Louis, But this is what troubles me about all this: isn't the argument you are advancing an ideological reason to be opposed to the thesis at hand rather than a social scientific one? Are we to dismiss arguments because of the way they are used by modernization theorists? Andrew you must be new here. mbs
- Re: Capitalism as slavery and coloniali... Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Re: Capitalism as slavery and ... Louis Proyect
- Re: Re: Re: Capitalism as slav... Jim Devine
- Re: Re: Re: Re: Capitalism as ... Louis Proyect
- Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Capitalism... Jim Devine
- Re: Capitalism as slavery and ... Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Capitalism as slavery and ... Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Re: Capitalism as slavery ... Louis Proyect
- Re: Re: Capitalism as slavery ... Doug Henwood
- Women & the Origins of Cap... Yoshie Furuhashi
- RE: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Max Sawicky
- RE: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Forstater, Mathew
- RE: RE: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Austin, Andrew
- Re: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Louis Proyect
- RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Austin, Andrew
- Re: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Louis Proyect
- RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Charles Brown
- RE: RE: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Austin, Andrew
- RE: Re: Capitalism as slavery and colonialism Forstater, Mathew