This is the Big Brother nightmare of oppressive government that the shrewd propagandists on the right are always blathering on about. Except that this time, they could not be more right.
This reeks of the Big Brother nightmare of oppressive government that the shrewd propagandists on the right are always blathering on about. Except that this time, they could not be more right. One would think the author would proof read his own material so he would not write an almost identical paragraph less than 100 words later. I work on a high acuity ward at a regional hospital and I see hundreds of thousands of dollars being spent on very expensive tests and procedures to extend someones life who has almost no hope of living for more than a couple of months and at best it will be all in a hospital with no "quality of life." So I understand why Obama wants to pull the plug on these people. Is it right? More importantly is it right for a person to steal from you so they can continue to live? And if so, how much can they steal from you? Only as much as it leaves you destitute, but not starving? And at that point you can say, "No more!"? These are the fundamental questions that are being ignored by most people. What right does another person have to your property or you to theirs? Can they use the government, with their guns, force you to work to keep them alive as long as possible, no matter the cost? On Aug 13, 2:28 am, Bruce Majors <[email protected]> wrote: > This says it right! > > Beth > > Obama's Euthanasia Mistake > by Lee Siegel > August 11, 2009 | 6:52am > > http://www.thedailybeast.com/blogs-and-stories/2009-08-11/obamas-euth... > > *[image: BS Top - Siegel euthanasia Obama protesters] The Republicans > carping about limitations on end-of-life care have a point. Lee Siegel on > why the plans Obama is endorsing are dangerously sympathetic to "cost > effective" end-of-life treatments.* > > For those of us who believe that the absence of universal health care is > America’s burning shame, the spectacle of opposition to Obama’s health-care > plan is Alice-in-Wonderland bewildering and also enraging—but on one point > the plan’s critics are absolutely correct. One of the key ideas under > consideration—which can be read as expressing sympathy for limitations on > end-of-life care—is morally revolting. And it’s helping to kill the plan > itself. > > Make no mistake about it. Determining which treatments are “cost effective” > at the end of a person’s life and which are not is one of Obama’s > priorities. It’s one of the principal ways he counts on saving money and > making universal healthcare affordable. > > This is the Big Brother nightmare of oppressive government that the shrewd > propagandists on the right are always blathering on about. Except that this > time, they could not be more right. > > Obama told > <http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/Politics/story?id=7910304&page=1>Diane > Sawyer in June that government should “study and figure out what works > and what doesn’t. And let’s encourage doctors and patients to get what > works. Let’s discourage what doesn’t.” > > Sawyer then asked him: “Will it just be encouragement? Or will there be a > board making Solomonic decisions?” > > Obama replied, “What I’ve suggested is—is that we have a—a commission that > helps—made up of doctors, made up of experts, that helps set best—best > practices.” > > When Sawyer pressed him to say whether those practices would be enforced by > law, he evaded the question. > > This reeks of the Big Brother nightmare of oppressive government that the > shrewd propagandists on the right are always blathering on about. Except > that this time, they could not be more right. > > Leave aside the argument for ending life when its prospects for continuing > seem too painful or too hopeless. Leave it aside because this is one case > where Kant’s beautiful categorical imperative—act as though your particular > deeds should be a universal law—will never apply. We know that theft and > murder are wrong because if they were universally committed, the world would > explode in chaos. But the decision to end your life before nature wrenches > it away is as rational and humane as the decision to prolong your life by > whatever means necessary. Life is too specifically precious to turn its > final phase into any type of universal practice, whether it’s enforced by > custom or by law. > > As for the argument that fruitless tests and “senseless” procedures are > bankrupting the health-care system, that is an insult to the intelligence. > No one knows which tests and procedures will be effective beforehand. No > amount of “study” and research is going to address the particular case and > the particular condition, let alone the particular, desperate, irrational > will to live—which, in animal terms, is pragmatic and rational. > > (And anyone who thinks that we are not all animals—even the “experts” Obama > is so enamored of— must read David Rieff’s remarkable > account<http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/04/magazine/04sontag.html>of > his mother Susan Sontag’s refusal to accept her doctors’ verdict of > imminent death. The will to live does not suddenly become an error of > judgment just because a “system” cannot “afford” to accommodate it, > especially when the system has the means to do so.) > > Most consequential of all, even if limitations were put on certain tests and > procedures, the only people who would be affected by it would be the people > who, presumably, are the ones meant to be rescued by the very plan that > would be imposing those limitations. The financially strapped, in other > words, who are the intended beneficiaries of the health care plan would be > the only people forbidden access to expensive life-extending technology. The > rich will always be able to afford it. > > Once the technology to extend life has become available, you cannot restrict > its availability. That would be like only letting some people use cell > phones. Such technology is a drain on the system? Then save money elsewhere. > It’s ironic that lacking the will to tax the very wealthy, some of > health-care supporters in Congress now wish to save money by limiting > end-of-life options to the economically burdened. > > Where is Obama coming from? Why is such an apparently humane man not more > strongly condemning a utilitarian initiative straight out of Victorian > England? A good part of the explanation has to do with the