Dan Bron wrote:


And, new in the J601 Dictionary, the parts of speech are explicitly spelled out:

   http://www.jsoftware.com/help/dictionary/partsofspeech.htm

(which the Vocabuarly links to under "Parts of Speech".)



I suggested to Roger a long time ago that the Dictionary of J should follow the standard practise of lexicographers. They follow the headword by the part of speech, then go on to give detailed information about the meaning.

He obviously has reasons for not wanting to include it in the definitions but it would surely be much easier for the user to have it attached to the definitions rather than off in an Appendix, or identified by the font used in the Vocabulary table.

The part of speech associated with each primitive is central to all aspects of its use. It really deserves a formal place where it is explicitly stated at the head of the Dictionary page which states the definitions.

Fraser
----------------------------------------------------------------------
For information about J forums see http://www.jsoftware.com/forums.htm

Reply via email to