----------------------------------------------------
Subject was: TR overview, TR-ER
----------------------------------------------------


All references to the Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Existing 
Roadways Task Partnership Report can be accessed at the following URL:

Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Existing Roadways Task Partnership Report
Section II. PRIORITY #2 TRAFFIC CONGESTION
Page 12 of 28 thru Page 14 of 28
<http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportation-existing-roadways.pdf/view>


.
>At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote:
>
>TRAFFIC CONGESTION DUE TO COMMERCIAL ACTIVITY
>
>Recommendations ii and iii: I believe that elsewhere it has been 
>recommended that no new commercial uses be permitted direct access 
>to Highways 11 and 130.
.


Aloha John W,

The Existing Roadways Task Partnership has not mentioned new 
commercial uses anywhere else in our report.  Are you referring to 
another working group report, e.g. Land Use WG, perhaps?


.
>At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote:
>
>Do these recommendations refer to new developments that are using 
>existing access driveways or roads?
.


Our recommendations refer to future development, build-out of 
existing subdivisions and new commercial activity in the District of Puna.


.
>At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote:
>
>Would a roadway impact fee system fulfill the intent of these recommendations?
.


Our intent is to discourage and/or prohibit commercial development 
that would require ingress/egress along Highway 11 and Highway 
130.  We did not discuss roadway impact fees in our task partnership.

My limited understanding is that roadway impact fee systems are an 
attempt to see that "the growth pays for the growth" and that such 
fees are based on "the amount of roadway capactiy used by a 
development, measured in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT)" and the 
"developer's share of the average cost of capacity."

I am not qualified to say whether or not a roadway impact fee system 
would fulfull the intent of our recommendations or whether there are 
other means that would be superior to a roadway impact fee 
system.  Perhaps the Land Use WG has also addressed this issue.


.
>At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote:
>
>TRAFFIC CONGESTION DUE TO ROADWAY DESIGN
>
>I'm not sure how these recommendations would work, in practice.  At 
>present, the STIP is supposed to be based on County land use plans 
>and is reviewed by the County.  What County agency would have this 
>oversight authority, and would it necessarily result in better 
>highway planning?  County engineers may be just as resistant to 
>roundabouts as the DOT engineers, for example.
.


On November 3, 2006, members of the Puna CDP met with former County 
Council Member, Gary Safarik to discuss his perspective on 
transportation issues in the District of Puna.  Prior to that 
meeting, I would guess that most of us knew nothing about the STIP.

Mr. Safarik explained to us that the STIP is "basically a project 
list, prioritized for the different islands."  He offered suggestions 
on how the County of Hawai`i could work in partnership with the State 
to make the STIP voting/allocation of resources protocols more 
equitable for the Big Island, specifically Puna where roadway safety 
issues and potential growth are serious concerns.

He pointed out to us that a single vote for each island in making 
STIP decisions does not address the potential for a significant 
increase in population density and traffic volume on the Big 
Island.  He talked about how we need more meaningful representation 
on the STIP to ameliorate the disparity in the State's 
voting/allocation procedures.

Rather than me trying to interpret everything that Mr. Safarik 
suggested, may I send you a copy of the audio transcript of the "talk 
story" meeting on CD?  I think you will find it informative with 
respect to the STIP, as well as other transportation issues.



forward!
devotion, prema


_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to