This and other RFCs are available on the web at
http://dev.perl.org/rfc/
=head1 TITLE
Perl should have a print operator
=head1 VERSION
Maintainer: Jon Ericson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Date: 5 August 2000
Last-Modified: 30 August 2000
Mailing List: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Version: 3
Number: 39
Status: Developing
=head1 ABSTRACT
Perl supplies an operator for line input - angle brackets. This is no
analogous operator for output. I propose "inverse angle brackets":
>"Print this line.\n"<;
=head1 DESCRIPTION
=head2 Easy things should be easy
Output is already easy in Perl, but it could be easier. For one thing,
it doesn't nest well in statements:
while (<>){
print;
push @line, $_;
};
This could be written:
push @line, >$_< while <>;
Printing to STDOUT and some other file ala tee(1):
print $fh >"This also goes to stdout.\n"<;
Another problem with print is that the ()s are optional. perlop points
out the following traps:
print $foo, exit;
print ($foo & 255) + 1, "\n";
They could be correctly written as:
>$foo<, exit;
>($foo & 255) + 1, "\n"<;
=head2 Ugly as a virtue
A representative comment of this RFC is "Ick!" -- Jonathan Scott Duff
<[EMAIL PROTECTED]> This RFC doesn't mind (nor does its maintainer).
The print operator should be quick and dirty - used as an afterthought
or side-effect. When you are looking for it, the print operator should
stick out. When you are looking for something else (and have gotten
used to the syntax), it should blend into the sea of punctuation. Do
you remember when you first saw <FH>, or i++ (in C)? Compact syntax
with side-effects, such as the print operator, should be ugly.
This operator _will_ be misused, just as `STRING` (qx/STRING/) is
misused. It will cause confusion just as the conditional operator (?:)
causes confusion. It will be as jarring as =~ is to those who have
never seen it. Perl is operator rich whether you like it or not.
=head2 print will still be there
Not all output is suited for inverse angle brackets. Most output will
still go through print. Prints to files should use 'print FH LIST' so
that the return value can be checked (and the filehandle specified).
Long documents should be printed with the expanded form on their own
lines so that they are emphasised. 'print "Hello world\n";' should
remain the canonical 'first Perl script'. We still need print for
practical and stylistic reasons.
=head1 IMPLEMENTATION
Let:
>LIST<
print LIST to the default output filehandle (normally STDOUT) and return
LIST. It should have the same precedence as other list operators
=head2 Migration from Perl 5
Inverse angle brackets are currently a syntax error, so no translation
will be needed.
=head1 Changes
=over
=item v3
Added "Developing" status
Operator now returns its arguments
Changed DESCRIPTION to respond to concerns voiced about previous
versions
=item v2
Changed title
Added other symbols section
Added migration section
Added RFC 51 reference
=back
=head1 REFERENCES
RFC 2: Request For New Pragma: Implicit
RFC 34: Angle brackets should not be used for file globbing
RFC 51: Angle brackets should accept filenames and lists
perlop
perlfunc/print
perldebug/"Debugger Commands"/{p,x}