Hi Nickus,
In my opinion, there isn't too much point getting caught up with things
like
the development of a 20 cycle wave etc, and I think from reading your
post
you are thinking along the same lines.
Simply buy the best speakers you can at the moment with the budget you've
got. At the price range your talking about, all speakers are designed for
nearfield use, which would mean listening from a distance of 6 feet or
less,
which in my mind eliminates the question of the need to develop those low
frequency sound waves anyway. Acoustics is a tricky business, but if you
have the best speakers you can afford you'll really improve because
you'll
know much better the exact nature of the sound your working with.
having your speakers on stands or something that will isolate them from
your
desk will help a lot too I would imagine.
I purchased Adam ax7 moniters, and for the price I got them at I'm
absolutely delighted. But there are many speakers around that price point
that are doing good things for various people. My main criteria was
buying
from a manufacturer that makes very well respected speakers at higher
price
points, and buying a speaker that was regarded as exposing things in the
mix
rather than making everything sound great. The mid range on the speakers
I
chose for example are said to be a little similar to the NS10, helping
for
vocal mixing and critical work in the mid range. Now I wouldn't read too
much into such claims by manufacturers or other users, but its worth
keeping
in mind. I've enjoyed working with genelec speakers for example, but they
do
seem to suffer from having a scooped mid range, which contrastly often
makes things sound a little more pleasing than they might be on other
systems. I didn't find it a huge problem for acoustic and electronic
music,
but when I was working with more rock/pop oriented stuff on Genelecs I
found
it difficult to know the impact of what I was mixing sometimes.
So all I'm saying really is buy the best speakers that you can find given
your budget and the research you do, and you'll never look back.
Since I bought mine I've been working in the same relatively untreated
room,
and with the only new element being the new speakers over the last year
my
mixes have improved ten times over with out exaggeration. I'm moving to a
great new room soon specifically designed for mixing, and while I'm
expecting some improvement again in my mix work, I'll probably never
again
experience such an improvement as I did after making the jump t better
speakers.
Best of luck with your research, hope tha thelped a little,
Brian.
----------------
From: "Nickus de Vos" <[email protected]>
Sent: Thursday, December 29, 2011 12:03 PM
To: "Pro Tools Accessibility" <[email protected]>
Subject: OT room size and monitor size
> Hi all I know this has nothing to do with PT but it has to do with
> sound. I'm just looking for some opinions before investing round $1000
> in studio monitors.
> The other day I read a article where the guy said if your monitors is
> too large for your room you'll never get a propper sound because the
> sound waves don't have space to fully develope. Now by theory I know 1
> cycle of a 20 Hz wave is 17.2 meters long and a 100 Hz wave is 3.44
> meters long so that guys theory doesn't make scence because it means
> everybody should have a mixing room longer than 3.44 meters to
> reproduce anything below 100 Hz. Now I have been around and very few
> studios I visited had control rooms longer than 4 or 5 meters not even
> mentioning the 17.2 meters for 20 Hz, not even mastering engineers who
> usually has longer rooms go that long. I also know that I will
> probably have my monitors for way longer than the time I use this
> current room for mixing so it's a long term investment and I mustn't
> spesifically buy monitors to fit my room. I currently have a 4 x 3.5
> meter room which is acoustically treeted, at the moment it sounds ok
> but I still want to improve it over time. I basically have to decide
> between 6 or 8 inch monitors with the 8's obviously havving a better
> bass responce and a bigger price tag. I'm just curious to what you are
> using and how it works for you, theory always helps but the opinions
> of other people also counts for a lot in my experience.
>
> Nickus
>