As mentioned in my previous set of comments on the TR-ER task group report, the transportation subconsultant will address most of the TR-AC recommendations in his studies and public meetings, so the following are just some my own observations.
At Keola's request, I am referencing the comments to the page numbers as well as the section headings in the TR-AC task group report so that it will be easier to follow the comments. Category 1 - Emergency Response Issue #2 (p.12) These recommendations (to increase County influence over decisions by DOT) are more likely to get attention if they are brought by your State legislators rather than made part of the CDP. The CDP holds no sway over the State, especially on matters that have statewide (not just Puna-wide) significance. Issue #3 (p. 14) The Puna Regional Circulation Plan (PRCP) recommended several emergency access routes (Figure 13.1 - Action Plan) that are similar - but not identical - to the ones listed in this section. Is there a reason why these recommendations differ? The transportation subconsultant could consider emergency routes that were not included in the PRCP, but some of the suggested routes could raise other concerns - for example, the alignment next to Wao Kele 'o Puna and the new corridor from Kalapana to Hilo could have unintended impacts on natural areas, in addition to being more expensive than the routes proposed in the PRCP. Category 2 - Aesthetics Issue #2 (p. 19) I'm not sure I understand the relationship between roadway connectivity and parks and open space acquisition. Does this refer to multi-modal, recreational trails? Issue #3 (p. 20) If a pedestrian/bicycle path could be located within a utility easement without burying the line, would this be acceptable? If burying utility lines is a mandate, then the high cost would likely delay indefinitely the implementation of the shared use of the easement for a walking/bicycling trail. Category 3 - Safety Issue #4 (pp. 26-27) What is the Puna Mauka Alternate Route and where would it go? There is no mention of it in the PRCP. Instead, the PRCP proposes several connections between the subdivisions. As noted in the PRCP report, even some of these "scaled-down" proposed connections were opposed by residents of the affected subdivisions. With respect to a referendum, does this suggest a non-binding measure? I don't believe there is legal authority to hold a binding referendum in a limited geographic area. Also, how would that area be defined? Issue #5 (p. 28) What is meant by "No Left Turn" corridor? If this means no left turns at successive intersections, then many drivers will have to make long, circuitous routes to reach a destination. Perhaps it would be better to create safer intersections with the use of signals or modern roundabouts, as suggested elsewhere in this report and in the TR-ER report. Category 4 - Connectivity and Efficiency Issue #2 (p. 33) It is highly unlikely that the County will ever derive enough tax revenue from the Puna district to purchase and improve all of the substandard roads in Puna's subdivisions. However, it may be feasible to improve some of the roads and provide additional infrastructure improvements in sections of these subdivisions through the creation of village centers via land pooling. We are conducting a pilot study of a section of Hawaiian Paradise Park to investigate the potential for using this approach. We expect to have the results in about a month or so. Also, the County could possibly acquire and improve sections of roadway that are necessary to promote connectivity. Issue #3 (p. 35) I suggest that the recommendation re bus stops be expressed in a positive manner: "Provide pull-overs on major highways for school and Hele-On buses" rather than "The County Council shall propose and enact legislation making stopping of any bus on major highways a traffic offense." Issue #7 (p. 42) How was the proposed compensation of 150% of fair market value derived? The procedures for determining value when government acquires property through eminent domain are well-established in statute and legal precedent. It is highly unlikely that this could be adjusted for a particular area or a particular purpose. Also, it assumes that all owners have the same degree of attachment to their property. Do absentee owners and investors have the same attachment as an owner-occupant? Does length of occupancy affect one's emotional attachment? Does the age of the occupant? There are many variables to consider other than monetary value. Also, there are many potential alternatives to direct compensation. For example, many vacant lots are available in Puna's subdivisions. It is quite possible that an owner might be happy if their house were relocated, especially if the new site had better access to services and infrastructure improvements. Land pooling is a potential method to accomplish this without using eminent domain. PlanPacific, Inc. 345 Queen Street, Suite 802 Honolulu, HI 96813 Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
