Big Business Goes Big for Health Care ReformWhy drug companies and insurance
providers are backing ObamaCare

John Stossel <http://www.reason.com/contrib/show/353.html> | August 13, 2009
"What disturbs Americans of all ideological persuasions is the fear that
almost everything, not just government, is fixed or manipulated by some
powerful hidden hand," Frank Rich wrote <http://tinyurl.com/nkqfy8> in
Sunday's *New York Times*.

That manipulation should disturb us. But contrary to Rich, it is not the
work of "corporatists" who have sprung up to attack progressive reforms
proposed by Obama and the Democratic majority. Manipulation is what we got
many years ago when we traded a more or less free market for the
"progressive" interventionist state. When government is big, the
well-connected always have an advantage over the rest of us in influencing
public policy.

Observe: Although President Obama and big-government activists demonize
health-insurance companies, the companies "are still mostly on board with
the president's effort to overhaul the U.S. health-care system," the *Wall
Street Journal* reports <http://tinyurl.com/mf2hu7>; and ...

Although the activists criticize Big Pharma, "The drug industry has already
contributed millions of dollars to advertising campaigns for the health care
overhaul through the advocacy groups like Healthy Economies Now and Families
USA. It has spent about $1 million on similar advertisements under its own
name," the *Times* reports <http://tinyurl.com/mcjfqv>.

Big Pharma and Big Insurance want Obama-style health-care reform?

It's not so hard to understand. "The drug makers stand to gain millions of
new customers," the*Times* said.

And from the *Journal*: "If health legislation succeeds, the [insurance]
industry would likely get a fresh batch of new customers. In particular,
many young and healthy people who currently forgo coverage would be forced
to sign up." No wonder insurers are willing to stop "discriminating" against
sick people. (Forget that the essence of insurance is discrimination
according to risk.)

Not that Big Pharma and Big Insurance like every detail of the Democratic
plan. Drug companies don't want Medicare negotiating drug prices—for good
reason. If it forces drug prices down, research and development will be
discouraged. (Depending whom you believe, Obama may or may not have agreed
with the drug companies on this point <http://tinyurl.com/mypxjq>.)

As for the insurance companies, they worry—legitimately—that a government
insurance company—the so-called public option"—would drive them out of
business. This isn't alarmism. It's economics. The public option would have
no bottom line to worry about and therefore could engage in "predatory
pricing" against the private insurers.

But despite these differences, the biggest companies in these two industries
are on board with "reform."

It illustrates economist Steven Horwitz's First Law of Political
Economy<http://tinyurl.com/cw9nbt>:
"No one hates capitalism more than capitalists." In this case, big business
wants to shape—and profit from—what inevitably will be an interventionist
health-care reform. Can you think of the last time a major business
supported a truly free market in anything?

In light of all this, it's funny to watch Democrats and their activist
allies panic over the protests at congressional town meetings around the
country. Tools of the corporate interests! they cry. But anyone opposing
"socialized medicine" at the meeting can't be a mouthpiece for big business
because, as we've seen, big business supports government control.
Conservative groups may be encouraging people to vent their anger at
congressmen who pass burdensome legislation without even bothering to read
it, but that's no reason to insult the protestors as pawns. What's wrong
with organizations helping like-minded people to voice their opinions? Why
do Democrats, such as Speaker Nancy Pelosi,
dismiss<http://tinyurl.com/nne8l4> citizen
participation as "AstroTurf"—not real grassroots—only when citizens oppose
the kind of big government they favor?

They weren't so dismissive when George W. Bush was president and people
protested—appropriately—his accumulation of executive powers.

"When handfuls of Code Pink ladies disrupted congressional hearings or
speeches by Bush administration officials," Glenn Reynolds
writes<http://tinyurl.com/nz5dzg>,
"it was taken as evidence that the administration's policies were unpopular,
and that the thinking parts of the populace were rising up in true
democratic fashion. ... But when it happens to Democrats, it's something
different: A threat to democracy, a sign of incipient fascism ... House
Speaker Nancy Pelosi calls the 'Tea Party' protesters Nazis. ... "

So when lefties do it, it's called "community organizing."

When conservatives and libertarians do it, it's "AstroTurf."

Give me a break.

*John Stossel is co-anchor of ABC News' *20/20* and the author of *Myth,
Lies, and Downright Stupidity*. He has a new blog at
http://blogs.abcnews.com/johnstossel.*

--~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~
Thanks for being part of "PoliticalForum" at Google Groups.
For options & help see http://groups.google.com/group/PoliticalForum

* Visit our other community at http://www.PoliticalForum.com/  
* It's active and moderated. Register and vote in our polls. 
* Read the latest breaking news, and more.
-~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---

Reply via email to