Aloha, Mr. Whalen...
I'd like to respond to your observations and questions re: the MT eval.

On Mar 7, 2007, at 7:07 PM, John P. Whalen wrote:

General Observations



The major challenge to improving transit service in Puna, both at present and in the future, is the extensive land development pattern imposed by the nonconforming subdivisions. The rule of thumb is that a minimum development density of about 5 to 8 dwelling units per acre is needed to sustain a viable, efficient public transit system. While Puna’s population is growing, the development density is much lower than this minimum, even if and when all of the existing subdivision lots are fully developed.

Your points re: the low density of the nonconforming subdivisions as well as the fact that our recommendations have islandwide significance and call for systemwide MTA changes outside the geographic Puna District were factors our working group members recognized and accepted as we studied the issues and developed our recommendations.

And, after reviewing issues from many different perspectives, that was the rationale for the very first statement in our MT recommendations calling for the proposed expansion of mass transit in Puna being a pilot project for the rest of the island. The conclusion was that what we're proposing would be helpful to the traffic crises in Kona and Waimea as well but there are less entrenched interests in Puna so it would be easier to demonstrate the validity of our recommendations if Puna was the guinea pig.

In our view, the next two years also present a unique opportunity for federal funding, even through federal avenues not specified in the Puna Regional Circulation Plan, for our proposals that are designed to help a significant portion of the public switch transportation modes and alleviate the negative impacts of peak hour traffic. Cynical as it may sound, that opportunity is the political jockeying on the federal level that will be taking place over the next 2 years for supremacy in the 2008 elections (presidential and legislative). It seems to us the timing is ripe for federal funding of mass transit and initiatives that reduce the consumption of fossil fuels. And the PRCP states in 12.3 that "there is a recent trend towards direct Congressional involvement in funding projects. These congressional 'earmarks' are separate from the Federal Highway Administration budget."


At the recommendation of the Land Use Working Group, we will be looking at ways to create village centers to promote more transit- friendly land use. In the long run, this type of change will be necessary to support effective transit service in Puna.

Again, agreed. But please review 11.3 of the PRCP. It says the Puna community cannot depend on the County to implement a village landuse scenario, that that takes private sector investment requiring "EXISTING concentration of people and dollars" which Puna does not have. But the whole island has major traffic issues and an MTA system that could be more fully utilized and give IMMEDIATE relief to some of these traffic problems.
        
In the meantime, the County’s Mass Transit Agency (MTA) has been attempting – commendably – to adapt its system to present land use conditions in order to improve transit service.
In several ways, our subcommittee stated its appreciation of the efforts of the County and MTA administrator Tom Brown in improving transit service. The strongest statement was in the first paragraph of our Mass Transit report following the mission statement. It was also stated in the lead paragraph of the MT executive summary (which then went on to describe a "disconnect" between the approach to mass transit of many of our local officials as compared to a majority of the Puna public's understanding and expectations of a MASS transit system).

Comments/Questions on the Recommendations

Recommendation 1: It’s my understanding, from reading the 2005 paratransit study report and interviewing Tom Brown several months ago, that MTA intends to serve general ridership with its paratransit service, thereby complementing rather than duplicating the paratransit services provided by other service agencies for people with special needs. I also understand that MTA intends to develop the capacity to coordinate Hele-On and paratransit services via computer-assisted scheduling and dispatching. I will ask Tom to confirm my understanding. If he does, then this would appear to be consistent with the TR-MT recommendations. In terms of timetable, it is possible that these measures will be implemented prior to the adoption of the CDP. If so, the CDP could acknowledge that they have been put in place rather than call for them to be carried out. If not, it would be appropriate to include these recommendations in the CDP.

With the greatest aloha for Tom Brown, he has been MTA deputy director or director since 1980, I think he told me. So he has served through the administrations of six different mayors. Mass transit was a ghost of a service until the current administration of Harry Kim. So it is Mayor Kim, Mr. Brown, and the County Councilmembers who voted for the establishment of Kokua ridership on the bus that we attribute the commendable expansion of MT services in the past five years.

