Antiwar “Lefts” embrace ultra-right Republican candidate Ron Paul By Jerry White and Jeff Lincoln 22 January 2008
Over the last several months, a section of the antiwar protest movement in the US has turned with increasing enthusiasm towards the candidacy of Ron Paul, the long-time Republican Congressman from Texas, who is seeking his party’s presidential nomination. With a stable of leading Democratic and Republican candidates committed to the continued occupation of Iraq and extension of US military power around the world, Paul’s promotion of a “non- interventionist” US foreign policy and his criticisms of the Patriot Act and other attacks on civil liberties have won him support from a section of politically inexperienced students looking for a means to oppose the war. The Texas congressman’s maverick image has been further enhanced by the vitriol with which his fellow Republican candidates responded to comments Paul made during a debate in Iowa, when he said terrorism was chiefly a response to US meddling in the Middle East. This was followed by the decision of Fox News to exclude him from the debate on the eve of the New Hampshire primary. That Paul can be construed as an “antiwar candidate,” is a measure of how far to the right the American political and media establishment has moved. It is one thing, however, for the politically naïve to be fooled by his demagogy; it is quite another for ostensibly “left” commentators to deliberately conceal his reactionary politics and perpetuate the fraud that the former Libertarian Party candidate for president can be a catalyst for building a powerful antiwar movement. Take for example, Alexander Cockburn, who wrote in his regular column in the Nation magazine that Paul is “rock-solid against war and empire and the neo-liberal corporate state,” adding that the Texas Republican is “a principled fellow who’s won passionate support (and millions in modest cash contributions) from ordinary Americans.” Cockburn’s colleague Jeff Taylor, in a “Letter to a Liberal Friend” posted on the Counterpunch web site, argues that Paul’s right-wing policies will actually broaden the base of the antiwar movement, presumably because the working class can only be attracted on the basis of nationalism, xenophobia and other reactionary appeals. “Not only does Ron Paul represent Jeffersonian values usually termed ‘conservative’ or ‘libertarian’ today (fidelity to the Constitution, frugal government, states’ rights, Second Amendment, national sovereignty), but he is also a leading example of support for Jeffersonian positions nowadays described as ‘liberal’ or ‘leftist’ (e.g. opposition not only to the Iraq War but to war in general, anti-imperialism, ending the federal war on drugs, hostility to the Patriot Act and other violations of civil liberties). This accounts for the wide appeal of the Paul campaign. It’s precisely the sort of trans-ideological, cross-generational populist-libertarian- moralist coalition that I was hoping to see with a [Wisconsin Democratic Senator Russ] Feingold presidential campaign.” In “An Open Letter to the Antiwar Left: Ron Paul Deserves Our Attention,” posted on the Counterpunch web site, Joshua Frank, co- editor of DissidentVoice.org, continues along these lines, arguing that a viable antiwar movement can only be built by blurring the lines of left and right politics. “This is not about Rep. Paul as an individual per se, but about his grassroots following,” Frank writes. “He’s exciting many newcomers to the [antiwar] movement and that must be welcomed. We certainly don’t share the same views with all who have latched on to his campaign, but on the issue of the Iraq war we are in total agreement. One doesn’t have to be a member of the left to oppose empire.” Having long ago rejected the possibility or desirability of building a socialist alternative to the two-party system, and having worked for years in their failed efforts to push the Democratic Party to the left, Cockburn & Co. hope promoting Paul will be a more effective means of influencing the two-party system to end the war. As Frank put it, “Rep. Paul’s call to end the war needs to be supported...We need to monkey-wrench the war issue so the media and the big party candidates cannot ignore it.” The struggle against war cannot be successful by appealing to the powers-that-be. This war and the explosion of American militarism in general is not just the product of the circle of neo-conservatives in the White House but is deeply rooted in objective economic and historical conditions, above all the decline in the global position of American capitalism. There is a general consensus in both political parties that military power be used to reassert US hegemony over America’s economic rivals by seizing control of the strategic energy resources of the Middle East and Central Asia. The only means of putting an end to war, therefore, is by putting an end to the capitalist system that produces it. Far from opposing the present economic and political set up, Ron Paul is one of the most vociferous defenders of the profit system and America's ruling elite, saying, that the “rights of all private property owners” are the key to “maintain a free society.” Paul’s criticisms of the Iraq War and the Bush administration are entirely tactical and stem from his ultra-nationalist and isolationist outlook, not any principled opposition to American