David> By default policy, I presume you mean that the user has declined to
David> express what should be done when certain networks are encountered.
David> In effect, the user either skipped that part of the install, or he
David> JumpStarted with no explicit network configuration.

Yes, a scenario more or less like that.


David> ... what's the use case?  I gather it's the data center ...

Primarily but not exclusively.

David> ... which is presumably using JumpStart.

We'd like to think that, but there's also the "I just got this big box and
plugged it in; let's boot it up" scenario.


David> If so, what services are we supposed to offer?  Just ssh?  Wouldn't
David> that require the user to log in and configure what services to offer?

I'm not following: if JumpStart is used, then we do whatever the profile
says; otherwise, we do whatever the Solaris default is.

David> Wouldn't it be better to just require that the user configure the
David> network during the JumpStart?

It might well make our life easier, but per above, I'm not sure if we can
require that.


David> I'd think that we should decline to participate in any wireless
David> networks unless directed to do so by the user...

Sorry for not providing context earlier, but I completely agree.  There is
another design thread, which I expect to be published here very soon, which
makes this clear.


David> Note that I think concepts like plumbing are really implementation
David> details that should not be allowed to muddy the user experience
David> scenarios.

I think I agree, but I don't see your point, so I'm not sure.

-- John

http://blogs.sun.com/jbeck

Reply via email to