Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel On Nov 19, 5:24 pm, "M.A. Johnson" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Patriotismby Ron Paul > Before the U.S. House of Representatives, May 22, 2007 > Madam Speaker, for some, patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel. For > others, it means dissent against a government's abuse of the people's rights. > I have never met a politician in Washington or any American, for that matter, > who chose to be called unpatriotic. Nor have I met anyone who did not believe > he wholeheartedly supported our troops, wherever they may be. > What I have heard all too frequently from various individuals are sharp > accusations that, because their political opponents disagree with them on the > need for foreign military entanglements, they were unpatriotic, un-American > evildoers deserving contempt. > The original American patriots were those individuals brave enough to resist > with force the oppressive power of King George. I accept the definition of > patriotism as that effort to resist oppressive state power. > The true patriot is motivated by a sense of responsibility and out of > self-interest for himself, his family, and the future of his country to > resist government abuse of power. He rejects the notion that patriotism means > obedience to the state. Resistance need not be violent, but the civil > disobedience that might be required involves confrontation with the state and > invites possible imprisonment. > Peaceful, nonviolent revolutions against tyranny have been every bit as > successful as those involving military confrontation. Mahatma Gandhi and Dr. > Martin Luther King, Jr., achieved great political successes by practicing > nonviolence, and yet they suffered physically at the hands of the state. But > whether the resistance against government tyrants is nonviolent or physically > violent, the effort to overthrow state oppression qualifies as true > patriotism. > True patriotism today has gotten a bad name, at least from the government and > the press. Those who now challenge the unconstitutional methods of imposing > an income tax on us, or force us to use a monetary system designed to serve > the rich at the expense of the poor are routinely condemned. These American > patriots are sadly looked down upon by many. They are never praised as > champions of liberty as Gandhi and Martin Luther King have been. > Liberals, who withhold their taxes as a protest against war, are vilified as > well, especially by conservatives. Unquestioned loyalty to the state is > especially demanded in times of war. Lack of support for a war policy is said > to be unpatriotic. Arguments against a particular policy that endorses a war, > once it is started, are always said to be endangering the troops in the > field. This, they blatantly claim, is unpatriotic, and all dissent must stop. > Yet, it is dissent from government policies that defines the true patriot and > champion of liberty. > It is conveniently ignored that the only authentic way to best support the > troops is to keep them out of dangerous undeclared no-win wars that are > politically inspired. Sending troops off to war for reasons that are not > truly related to national security and, for that matter, may even damage our > security, is hardly a way to patriotically support the troops. > Who are the true patriots, those who conform or those who protest against > wars without purpose? How can it be said that blind support for a war, no > matter how misdirected the policy, is the duty of a patriot? > Randolph Bourne said that, "War is the health of the state.'' With war, he > argued, the state thrives. Those who believe in the powerful state see war as > an opportunity. Those who mistrust the people and the market for solving > problems have no trouble promoting a "war psychology'' to justify the > expansive role of the state. This includes the role the Federal Government > plays in our lives, as well as in our economic transactions. > Certainly, the neoconservative belief that we have a moral obligation to > spread American values worldwide through force justifies the conditions of > war in order to rally support at home for the heavy hand of government. It is > through this policy, it should surprise no one, that our liberties are > undermined. The economy becomes overextended, and our involvement worldwide > becomes prohibited. Out of fear of being labeled unpatriotic, most of the > citizens become compliant and accept the argument that some loss of liberty > is required to fight the war in order to remain safe. > This is a bad trade-off, in my estimation, especially when done in the name > of patriotism. Loyalty to the state and to autocratic leaders is substituted > for true patriotism; that is, a willingness to challenge the state and defend > the country, the people and the culture. The more difficult the times, the > stronger the admonition comes that the leaders be not criticized. > Because the crisis atmosphere of war supports the growth of the state, any > problem invites an answer by declaring war, even on social and economic > issues. This elicits patriotism in support of various government solutions, > while enhancing the power of the state. Faith in government coercion and a > lack of understanding of how free societies operate encourages big-government > liberals and