Well, experience in general w/ sFlow seems pretty thin all over :-) If the ProCurve sees the packets, it should report on them via sFlow to ntop. You won't have a complete picture of the sub networks, only the subset of traffic that the ProCurve sees.
-----Burton -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Victor Rodriguez Cortes Sent: Wednesday, May 17, 2006 6:30 AM To: [email protected] Subject: RE: [Ntop] SFlow and chain linked switches Hello, > This really isn't an ntop question ... It belongs with the switch > vendor. Because it's dependent on their implementation of sFlow and > (more importantly) on what 'chain-linked' is and how it's implemented. Sorry for the OT, I just thought that someone here may have experience with this kind of setup. > Within the realm of standard Ethernet and tcp/ip, the 'procurve' > switch in your diagram will never see packets local to either of the > 'non-sFlow' switches, so it wouldn't be able to report ANYTHING about > them. That's correct: if the traffic remains within any "non-sFlow" switches I won't see anything. But if the traffic is like this: Computer1 --> non s-Flow switch -> Procurve Switch -> gateway Computer2 --> Would I be able to distinguishing from which computer the traffic comes from using sFlow at the Procurve switch? Thanks a lot, Victor. > -----Burton > > -----Original Message----- > From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf > Of Victor Rodriguez Cortes Sent: Tuesday, May 16, 2006 10:21 AM To: > [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [Ntop] SFlow and chain linked > switches > > Hello, > > I'm new to the list and maybe someone has some experience with this > and could give me some advice. I sent this questions to the Misc list, > but I didn't received any reply yet. I hope that someone here may help > me. > > I would like to know what kind of information would SFlow give me > from a chain- linked switch that does NOT support SFlow. The network > would be something like this (sorry, I'm too bad drawing with > letters!): > > > Gateway > | > Procurve 2800 > | | > Non-sflow switchA Non-slow switchB > | | > Network devices Network devices > > > For some systems (printers, voip phones, some departments...) I do > not need the performance of one Procurve's Gb port, so I would use > those ports for other systems and use a different switch to give > network access to less performance-hungry devices. It's basically a > matter of cost per port, trying to avoid buying 2 or more ProCurve and > reuse some basic switches that I have right now. > > - Would I see real information for traffic that comes from / goes to > systems connected to the Non-sflow switches? Obviously all traffic > would be detected on the Procurve port that has switchA and switchB > connected to, but I suppose that I should get the IP address of each > system and be able of identify each one through it (as is there was > just one system with many IP addresses). > > - Would I be able of getting real traffic stats from those systems? > > - Would all this work if the switches are connected with a 2Gb trunk? > > Many thanks in advance, > Victor. > _______________________________________________ Ntop mailing list [email protected] http://listgateway.unipi.it/mailman/listinfo/ntop _______________________________________________ Ntop mailing list [email protected] http://listgateway.unipi.it/mailman/listinfo/ntop