University of > Chicago Law School milieu that Obama comes out of. By far, the most > influential figure in that world is Judge Richard Posner, who teaches law at > Chicago and publishes streams of pompous, robotically written books that are > much praised and little read. > > Judge Posner is both an enthusiastic advocate of euthanasia and an energetic > eugenicist. He once wrote of Oliver Wendell Holmes’ ideas about > eugenics—Holmes believed that a just society “prevents continuance of the > unfit”—that “we may yet find [Holmes’] enthusiasms prescient rather than > depraved.” > > Cass Sunstein, who is Obama’s nominee for regulatory czar, is a disciple of > Posner and believes in what Time magazine > describes<http://www.time.com/time/politics/article/0,8599,1881473,00.html>as > “the statistical practice of taking into account years of life > expectancy > when evaluating a regulation.” In other words, Sunstein believes that the > lives of younger people have a greater value than those of the elderly. > This, obviously, would have a radical bearing on end-of-life considerations. > > End-of-life treatment is still under consideration and would be a tiny > sliver of Obama’s health-care package. But it is a highly volatile sliver. > Betsy McCaughey, who singlehandedly killed the Clintons’ health-care > initiative 15 years ago with her infamous and infamously inaccurate cover > story in The New Republic, > claims<http://www.politico.com/news/stories/0709/25486.html>that this > small passage in the bill “would make it mandatory—absolutely > require—that every five years people in Medicare have a required counseling > session that will tell them how to end their life sooner.” Not quite. > But—painful as it is to concede anything to an ideological hack like > McCaughey—it’s uncomfortably close. > > The section, on page 425 of the bill, offers to pay once every five years > for a voluntary, not mandatory, consultation with a doctor, who will not > blatantly tell the patient how to end his or her life sooner, but will > explain to the patient the set of options available at the end of life, > including living wills, palliative care and hospice, life sustaining > treatment, and all aspects of advance care planning, including, presumably, > the decision to end one’s life. > > The shading in of human particulars is what makes this so unsettling. A > doctor guided by a panel of experts who have decided that some treatments > are futile will, in subtle ways, advance that point of view. Cass Sunstein > calls this “nudging,” which he characterizes as using various types of > reinforcement techniques to “nudge” people’s behavior in one direction or > another. An elderly or sick person would be especially vulnerable to the > sophisticated nudging of an authority figure like a doctor. > > Bad enough for such people who are lucky enough to be supported by family > and friends. But what about the dying person who is all alone in the world > and who has only the “consultant” to turn to and rely on? The heartlessness > of such a scene is chilling. > > Yet many liberals seem drawn to such fantasies of power and control. We live > in a highly quantified society, entertained on all sides by divertissements > that reduce human life to cute little anecdotes illustrating the morality of > statistical, utilitarian analysis, from Malcolm Gladwell to Freakonomics and > beyond. > > A few weeks ago, The New York Times Magazine unfathomably > ran<http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/19/magazine/19healthcare-t.html?pagewa...>an > entire essay arguing, in effect, for a eugenic attitude toward > end-of-life treatment written by Peter Singer, a Princeton University > “bio-ethicist” whose views are squarely in line with those of Posner and > Oliver Wendell Holmes. The essay drove the conservatives opposing Obama’s > health-care plan into even greater apoplexy, as it should have. The only > point on which it convinced was that euthanasia is morally acceptable only > as an antidote to tenure. > > One of Obama’s most alluring traits has been what some see as a literary > bent that relishes complexity, irony, and even the mystery of the human > personality. Let him turn toward that part of his nature and leave the > sterile precincts of utilitarian social and legal theory behind. He should > immediately and publicly declare his commitment to not placing economic > hurdles in the way of people who want to prolong their life, or the life of > their loved ones. In that way, he would take the air out of charlatans like > McCaughey. And he would calm the fears of people who, far from being > right-wing fanatics, are in clear-eyed possession of perhaps the only > universal truth there is. No one wants to die. > > *Lee Siegel has written about culture and politics and is the author of > three books:** *Falling Upwards: Essays in Defense of the > Imagination<http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0465078001/thedaibea-20/>; > Not Remotely Controlled: Notes on > Television<http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0465078109/thedaibea-20/>; > *and, most recently,** *Against the Machine: Being Human in the Age of the > Electronic > Mob<http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0385522657/thedaibea-20/> > *. In 2002, he received a National Magazine Award for reviews and criticism. > * > > __._,_.___ > > Your email settings: Individual Email|Traditional > Change settings via the > Web<http://groups.yahoo.com/group/RumblesAList/join;_ylc=X3oDMTJnbnB0ZXRp...>(Yahoo! > ID required) > Change settings via email: Switch delivery to Daily > Digest<[email protected]?subject=email+delivery:+Digest>| > Switch > to Fully > Featured<[email protected]?subject=change+delivery+format:+Fully+Featured> > Visit Your Group > <http://groups.yahoo.com/group/RumblesAList;_ylc=X3oDMTJlYm9scWRlBF9TA...>| > Yahoo! > Groups Terms of Use <http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/> | Unsubscribe > <[email protected]?subject=unsubscribe> > > __,_._,___ > > img-bs-top---siegel-euthanasia-hospital-visit_234234153597.jpg > 74KViewDownload > > print_blogs_header.gif?v=12.02 > 16KViewDownload --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups. For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum * Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/ * It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls. * Read the latest breaking news, and more. -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