big-government conservatives to manufacture a war psychology to > demand political loyalty for domestic policy just as is required in foreign > affairs. > The long-term cost in dollars spent and liberties lost is neglected as > immediate needs are emphasized. It is for this reason that we have multiple > perpetual wars going on simultaneously. Thus, the war on drugs, the war > against gun ownership, the war against poverty, the war against illiteracy, > the war against terrorism, as well as our foreign military entanglements are > endless. > All this effort promotes the growth of statism at the expense of liberty. A > government designed for a free society should do the opposite, prevent the > growth of statism and preserve liberty. > Once a war of any sort is declared, the message is sent out not to object or > you will be declared unpatriotic. Yet, we must not forget that the true > patriot is the one who protests in spite of the consequences. Condemnation or > ostracism or even imprisonment may result. > Nonviolent protesters of the Tax Code are frequently imprisoned, whether they > are protesting the code's unconstitutionality or the war that the tax > revenues are funding. Resisters to the military draft or even to Selective > Service registration are threatened and imprisoned for challenging this > threat to liberty. > Statism depends on the idea that the government owns us and citizens must > obey. Confiscating the fruits of our labor through the income tax is crucial > to the health of the state. The draft, or even the mere existence of the > Selective Service, emphasizes that we will march off to war at the state's > pleasure. > A free society rejects all notions of involuntary servitude, whether by draft > or the confiscation of the fruits of our labor through the personal income > tax. A more sophisticated and less well-known technique for enhancing the > state is the manipulation and transfer of wealth through the fiat monetary > system operated by the secretive Federal Reserve. > Protesters against this unconstitutional system of paper money are considered > unpatriotic criminals and at times are imprisoned for their beliefs. The fact > that, according to the Constitution, only gold and silver are legal tender > and paper money outlawed matters little. The principle of patriotism is > turned on its head. Whether it's with regard to the defense of welfare > spending at home, confiscatory income tax, or an immoral monetary system or > support for a war fought under false pretense without a legal declaration, > the defenders of liberty and the Constitution are portrayed as unpatriotic, > while those who support these programs are seen as the patriots. > If there is a war going on, supporting the state's effort to win the war is > expected at all costs, no dissent. The real problem is that those who love > the state too often advocate policies that lead to military action. At home, > they are quite willing to produce a crisis atmosphere and claim a war is > needed to solve the problem. Under these conditions, the people are more > willing to bear the burden of paying for the war and to carelessly sacrifice > liberties, which they are told is necessary. > The last 6 years have been quite beneficial to the health of the state, which > comes at the expense of personal liberty. Every enhanced unconstitutional > power of the state can only be achieved at the expense of individual liberty. > Even though in every war in which we have been engaged civil liberties have > suffered, some have been restored after the war ended, but never completely. > That has resulted in a steady erosion of our liberties over the past 200 > years. Our government was originally designed to protect our liberties, but > it has now, instead, become the usurper of those liberties. > We currently live in the most difficult of times for guarding against an > expanding central government with a steady erosion of our freedoms. We are > continually being reminded that 9/11 has changed everything. > Unfortunately, the policy that needed most to be changed, that is, our policy > of foreign interventionism, has only been expanded. There is no pretense any > longer that a policy of humility in foreign affairs, without being the > world's policemen and engaging in nation building, is worthy of consideration. > We now live in a post-9/11 America where our government is going to make us > safe no matter what it takes. We are expected to grin and bear it and adjust > to every loss of our liberties in the name of patriotism and security. > Though the majority of Americans initially welcomed the declared effort to > make us safe, and we are willing to sacrifice for the cause, more and more > Americans are now becoming concerned about civil liberties being needlessly > and dangerously sacrificed. > The problem is that the Iraq war continues to drag on, and a real danger of > it spreading exists. There is no evidence that a truce will soon be signed in > Iraq or in the war on terror or the war on drugs. Victory is not even > definable. If Congress is incapable of declaring an official war, it is > impossible to know when it will end. We have been fully forewarned that the > world conflict in which we are now engaged will last a long, long time. > The war mentality and the pervasive fear of an unidentified enemy allows for > a steady erosion of our liberties, and, with