For purposes of supporting multiple backends for Identity (multiple LDAP, mix 
of LDAP and SQL, federation, etc) Keystone is planning to increase the maximum 
size of the USER_ID field from an upper limit of 64 to an upper limit of 255. 
This change would not impact any currently assigned USER_IDs (they would remain 
in the old simple UUID format), however, new USER_IDs would be increased to 
include the IDP identifier (e.g. USER_ID@@IDP_IDENTIFIER). 

There is the obvious concern that projects are utilizing (and storing) the 
user_id in a field that cannot accommodate the increased upper limit. Before 
this change is merged in, it is important for the Keystone team to understand 
if there are any places that would be overflowed by the increased size.

The review that would implement this change in size is 
https://review.openstack.org/#/c/74214 and is actively being worked on/reviewed.

I have already spoken with the Nova team, and a single instance has been 
identified that would require a migration (that will have a fix proposed for 
the I3 timeline). 

If there are any other known locations that would have issues with an increased 
USER_ID size, or any concerns with this change to USER_ID format, please 
respond so that the issues/concerns can be addressed.  Again, the plan is not 
to change current USER_IDs but that new ones could be up to 255 characters in 
length.

Cheers,
Morgan Fainberg
—
Morgan Fainberg
Principal Software Engineer
Core Developer, Keystone
m...@metacloud.com
_______________________________________________
OpenStack-dev mailing list
OpenStack-dev@lists.openstack.org
http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-dev

Reply via email to