Hi Frank, Phil, list! Thanks for your opinions. I find very useful sssad because it's vanilla PD and that's good for my purpose. Anyway memento looks more general and really powerfull. Really great job Frank!!!
I will get into this state-saving libraries which looks really useful. Thanks for your attention! On 12/04/2008, Phil Stone <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Hi Raul, > > I've used both sssad (in [polywavesynth], as you noted) and memento, and > they are similar in many ways, with a few important differences. sssad, as > Frank pointed out, works in vanilla PD. In my opinion, it's slightly easier > to work with than memento, but Frank has done most of the work for you in > both cases. > > I found that I really like [pool]*, and the power it gives to memento. At > the same time, I wish the hierarchy were organized differently (do an > archive search for a thread about this). Also, Luke Iannini has done some > enhancements to memento (search for "semento"), so there's life in this line > of state-saving for Pd. > > I'm actually using a hybrid of both currently -- I'm using sssad for the > voice presets of [polywavesynth], and memento for storing the configuration > of my entire setup. > > To be even less help, :-) I currently use both libraries for OSC. I'm > gradually switching over to mrpeach OSC, because it seems solid and well > designed. I've never had trouble with oscx, though, and have used both > heavily. > > You're right, it's kind of crazy, an embarrassment of riches. But it's > part of the charm of PD for me; it's like a big kit, where you can put > together whatever you want out of a multitude of components. If you add > components carefully, you can put some reliable stuff together. > > > Phil Stone > www.pkstonemusic.com > > > * as Frank also pointed out, [pool] could also be used for the backing > store to sssad, which is an interesting avenue for exploration, but it > already is all wired up in memento. I think [pool] should be in vanilla PD, > by the way. > > > raul diaz wrote: > > > Hi Frank, list! > > > > I'm getting into memento because I'm trying to implemet a state saving > > utility for my tr-909 emulation patch. > > I've taken a look to your RRadical Pd tutorial and I have use your > > examples from Pd extended help. > > But looking at Polywavesynth patch by Phil Stone, I've taken a look to > > his state saving stuffs based on sssad, and that looks pretty much easy and > > suitable for my purpose. > > > > So, now I'm a little bit confuse with so many libraries. I would like to > > know what's the purpose of each of this libraries (memento, rrradical, > > sssad), its applications, advantages, and inconvenients, and which of this > > is better for my purpose. > > > > Another question is about OSC libraries. I've used oscx succesfully but > > I've seen Polywavesynth used Mr Peach OSC objects (which seems pretty > > usefull). What's the difference between both? > > > > My head is full of apparently-same-purpose libraries!!! > > > > Saludos! > > > > -- > > Raul Diaz Poblete > > ************************* > > [EMAIL PROTECTED] <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > Barcelona [Spain] > > ------------------------------------------------------------------------ > > > > _______________________________________________ > > PD-list@iem.at mailing list > > UNSUBSCRIBE and account-management -> > > http://lists.puredata.info/listinfo/pd-list > > > > > > -- Raul Diaz Poblete ************************* [EMAIL PROTECTED] Barcelona [Spain]
_______________________________________________ PD-list@iem.at mailing list UNSUBSCRIBE and account-management -> http://lists.puredata.info/listinfo/pd-list