this, our respect for > self-reliance and confidence is lost. Just think of the self-sacrifice and > the humiliation we go through at the airport screening process on a routine > basis. Though there is no scientific evidence of any likelihood of liquids > and gels being mixed on an airplane to make a bomb, billions of dollars are > wasted throwing away toothpaste and hair spray, and searching old women in > wheelchairs. > Our enemies say boo, and we jump, we panic, and then we punish ourselves. We > are worse than a child being afraid of the dark. But in a way, the fear of > indefinable terrorism is based on our inability to admit the truth about why > there is a desire by a small number of angry radical Islamists to kill > Americans. It is certainly not because they are jealous of our wealth and > freedoms. > We fail to realize that the extremists, willing to sacrifice their own lives > to kill their enemies, do so out of a sense of weakness and desperation over > real and perceived attacks on their way of life, their religion, their > country, and their natural resources. Without the conventional diplomatic or > military means to retaliate against these attacks, and an unwillingness of > their own government to address the issue, they resort to the desperation > tactic of suicide terrorism. Their anger toward their own governments, which > they believe are coconspirators with the American Government, is equal to or > greater than that directed toward us. > These errors in judgment in understanding the motive of the enemy and the > constant fear that is generated have brought us to this crisis where our > civil liberties and privacy are being steadily eroded in the name of > preserving national security. > We may be the economic and the military giant of the world, but the effort to > stop this war on our liberties here at home in the name of patriotism is > being lost. > The erosion of our personal liberties started long before 9/11, but 9/11 > accelerated the process. There are many things that motivate those who pursue > this course, both well-intentioned and malevolent, but it would not happen if > the people remained vigilant, understood the importance of individual rights, > and were unpersuaded that a need for security justifies the sacrifice for > liberty, even if it is just now and then. > The true patriot challenges the state when the state embarks on enhancing its > power at the expense of the individual. Without a better understanding and a > greater determination to rein in the state, the rights of Americans that > resulted from the revolutionary break from the British and the writing of the > Constitution will disappear. > The record since September 11th is dismal. Respect for liberty has rapidly > deteriorated. Many of the new laws passed after 9/11 had, in fact, been > proposed long before that attack. The political atmosphere after that attack > simply made it more possible to pass such legislation. The fear generated by > 9/11 became an opportunity for those seeking to promote the power of the > state domestically, just as it served to falsely justify the long-planned > invasion of Iraq. > The war mentality was generated by the Iraq war in combination with the > constant drumbeat of fear at home. Al Qaeda and Osama bin Laden, who is now > likely residing in Pakistan, our supposed ally, are ignored, as our troops > fight and die in Iraq and are made easier targets for the terrorists in their > backyard. While our leaders constantly use the mess we created to further > justify the erosion of our constitutional rights here at home, we forget > about our own borders and support the inexorable move toward global > government, hardly a good plan for America. > The accelerated attacks on liberty started quickly after 9/11. Within weeks, > the PATRIOT Act was overwhelmingly passed by Congress. Though the final > version was unavailable up to a few hours before the vote, no Member had > sufficient time to study it. Political fear of not doing something, even > something harmful, drove the Members of Congress to not question the > contents, and just voted for it. A little less freedom for a little more > perceived safety was considered a fair trade-off, and the majority of > Americans applauded. > The PATRIOT Act, though, severely eroded the system of checks and balances by > giving the government the power to spy on law-abiding citizens without > judicial supervision. The several provisions that undermine the liberties of > all Americans include sneak-and-peek searches, a broadened and more vague > definition of domestic terrorism, allowing the FBI access to library and > bookstore records without search warrants or probable cause, easier FBI > initiation of wiretaps and searches, as well as roving wiretaps, easier > access to information on American citizens' use of the Internet, and easier > access to e-mail and financial records of all American citizens. > The attack on privacy has not relented over the past 6 years. The Military > Commissions Act is a particularly egregious piece of legislation and, if not > repealed, will change America for the worse as the powers unconstitutionally > granted to the executive branch are used and abused. This act grants > excessive authority to use secretive military commissions outside of places > where active hostilities are going on. The Military Commissions