imperialism. This is demonstrated by reviewing his record. During the debate on the floor of the House of Representatives in October 2002 Paul, a former Air Force officer and senior member of the House Foreign Relations Committee, rose to speak against the resolution authorizing Bush to launch war against Iraq. His chief criticism was that ceding Congress’ power to declare war to the president ran the danger of giving ultimate authority over US foreign interventions to the United Nations, whose resolutions Bush had cited to prepare war against Iraq. Rather than UN resolutions, Paul said, “I happen to like it more when the president speaks about unilateralism and national security interests” to declare war. When the US “depends on the UN for our instructions,” he insisted, “we end up in no-win wars.” The first President Bush “didn’t go all the way” in the first Gulf War, Paul complained, because G.H.W. Bush said “the UN did not give him permission to.” When you go “through the backdoor” with UN-declared wars, Paul said, “wars last longer and you do not have a completion, like we had in Korea and Vietnam.” A month after the US invasion of Iraq, Paul took the floor of Congress to promote his “American Sovereignty Restoration Act” to end US participation in the United Nations. He said Bush deserved some credit for “ultimately upholding the principle that American national security is not a matter of international consensus, and that we don’t need UN authorization to act.” He warned if the US did not leave the UN, its “global planners” would establish a “true world government” that would “interfere not only in our nation’s foreign policy matters, but in our domestic policies as well” and “America as we know it will cease to exist.” Paul voted to authorize the war against Afghanistan. His criticisms of the Iraq War are conditional and tactical, chiefly centering on the complaint that it is undermining “national defense” by overstretching US military forces and its high cost is creating ever-greater economic dependence on foreign powers and potential enemies like “Communist China.” Who is Ron Paul? Attracted at a young age to the free market and anti-socialist nostrums of Ayn Rand and Austrian economist Ludwig von Mises—the father of the modern libertarian movement—Paul entered political life in 1964 when he became involved with the presidential campaign of Republican Senator Barry Goldwater, a bitter opponent of federal welfare programs, labor unions and civil rights legislation. In 1974 he ran for Congress as a Republican candidate and lost the election. But he won a special election in 1976, after President Gerald Ford appointed Paul’s former opponent to a federal position. Paul was eventually able to hold his seat in a regular election, and during his terms in Congress he ingratiated himself with the most right-wing elements of the political establishment. He was one of only a handful of Republican congressmen to endorse Ronald Reagan for president against Ford in 1976, and he used his seat on the House Banking Committee to advocate complete banking deregulation and the abolishing of the Federal Reserve Board. The favor was returned, as Paul was able to gain the backing of the ultra-rich, such as multi-billionaire Charles Koch, CEO of Koch Industries, the largest privately held company in the United States, and Steve Forbes, who would later be instrumental in financing Paul’s reelection campaigns in the 1990s. After a failed US Senate bid in the mid-1980s, Paul briefly returned to the practice of medicine. In his private practice, he refused to accept Medicare or Medicaid payments from patients, claiming they were paying with “stolen money.” He then launched a presidential campaign as the Libertarian Party candidate in 1988. The political hallmark of Paul is a combination of populist and even left-sounding rhetoric and the most right-wing positions. This is especially apparent in his economic policies. Paul often denounces “corporate welfare” and the influence that large corporations have within government. He also voices opposition to an inflationary monetary policy on the grounds that the real wages of workers are being eroded. His actual policy proposals, however, are based entirely on removing any restrictions on corporations and wealthy individuals to amass more wealth and exploit workers even more brutally. In this area, Paul is farther to the right than any other Republican seeking the nomination. He wishes to eliminate income taxes completely by abolishing virtually every federal department and domestic program. Paul advocates the elimination of the Department of Education, Social Security, the Occupational Safety & Health Administration, minimum wage laws, unemployment insurance, and virtually every other gain won by the struggle of previous generations of workers. Paul blames “illegal immigration” for a whole host of social ills, from the spread of disease, to crime, to the lowering of workers’ wages. He has also proposed amending the Constitution to remove birthright citizenship for the children of undocumented immigrants, writing in 2006: “The recent immigration protests in Los Angeles have brought the issue to the forefront, provoking strong reactions from millions of Americans. The protesters’ cause of open borders is not well served when they drape themselves in Mexican flags and chant slogans in Spanish . . . We must reject