Greetings Economists, On Aug 17, 2006, at 6:03 PM, Louis Proyect wrote:
I wonder if you think that you have achieved some victory by forcing Doug and I to walk away from engaging with you.
Doyle; I would not say the exchanges as engaged so far, points at how to understand dialectic. What is the resolution? How do you do that? This is a set up to blame Yoshie in my view. You want to have an argument but you don't want to resolve it somehow. Why not think about that? I think just writing emails leads to not much. What's a good combination of thoughts lead to? At the very least the Wiki's provide a model of how to evolve a common document. Just posting an opinion back and forth gives the impression that the individuals particular self expression is the point of resolution. The list audience being some sort of receptacle for the 'show'. I think it much more positive to propose a way to synthesize contradictory positions. As to Yoshie not backing down. I think that is just grand, myself. Jolly good Yoshie. Jolly good. thanks, Doyle