Act permits > torture, arbitrary detention of American citizens as unlawful enemy > combatants at the full discretion of the President and without the right of > habeas corpus, and warrantless searches by the NSA. It also gives to the > President the power to imprison individuals based on secret testimony. > Since 9/11, Presidential signing statements designating portions of > legislation that the President does not intend to follow, though not legal > under the Constitution, have enormously multiplied. Unconstitutional > Executive Orders are numerous and mischievous and need to be curtailed. > Extraordinary rendition to secret prisons around the world have been widely > engaged in, though obviously extralegal. > A growing concern in the post-9/11 environment is the Federal Government's > list of potential terrorists based on secret evidence. Mistakes are made, and > sometimes it is virtually impossible to get one's name removed even though > the accused is totally innocent of any wrongdoing. > A national ID card is now in the process of being implemented. It is called > the REAL ID card, and it is tied to our Social Security numbers and our State > driver's license. If REAL ID is not stopped, it will become a national > driver's license ID for all Americans. We will be required to carry our > papers. > Some of the least-noticed and least-discussed changes in the law were the > changes made to the Insurrection Act of 1807 and to posse comitatus by the > Defense Authorization Act of 2007. These changes pose a threat to the > survival of our Republic by giving the President the power to declare martial > law for as little reason as to restore public order. The 1807 act severely > restricted the President in his use of the military within the United States > borders, and the Posse Comitatus Act of 1878 strengthened these restrictions > with strict oversight by Congress. The new law allows the President to > circumvent the restrictions of both laws. The Insurrection Act has now become > the "Enforcement of the Laws to Restore Public Order Act.'' This is hardly a > title that suggests that the authors cared about or understood the nature of > a constitutional Republic. > Now, martial law can be declared not just for insurrection, but also for > natural disasters, public health reasons, terrorist attacks or incidents, or > for the vague reason called "other conditions.'' The President can call up > the National Guard without congressional approval or the Governors' approval, > and even send these State Guard troops into other States. > The American Republic is in remnant status. The stage is set for our country > eventually devolving into a military dictatorship, and few seem to care. > These precedent-setting changes in the law are extremely dangerous and will > change American jurisprudence forever if not revised. The beneficial results > of our revolt against the King's abuses are about to be eliminated, and few > Members of Congress and few Americans are aware of the seriousness of the > situation. Complacency and fear drive our legislation without any serious > objection by our elected leaders. Sadly, though, those few who do object to > this self-evident trend away from personal liberty and empire-building > overseas are portrayed as unpatriotic and uncaring. > Though welfare and socialism always fails, opponents of them are said to lack > compassion. Though opposition to totally unnecessary war should be the only > moral position, the rhetoric is twisted to claim that patriots who oppose the > war are not supporting the troops. The cliché "Support the Troops'' is > incessantly used as a substitute for the unacceptable notion of supporting > the policy, no matter how flawed it may be. > Unsound policy can never help the troops. Keeping the troops out of harm's > way and out of wars unrelated to our national security is the only real way > of protecting the troops. With this understanding, just who can claim the > title of "patriot''? > Before the war in the Middle East spreads and becomes a world conflict for > which we will be held responsible, or the liberties of all Americans become > so suppressed we can no longer resist, much has to be done. Time is short, > but our course of action should be clear. Resistance to illegal and > unconstitutional usurpation of our rights is required. Each of us must choose > which course of action we should take: education, conventional political > action, or even peaceful civil disobedience to bring about necessary changes. > But let it not be said that we did nothing. Let not those who love the power > of the welfare/warfare state label the dissenters of authoritarianism as > unpatriotic or uncaring. Patriotism is more closely linked to dissent than it > is to conformity and a blind desire for safety and security. Understanding > the magnificent rewards of a free society makes us unbashful in its > promotion, fully realizing that maximum wealth is created and the greatest > chance for peace comes from a society respectful of individual liberty. --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups. For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum
* Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/ * It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls. * Read the latest breaking news, and more. -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