amnesty for illegal immigrants in any form. We cannot continue to reward lawbreakers and expect things to get better. . . . Birthright citizenship similarly rewards lawbreaking, and must be stopped. As long as illegal immigrants know their children born here will be citizens, the perverse incentive to sneak into this country remains strong.” This thinly veiled racist demagogy has earned Paul the praise of reactionaries such as CNN anchor Lou Dobbs and the support of extreme right elements, from members of the Minutemen Project to Don Black, founder of the white supremacist group Stormfront, who donated $500 to Paul’s campaign. In his campaign ads in Michigan, Paul sought to divert anger over the destruction of autoworkers’ jobs and living standards with appeals to anti-immigrant and national chauvinism. The North American Free Trade Agreement, he said, was “just one part of a plan to erase the borders...and create a single nation out of Canada, the U.S. and Mexico, with a new unelected bureaucracy and money system. Forget about controlling immigration under this scheme. And a free America, with limited, constitutional government, would be gone forever.” As he did on the eve of the invasion of Iraq on numerous occasions Paul has promoted the idea that the United Nations is a conspiratorial organization planning to implement a “new world order” and that the World Trade Organization is a plot by a “global elite” to strip America of its sovereignty. Paul’s brand of libertarianism doesn’t prevent him from opposing abortion in terms that are similar to those of the religious fundamentalists. Paul likens abortion to state-sanctioned murder, stating, “Abortion on demand is the ultimate State tyranny . . . Unlike Nazi Germany, which forcibly sent millions to the gas chambers (as well as forcing abortion and sterilization upon many more), the new regime has enlisted the assistance of millions of people to act as its agents in carrying out a program of mass murder.” He has proposed legislation that would remove from all federal courts the jurisdiction to hear cases relating to abortion. This would effectively overturn Roe v. Wade and allow the states to criminalize all abortion procedures. Paul has similarly tried to remove federal court jurisdiction to decide whether the phrase “under God” can be included in the Pledge of Allegiance, voted to ban federal funding for embryonic stem cell research, and voted to prevent same-sex couples from adopting. His consistent record of attacking democratic rights has prompted his supporters at Lew Rockwell.com to write a column approvingly posing the question, “Will Ron Paul Be the Candidate of the Christian Right?” Ron Paul’s appeal to the extreme right and fascist groups is not a new phenomenon. In a recent article published by theNew Republic, James Kurchick highlights the contents of some of Ron Paul’s newsletters, published during the time after Paul finished his first terms in Congress and returned to the practice of medicine. Kurchick describes an issue of the newsletter that was published after the 1992 riots in Los Angeles in the following manner, “’Order was only restored in L.A. when it came time for the blacks to pick up their welfare checks three days after rioting began,’ read one typical passage. According to the newsletter, the looting was a natural byproduct of government indulging the black community with ‘civil rights, quotas, mandated hiring preferences, set-asides for government contracts, gerrymandered voting districts, black bureaucracies, black mayors, black curricula in schools, black tv shows, black tv anchors, hate crime laws, and public humiliation for anyone who dares question the black agenda.’ It also denounced ‘the media’ for believing that ‘America’s number one need is an unlimited white checking account for underclass blacks.’” A newsletter issue reporting on the Louisiana Senate primary election campaign of former Ku Klux Klan wizard David Duke in 1990 stated, “our priority should be to take the anti-government, anti-tax, anti-crime, anti-welfare loafers, anti-race privilege, anti-foreign meddling message of Duke, and enclose it in a more consistent package of freedom.” In response to the New Republic exposé, Ron Paul issued a statement on his website claiming that material in the articles are not his words but were contributed by numerous writers for his newsletter, which Paul did not edit and that Paul was not aware of what was being published. It is entirely unbelievable that Paul had no knowledge of the content of articles printed under his name for over a decade. Moreover, Paul has repeatedly made his opposition to civil rights legislation clear. As recently as 2004, he marked the 40th anniversary of the Civil Rights Act of 1964—which outlawed the system of apartheid- like racial segregation in Southern schools and public places during the Jim Crow period—by denouncing the measure from the floor of Congress for infringing on the “rights of private property owners,” including the “customer service practices of every business in the country.” Such reactionary politics make a farce out of the efforts to paint Paul in “antiwar” colors. That he commands any following at all is due entirely to the absence of a genuine opposition to militarism among the leading contenders for the presidential race in both big business parties. In such a vacuum, extreme right figures can