Rene Herman wrote:
Timothy Miller wrote:

Please have a look at the feature spec and comment on it so I can make sure I haven't missed something imporant that needs to be in there:

http://opengraphics.gitk.com/open%20graphics%20spec.pdf

I also need to update the main page, and comments on that are welcome also.


[ note: http://opengraphics.gitk.com/open_graphics_spec.pdf instead ]

I notice it's still explicit about AGP 4x. As I commented earlier, I personally would on my current machine need AGP 2x compatibility. AGP 1.0 is 1x and 2x, AGP 2.0 is 1x, 2x and 4x and AGP 3.0 is 4x and 8x so I guess that's saying that I need it to be AGP 1.0 or 2.0. The 4x implies 2.0 and 3.0 so there's a nice overlap at AGP 2.0 ...

I forgot about that, and you're right. I guess we'll be doing 2.0.

Will an AGP 2.0 board work in a 3.0 slot?


Moreover, I'm going to have a go again at convincing you that a version with a regular old VGA connector is worth it.

I don't see why an extra connector is needed when there will be an adaptor from the DVI-I port to VGA. The adaptor isn't going to impact signal quality.


The target market for this card consist not of hardcore gaming and graphics types, but people sensitive to picture quality are, I have noticed, explicitly not excluded. Many of those are likely to still have a good quality analog VGA monitor as opposed to a flat panel, since at least at the same price, today's monitors are of significantly higher quality than today's panels. Especially with respect to color.

We're in ATC. We have strict 2 to 3 picosecond rise-and-fall requirements for a 357 Mhz pixel clock. We know about picture quality. That being said, we are unfamiliar with the DAC we're looking at, so we can't be sure it's so great. We do, however, know how to lay out a board properly with correct electrical isolation, etc.


Another, overlapping, part of the market is obviously open source enthousiasts, probably runing Linux. A panel only has a _chance_ of looking good in its native resolution meaning that a plain VGA console is not something you want to display on them.

By "plain VGA", do you mean the port or the resolution? The VGA resolution is only useful for boot (or pre-boot if you're using fbconsole). The port is part of DVI-I.


But, considering the frequency with which the linux framebuffer layer is broken beyond any hope of functionality in development kernels, there might again be a significantly higher percentage of "plain ol' VGA" people in this crowd then elsewhere.

On old machines, which you are also targetting considering the inclusion of PCI, a matching old analog VGA is even more likely.

Now, ofcourse, an adapter works, but someone on this list pointed out they are bulky and quality-wise, any adapter is a prime opportunity for signal degradation. I haven't bought high quality cables for nothing...

They're not that bulky. And while I'm sure there are plenty of lousy ones out there, I am confident that we can find a good one to provide.


Old VGA is, I assume, cheaper to produce and you can sell at the same price, but I really want it. Heck, I'd pay _extra_ if I didn't have to mess around with adapters.

We need one single version of the board that meets as many different needs as possible. This is the ONLY way keep the cost down to something reasonable. Volume is everything.
_______________________________________________
Open-graphics mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.duskglow.com/mailman/listinfo/open-graphics
List service provided by Duskglow Consulting, LLC (www.duskglow.com)

Reply via email to