GPP interface is updated right away, and the "State" property in the
Modem interface is also updated (Registered->Searching) right away.
2) If the modem *is* connected and we get a 3GPP registration update
from MM_MODEM_3GPP_REGISTRATION_STATE_HOME to
MM_MODEM_3GPP_REGISTRATION_STATE_SEARCHING, "RegistrationState" in the
3GPP interface is updated right away, _but_ for the "State" property in
the Modem interface we wait up to 15s before updating it
(Connected->Disconnecting->Searching), in case we get a new registration
state update back to HOME.
--
Aleksander
_______________________________________________
networkmanager-list mailing list
networkmanager-list@gnome.org
https://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/networkmanager-list
