General Observations
The major challenge to improving transit service in Puna, both at present and in the future, is the extensive land development pattern imposed by the nonconforming subdivisions. The rule of thumb is that a minimum development density of about 5 to 8 dwelling units per acre is needed to sustain a viable, efficient public transit system. While Puna's population is growing, the development density is much lower than this minimum, even if and when all of the existing subdivision lots are fully developed. At the recommendation of the Land Use Working Group, we will be looking at ways to create village centers to promote more transit-friendly land use. In the long run, this type of change will be necessary to support effective transit service in Puna. In the meantime, the County's Mass Transit Agency (MTA) has been attempting - commendably - to adapt its system to present land use conditions in order to improve transit service. I appreciate Frankie Stapleton's recent message explaining further the context and intent of the recommendations in the TR-MT report. This was helpful in preparing my following comments and questions on the recommendations. Comments/Questions on the Recommendations Recommendation 1: It's my understanding, from reading the 2005 paratransit study report and interviewing Tom Brown several months ago, that MTA intends to serve general ridership with its paratransit service, thereby complementing rather than duplicating the paratransit services provided by other service agencies for people with special needs. I also understand that MTA intends to develop the capacity to coordinate Hele-On and paratransit services via computer-assisted scheduling and dispatching. I will ask Tom to confirm my understanding. If he does, then this would appear to be consistent with the TR-MT recommendations. In terms of timetable, it is possible that these measures will be implemented prior to the adoption of the CDP. If so, the CDP could acknowledge that they have been put in place rather than call for them to be carried out. If not, it would be appropriate to include these recommendations in the CDP. Recommendation 2: Unlike Recommendation 1, which is focused on paratransit service in the Puna and Kona districts, the suggestions listed under Recommendation 2 have island-wide significance. System-wide measures for MTA - such as fleet inventories and changes to the composition and role of the Transportation Commission - are best presented in a forum other than the Puna CDP process because of their broader application. This is not meant to question the validity of these recommendations, just to advise that they are more likely to get attention if presented in another way, such as a recommendation directly to the Mayor and County Council. Recommendations 3, 4 & 5: Similar to the comment on Recommendation 1, I believe these proposals reflect MTA's intentions to create transit hubs at the towns of Keaau, Pahoa and Volcano and adjacent to Highway 130 near the Hawaiian Paradise Park and Orchidland subdivisions. Do the specific locations mentioned in this recommendation reflect MTA's current thinking or are they suggestions that came from your Working Group process? My understanding is that MTA will be going through a site selection process, possibly this year. There are many factors to consider in making site selections, so I would hope to defer to their review process. While it wasn't explicit in the recommendations, was the TR-MT Working Group thinking that there would be park-and ride facilities at each of these hubs, if feasible? Recommendations 6 & 7: Similar to comments on Recommendation 2, I believe these are suggested system-wide changes that should be considered outside the geography-limited context of the Puna CDP. Electronic ticketing systems are convenient for riders, but I am wondering whether existing or potential ridership on the MTA system is large enough to support the start-up cost. Even many much larger transit systems (e.g., Honolulu) have not yet implemented electronic ticketing due to cost constraints. Marketing campaigns can help increase ridership, but they, too, are costly. Improved service and competitive fares are the best marketing devices of all, so it would be wise to focus resources on those operational aspects to attract riders. In any case, the allocation of transit resources affects service throughout the island, so the decision should be made on a system-wide rather than regional basis. Recommendation 8: MTA is charged to - and in fact does - develop transit plans on a continuing basis, so it is not necessary to call for this in the CDP. If a reasonably feasible proposal is made by a potential private sector partner to develop a people-mover system in Puna to target the eco-tourism market, then MTA or another County agency could respond to the opportunity as it is presented. Honestly, I don't think such an opportunity will arise in Puna. The Waikaloa resort represents a very rare combination of circumstances - an ambitious developer with a broad vision to create a unique resort destination on a tract of land under single ownership, using abundant financing at low interest rates from foreign sources. Aloha, John W PlanPacific, Inc. 345 Queen Street, Suite 802 Honolulu, HI 96813 Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
