Greetings,

Just providing some feedback....

The fist thing I wanted to know when I started J was how to exit.  I did
some research and discovered 2!:55.  I then defined a verb and used that to
exit.  Therefore, in order to get a clean way to exit a new language, I had
to learn what a verb is, what system verbs were available, how to define
it, and how to load it.  (I know about ^d but think that is hardly a clean
way to exit.)

Now, years later, I discover the pre-defined verb 'exit'.  I checked the
docs, especially "Learning J".  There is no mention of 'exit'!

As someone who has played with many languages over the years, and in fact
an author of one, I respectfully suggest updating chapter 1 of Learning J
to tell the user how to exit.  Making a research project out of the first
obvious desire is an unnecessary impediment to a language acquision.

Additionally, since I discovered 'exit', a comprehensive dictionary of
pre-defined verbs would be very helpful.  (I know about z, etc.)

Thanks.  Just some thoughts...

Blake McBride
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For information about J forums see http://www.jsoftware.com/forums.htm

Reply via email to