emerge. A serious struggle against war requires steadfast opposition to such reactionary politics and all those who compromise with it On Nov 19, 5:24 pm, "M.A. Johnson" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Patriotismby Ron Paul > Before the U.S. House of Representatives, May 22, 2007 > Madam Speaker, for some, patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel. For > others, it means dissent against a government's abuse of the people's rights. > I have never met a politician in Washington or any American, for that matter, > who chose to be called unpatriotic. Nor have I met anyone who did not believe > he wholeheartedly supported our troops, wherever they may be. > What I have heard all too frequently from various individuals are sharp > accusations that, because their political opponents disagree with them on the > need for foreign military entanglements, they were unpatriotic, un-American > evildoers deserving contempt. > The original American patriots were those individuals brave enough to resist > with force the oppressive power of King George. I accept the definition of > patriotism as that effort to resist oppressive state power. > The true patriot is motivated by a sense of responsibility and out of > self-interest for himself, his family, and the future of his country to > resist government abuse of power. He rejects the notion that patriotism means > obedience to the state. Resistance need not be violent, but the civil > disobedience that might be required involves confrontation with the state and > invites possible imprisonment. > Peaceful, nonviolent revolutions against tyranny have been every bit as > successful as those involving military confrontation. Mahatma Gandhi and Dr. > Martin Luther King, Jr., achieved great political successes by practicing > nonviolence, and yet they suffered physically at the hands of the state. But > whether the resistance against government tyrants is nonviolent or physically > violent, the effort to overthrow state oppression qualifies as true > patriotism. > True patriotism today has gotten a bad name, at least from the government and > the press. Those who now challenge the unconstitutional methods of imposing > an income tax on us, or force us to use a monetary system designed to serve > the rich at the expense of the poor are routinely condemned. These American > patriots are sadly looked down upon by many. They are never praised as > champions of liberty as Gandhi and Martin Luther King have been. > Liberals, who withhold their taxes as a protest against war, are vilified as > well, especially by conservatives. Unquestioned loyalty to the state is > especially demanded in times of war. Lack of support for a war policy is said > to be unpatriotic. Arguments against a particular policy that endorses a war, > once it is started, are always said to be endangering the troops in the > field. This, they blatantly claim, is unpatriotic, and all dissent must stop. > Yet, it is dissent from government policies that defines the true patriot and > champion of liberty. > It is conveniently ignored that the only authentic way to best support the > troops is to keep them out of dangerous undeclared no-win wars that are > politically inspired. Sending troops off to war for reasons that are not > truly related to national security and, for that matter, may even damage our > security, is hardly a way to patriotically support the troops. > Who are the true patriots, those who conform or those who protest against > wars without purpose? How can it be said that blind support for a war, no > matter how misdirected the policy, is the duty of a patriot? > Randolph Bourne said that, "War is the health of the state.'' With war, he > argued, the state thrives. Those who believe in the powerful state see war as > an opportunity. Those who mistrust the people and the market for solving > problems have no trouble promoting a "war psychology'' to justify the > expansive role of the state. This includes the role the Federal Government > plays in our lives, as well as in our economic transactions. > Certainly, the neoconservative belief that we have a moral obligation to > spread American values worldwide through force justifies the conditions of > war in order to rally support at home for the heavy hand of government. It is > through this policy, it should surprise no one, that our liberties are > undermined. The economy becomes overextended, and our involvement worldwide > becomes prohibited. Out of fear of being labeled unpatriotic, most of the > citizens become compliant and accept the argument that some loss of liberty > is required to fight the war in order to remain safe. > This is a bad trade-off, in my estimation, especially when done in the name > of patriotism. Loyalty to the state and to autocratic leaders is substituted > for true patriotism; that is, a willingness to challenge the state and defend > the country, the people and the culture. The more difficult the times, the > stronger the admonition comes that the leaders be not criticized. > Because the crisis atmosphere of war supports the growth of the state, any > problem invites an answer by declaring war, even on social and economic > issues. This elicits patriotism in support of various government solutions, > while enhancing the power of the state. Faith in government coercion and a > lack of understanding of how free societies