Netbeans no longer defaults to creating Ant based projects unlike years ago & there has been, IIRC, some talk on further retiring support for it and Maven works just fine provided that you use the JavaFX Maven plugin*.

Still maybe worth fixing since support isn't completely removed and there may be cases where one might want to download and use a JavaFX SDK dist.


* the situation with IDE JavaFX support is complicated due to a project created outside Netbeans not set up with hacks Netbeans needs for green run button but there is an in-IDE option to do javafx:run and intellij needs a custom run action created to do javafx:run AFAIK, but I digress.


On 6/14/2021 1:15 PM, Kevin Rushforth wrote:
We deliver a set of modular jars in the lib directory of the standalone JavaFX SDK. We also deliver src.zip for use by IDEs into that same directory. If you add the lib directory to your application's module path in your IDE, it will try to load src.zip as if it were a jar file, and will fail. This is a pain point for developers using the SDK. This problem has been raised on the mailing list a couple of times, and I think it's time to fix it. This issue is tracked in JBS by JDK-8258499 [1].

I propose to move the src.zip file from the lib directory to the top directory of the SDK.

Alternatively, we could create a new directory for src.zip (either a sibling of lib or sub-directory under lib). However, I think it would be easier to find in the top dir of the SDK, and I don't see the need for a new directory just to hold src.zip.

Before I create the PR and the associated CSR, I'd like to hear developer's opinions on this.

-- Kevin

[1] https://bugs.openjdk.java.net/browse/JDK-8258499

Reply via email to