> I agree with Jim. That's basically the crux of the debate: what is > the most important causal mechanism that gave rise to capitalism, > i.e., M-C-M'? Not culture, not climate, not environment, not > geography, not demography (understood in the Malthusian sense), not > quantitative growth of markets & towns, but class struggles that > gradually led to free labor & eventually to wage labor. > > Yoshie no books, no research, no debate, no history. just jim
- Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Reply to Ellen Meik... Jim Devine
- Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood, ... Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood, part 1 Michael Perelman
- Re: Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood, p... Stephen E Philion
- Re: Re: Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksin... Louis Proyect
- Re: Re: Re: Re: Reply to Ellen... Stephen E Philion
- Re: Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksin... Louis Proyect
- Re: Re: Re: Reply to Ellen Mei... Stephen E Philion
- Re: Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood, p... Jim Devine
- Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood, part 1 Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood, part 1 Ricardo Duchesne
- Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood, part 1 Jim Devine
- Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood, part ... Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood, part 1 Yoshie Furuhashi
- Re: Re: Reply to Ellen Meiksins Wood, part 1 Louis Proyect