Thanks for your reply. I have also had the ‘you have no works by’
message as well. So I shouldn't waste time in tweaking my Artist / Album
Artist tags then but focusing on the album names?

What is the correct response to ‘I need the name of the artist’?

Steve


philchillbill wrote: 
> The issue with classical music is that there are no standardised tag
> schemes for all the details so people usually invent their own.
> MediaServer just works with AlbumArtist/Band, TrackArtist/Artist, Album,
> Title, Genre and Year as tags. Amazon has a long list of 'known' artists
> to match against when you say something to Alexa, but not for classical
> artists. Alexa doesn't really 'hear' you without context. If you ask her
> to tell you a lightbulb joke, she first hears joke and then matches
> lightbulb against her joke categories. So there is context. Same with
> music. When you ask her to play an album by XXX, from the context of
> play combined with album she goes, aha, the XXX must be an artist so
> let's check my known-artist list. That list is unfortunately very
> unsuited to classical music. The "MediaServer can't help you with that"
> is indicative of her not even recognising your artist as being in the
> Amazon-curated artist category, otherwise you would have been told "you
> have no works by XXX" which is a different message that I generate based
> on matching against your library.
> 
> So I'm not sure Alexa will ever bring joy to classical lovers, whether
> via this skill or otherwise. I'd say your best bet is to tag your albums
> so that the match can occur without needing the artist name. The skill
> itself uses fuzzy matching, but it can only match against what LMS
> returns and LMS unfortunately does not do fuzzy or metaphonic matching.


------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shozzer's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=58726
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=111016

_______________________________________________
plugins mailing list
plugins@lists.slimdevices.com
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/plugins

Reply via email to