operate encourages big-government > liberals and big-government conservatives to manufacture a war psychology to > demand political loyalty for domestic policy just as is required in foreign > affairs. > The long-term cost in dollars spent and liberties lost is neglected as > immediate needs are emphasized. It is for this reason that we have multiple > perpetual wars going on simultaneously. Thus, the war on drugs, the war > against gun ownership, the war against poverty, the war against illiteracy, > the war against terrorism, as well as our foreign military entanglements are > endless. > All this effort promotes the growth of statism at the expense of liberty. A > government designed for a free society should do the opposite, prevent the > growth of statism and preserve liberty. > Once a war of any sort is declared, the message is sent out not to object or > you will be declared unpatriotic. Yet, we must not forget that the true > patriot is the one who protests in spite of the consequences. Condemnation or > ostracism or even imprisonment may result. > Nonviolent protesters of the Tax Code are frequently imprisoned, whether they > are protesting the code's unconstitutionality or the war that the tax > revenues are funding. Resisters to the military draft or even to Selective > Service registration are threatened and imprisoned for challenging this > threat to liberty. > Statism depends on the idea that the government owns us and citizens must > obey. Confiscating the fruits of our labor through the income tax is crucial > to the health of the state. The draft, or even the mere existence of the > Selective Service, emphasizes that we will march off to war at the state's > pleasure. > A free society rejects all notions of involuntary servitude, whether by draft > or the confiscation of the fruits of our labor through the personal income > tax. A more sophisticated and less well-known technique for enhancing the > state is the manipulation and transfer of wealth through the fiat monetary > system operated by the secretive Federal Reserve. > Protesters against this unconstitutional system of paper money are considered > unpatriotic criminals and at times are imprisoned for their beliefs. The fact > that, according to the Constitution, only gold and silver are legal tender > and paper money outlawed matters little. The principle of patriotism is > turned on its head. Whether it's with regard to the defense of welfare > spending at home, confiscatory income tax, or an immoral monetary system or > support for a war fought under false pretense without a legal declaration, > the defenders of liberty and the Constitution are portrayed as unpatriotic, > while those who support these programs are seen as the patriots. > If there is a war going on, supporting the state's effort to win the war is > expected at all costs, no dissent. The real problem is that those who love > the state too often advocate policies that lead to military action. At home, > they are quite willing to produce a crisis atmosphere and claim a war is > needed to solve the problem. Under these conditions, the people are more > willing to bear the burden of paying for the war and to carelessly sacrifice > liberties, which they are told is necessary. > The last 6 years have been quite beneficial to the health of the state, which > comes at the expense of personal liberty. Every enhanced unconstitutional > power of the state can only be achieved at the expense of individual liberty. > Even though in every war in which we have been engaged civil liberties have > suffered, some have been restored after the war ended, but never completely. > That has resulted in a steady erosion of our liberties over the past 200 > years. Our government was originally designed to protect our liberties, but > it has now, instead, become the usurper of those liberties. > We currently live in the most difficult of times for guarding against an > expanding central government with a steady erosion of our freedoms. We are > continually being reminded that 9/11 has changed everything. > Unfortunately, the policy that needed most to be changed, that is, our policy > of foreign interventionism, has only been expanded. There is no pretense any > longer that a policy of humility in foreign affairs, without being the > world's policemen and engaging in nation building, is worthy of consideration. > We now live in a post-9/11 America where our government is going to make us > safe no matter what it takes. We are expected to grin and bear it and adjust > to every loss of our liberties in the name of patriotism and security. > Though the majority of Americans initially welcomed the declared effort to > make us safe, and we are willing to sacrifice for the cause, more and more > Americans are now becoming concerned about civil liberties being needlessly > and dangerously sacrificed. > The problem is that the Iraq war continues to drag on, and a real danger of > it spreading exists. There is no evidence that a truce will soon be signed in > Iraq or in the war on terror or the war on drugs. Victory is not even > definable. If Congress is incapable of declaring an official war, it is > impossible to know when it will end. We have been fully forewarned that the > world conflict in which we are now engaged will last a long, long time. > The war mentality and the pervasive fear of an unidentified enemy allows for > a steady erosion of our liberties, and, with this, our respect for > self-reliance and confidence is lost. Just think of the self-sacrifice and > the humiliation we go through at the airport screening process on a routine > basis. Though there is no scientific evidence of any likelihood of liquids > and gels being mixed on an airplane to make a bomb, billions of dollars are > wasted throwing away toothpaste and hair spray, and searching old women in > wheelchairs. > Our enemies say boo, and we jump, we panic, and then we punish ourselves. We > are worse than a child being afraid of the dark. But in a way, the fear of > indefinable terrorism is based on our inability to admit the truth about why > there is a desire by a small number of angry radical Islamists to kill > Americans. It is certainly not because they are jealous of our wealth and > freedoms. > We fail to realize that the extremists, willing to sacrifice their own lives > to kill their enemies, do so out of a sense of weakness and desperation over > real and perceived attacks on their way of life, their religion, their > country, and their natural resources. Without the conventional diplomatic or > military means to retaliate against these attacks, and an unwillingness of > their own government to address the issue, they resort to the desperation > tactic of suicide terrorism. Their anger toward their own governments, which > they believe are coconspirators with the American Government, is equal to or > greater than that directed toward us. > These errors in judgment in understanding the motive of the enemy and the > constant fear that is generated have brought us to this crisis where our > civil liberties and privacy are being steadily eroded in the name of > preserving national security. > We may be the economic and the military giant of the world, but the effort to > stop this war on our liberties here at home in the name of patriotism is > being lost. > The erosion of our personal liberties started long before 9/11, but 9/11 > accelerated the process. There are many things that motivate those who pursue > this course, both well-intentioned and malevolent, but it would not happen if > the people remained vigilant, understood the importance of individual rights, > and were unpersuaded that a need for security justifies the sacrifice for > liberty, even if it is just now and then. > The true patriot challenges the state when the state embarks on enhancing its > power at the expense of the individual. Without a better understanding and a > greater determination to rein in the state, the rights of Americans that > resulted from the revolutionary break from the British and the writing of the > Constitution will disappear. > The record since September 11th is dismal. Respect for liberty has rapidly > deteriorated. Many of the new laws passed after 9/11 had, in fact, been > proposed long before that attack. The political atmosphere after that attack > simply made it more possible to pass such legislation. The fear generated by > 9/11 became an opportunity for those seeking to promote the power of the > state domestically, just as it served to falsely justify the long-planned > invasion of Iraq. > The war mentality was generated by the Iraq war in combination with the > constant drumbeat of fear at home. Al Qaeda and Osama bin Laden, who is now > likely residing in Pakistan, our supposed ally, are ignored, as our troops > fight and die in Iraq and are made easier targets for the terrorists in their > backyard. While our leaders constantly use the mess we created to further > justify the erosion of our constitutional rights here at home, we forget > about our own borders and support the inexorable move toward global > government, hardly a good plan for America. > The accelerated attacks on liberty started quickly after 9/11. Within weeks, > the PATRIOT Act was overwhelmingly passed by Congress. Though the final > version was unavailable up to a few hours before the vote, no Member had > sufficient time to study it. Political fear of not doing something, even > something harmful, drove the Members of Congress to not question the > contents, and just voted for it. A little less freedom for a little more > perceived safety was considered a fair trade-off, and the majority of > Americans applauded. > The PATRIOT Act, though, severely eroded the system of checks and balances by > giving the government the power to spy on law-abiding citizens without > judicial supervision. The several provisions that undermine the liberties of > all Americans include sneak-and-peek searches, a broadened and more vague > definition of domestic terrorism, allowing the FBI access to library and > bookstore records without search warrants or probable cause, easier FBI > initiation of wiretaps and searches, as well as roving wiretaps, easier > access to information on American citizens' use of the Internet, and easier > access to e-mail and financial records of all American citizens. > The attack on privacy has not relented over the past 6 years. The Military > Commissions Act is a particularly egregious piece of legislation and, if not > repealed, will change America for the worse as the powers unconstitutionally > granted to the executive branch are used and abused. This act grants > excessive authority to use secretive military commissions outside of places > where active hostilities are going on. The