On 3 June 2015 at 14:09, Thierry Carrez <thie...@openstack.org> wrote: > John Garbutt wrote: >> Given we are thinking Liberty is moving to semantic versioning, maybe >> it could look like this: >> * 12.0.1 (liberty-1) will have some features (hopefully), and will be a tag >> * 12.0.2.dev1 is the first commit after 12.0.1 and does not get a tag >> * 12.0.2.dev1234 would be the 1234th commit after 12.0.1 >> * 12.0.2 (liberty-2) will also contain features >> * 12.0.3 (liberty-3) is focused on priority features (given the current plan) >> * 12.1 is Liberty release is just bug fixes on 12.0.3 >> * 13.0.0.dev1 would be the first commit to open M > > The current thinking on the release management team would be to do > something like this for projects that are still doing milestone-based > development: > > * 12.0.0b1 (liberty-1) > * 12.0.0b2 (liberty-2) > * 12.0.0b3 (liberty-3) > * 12.0.0rc1 (RC1) > * 12.0.0 is Liberty release > > I think assuming people can tell 12.0.1 is an alpha and 12.1 is a > release that is just bug fixes over 12.0.3 is a bit crazy...
We go to great lengths to ensure folks can upgrade from b1 -> b3 and b2 -> release. I am really looking for a way to advertise that, incase its useful. ... But it could/will be missing aligned docs and translations. So maybe its not enough different from beta... needs more thought. > The alternative would be to go full intermediary releases and do: > > * 11.1.0 > * 11.2.0 > * 11.2.1 > * 11.3.0 > * 11.3.1 (oh! that happens to also be the "liberty" release!) > * 11.4.0 > > I don't think we can maintain an middle ground. I think that could still work. But I was attempting to skip the exception of creating 11.2.1 just because 11.2.0.dev42 fixes a critical bug present in 11.2.1. You would have to wait for the next (time bound) release to get the extra bug fixes and features. Thanks, John __________________________________________________________________________ OpenStack Development Mailing List (not for usage questions) Unsubscribe: openstack-dev-requ...@lists.openstack.org?subject:unsubscribe http://lists.openstack.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/openstack-dev
