To whom...., Yet again, Louis Proyect is deliberately trying to undermine and ruin *another* discussion list. I have been on four lists that he has done this too and the pattern is always identical. He finds some scapegoat and then makes wilder and wilder charges until he gets people worked up. The Freedom of Information Act is his new cudgel. He threatens to denounce people as Vichy collaborators or some idiocy until he gets his way and the list capitulates. C. Proyect has a wonderful intellect and is a great contributor to the lists he's on - until he starts the inevitable nonsense. I'm not sure whether he has the nerve to do the same to Doug Henwood's new list, but I am sure he would be much happier if we all would simply face our destiny and meekly fall under Proyect's "moderation". Only in ProyectReich is the thinking pure. When C. Proyect is contributing to a list he could not be more helpful to Marxist discussion on the Internet. When he engages in this stuff he could not be more destructive if he was in the direct employ of the CIA which, given his history, is not so utterly preposterous as it might otherwise seem, although I'm quite sure that the behavior is simply rooted in childishness. peace