Military Commissions Act permits > torture, arbitrary detention of American citizens as unlawful enemy > combatants at the full discretion of the President and without the right of > habeas corpus, and warrantless searches by the NSA. It also gives to the > President the power to imprison individuals based on secret testimony. > Since 9/11, Presidential signing statements designating portions of > legislation that the President does not intend to follow, though not legal > under the Constitution, have enormously multiplied. Unconstitutional > Executive Orders are numerous and mischievous and need to be curtailed. > Extraordinary rendition to secret prisons around the world have been widely > engaged in, though obviously extralegal. > A growing concern in the post-9/11 environment is the Federal Government's > list of potential terrorists based on secret evidence. Mistakes are made, and > sometimes it is virtually impossible to get one's name removed even though > the accused is totally innocent of any wrongdoing. > A national ID card is now in the process of being implemented. It is called > the REAL ID card, and it is tied to our Social Security numbers and our State > driver's license. If REAL ID is not stopped, it will become a national > driver's license ID for all Americans. We will be required to carry our > papers. > Some of the least-noticed and least-discussed changes in the law were the > changes made to the Insurrection Act of 1807 and to posse comitatus by the > Defense Authorization Act of 2007. These changes pose a threat to the > survival of our Republic by giving the President the power to declare martial > law for as little reason as to restore public order. The 1807 act severely > restricted the President in his use of the military within the United States > borders, and the Posse Comitatus Act of 1878 strengthened these restrictions > with strict oversight by Congress. The new law allows the President to > circumvent the restrictions of both laws. The Insurrection Act has now become > the "Enforcement of the Laws to Restore Public Order Act.'' This is hardly a > title that suggests that the authors cared about or understood the nature of > a constitutional Republic. > Now, martial law can be declared not just for insurrection, but also for > natural disasters, public health reasons, terrorist attacks or incidents, or > for the vague reason called "other conditions.'' The President can call up > the National Guard without congressional approval or the Governors' approval, > and even send these State Guard troops into other States. > The American Republic is in remnant status. The stage is set for our country > eventually devolving into a military dictatorship, and few seem to care. > These precedent-setting changes in the law are extremely dangerous and will > change American jurisprudence forever if not revised. The beneficial results > of our revolt against the King's abuses are about to be eliminated, and few > Members of Congress and few Americans are aware of the seriousness of the > situation. Complacency and fear drive our legislation without any serious > objection by our elected leaders. Sadly, though, those few who do object to > this self-evident trend away from personal liberty and empire-building > overseas are portrayed as unpatriotic and uncaring. > Though welfare and socialism always fails, opponents of them are said to lack > compassion. Though opposition to totally unnecessary war should be the only > moral position, the rhetoric is twisted to claim that patriots who oppose the > war are not supporting the troops. The cliché "Support the Troops'' is > incessantly used as a substitute for the unacceptable notion of supporting > the policy, no matter how flawed it may be. > Unsound policy can never help the troops. Keeping the troops out of harm's > way and out of wars unrelated to our national security is the only real way > of protecting the troops. With this understanding, just who can claim the > title of "patriot''? > Before the war in the Middle East spreads and becomes a world conflict for > which we will be held responsible, or the liberties of all Americans become > so suppressed we can no longer resist, much has to be done. Time is short, > but our course of action should be clear. Resistance to illegal and > unconstitutional usurpation of our rights is required. Each of us must choose > which course of action we should take: education, conventional political > action, or even peaceful civil disobedience to bring about necessary changes. > But let it not be said that we did nothing. Let not those who love the power > of the welfare/warfare state label the dissenters of authoritarianism as > unpatriotic or uncaring. Patriotism is more closely linked to dissent than it > is to conformity and a blind desire for safety and security. Understanding > the magnificent rewards of a free society makes us unbashful in its > promotion, fully realizing that maximum wealth is created and the greatest > chance for peace comes from a society respectful of individual liberty. --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups. For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum * Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/ * It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls. * Read the latest breaking news, and more. -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