However, when asked as to MT's top priority (in winter 2006), Mr. Brown said it was paratransit. We feel that is a misplaced TOP priority and it is the reason we stated repeatedly that public sentiment calls for increased transportation options for ALL Puna residents. (Politically and economically more expedient, as well.)

Our report also noted a "major disconnect" between County and State officials' views of mass transit and those expressed and expected by the public" (MT Executive Summary lead paragraph). The PRCP acknowledged that CAGs and the community recognize the higher pedestrian, bike and transit goals "will require a conceptual shift in the way transportation improvements are implemented." The PRCP itself states preferred plan Alternative E "does assert aggressive goals for multimodal ridership and transportation demand management (my note: both of which include increased emphasis on mass transit). However, these optimistic goals are set precisely to address the community values of the district and promote shifts in modes." (PRCP 11.2.2)

We do not fault the efforts of the past 5 years for the disconnect we discuss in our MT report. In fact, the progress toward increased emphasis on mass transit is a realistic response to the major problems -- environmental, social, economic, et al -- facing our community on every level, from neighborhoods to globally.

But the need to please so many political masters over time makes civil servants cautious. Our inquiries indicate Mr. Brown has promised many things to many people at different times and different places and while he has made great progress administratively in moving forward with the MT goals outlined in the PRCP, many sectors of our community feel it is not enough or he hasn't gotten the "big picture." My feeling is he hasn't felt he had the political bandwagon behind him to implement the big picture.

But to some, it feels like critical mass has been surpassed geopolitically and we wanted to use this process to be specific in our view of the "big picture" and provide support and justification for Mr. Brown as he goes before the local political powers to authorize these major changes. Larry Brown encouraged us in this effort, telling us our findings would be used to support the public officials trying to bring these changes about.

Mr. Whalen's comments continue:
Recommendation 2: Unlike Recommendation 1, which is focused on paratransit service in the Puna and Kona districts, the suggestions listed under Recommendation 2 have island-wide significance. System- wide measures for MTA – such as fleet inventories and changes to the composition and role of the Transportation Commission – are best presented in a forum other than the Puna CDP process because of their broader application. This is not meant to question the validity of these recommendations, just to advise that they are more likely to get attention if presented in another way, such as a recommendation directly to the Mayor and County Council.

Point well-taken and one I tried to help other WG and MTTP members understand in our earlier discussions.


Recommendations 3, 4 & 5: Similar to the comment on Recommendation 1, I believe these proposals reflect MTA’s intentions to create transit hubs at the towns of Keaau, Pahoa and Volcano and adjacent to Highway 130 near the Hawaiian Paradise Park and Orchidland subdivisions. Do the specific locations mentioned in this recommendation reflect MTA’s current thinking or are they suggestions that came from your Working Group process?
These were our group's suggestions. However, Tom Brown asked us for specific suggestions, and we ran into numerous instances in the past where the record indicates Mr. Brown asked various individuals and community groups for their suggestions of where park&rides, bus shelters, etc. should be placed. That was one of the reasons we felt we needed a permanent community advisory group (such as the Police Commission, the Committee on the Status of Women, etc.) for Transportation. And as we put that idea forward in our drafts and discussed it at our meetings, that's when Mr. Brown informed us there is already a Transportation Commission in place (extremely underutilized, in our view). (Appendices J and K)

In addition, members of the steering committee who attended some of our meetings said we should be specific in our suggestions, and implement benchmarks. We used specific deadlines for the implementation of some of our recommendations as our way of benchmarking, also to indicate the priority and order in which we felt some of these issues should be tackled. (Recommendations 1 and 2)

My understanding is that MTA will be going through a site selection process, possibly this year. There are many factors to consider in making site selections, so I would hope to defer to their review process. While it wasn’t explicit in the recommendations, was the TR-MT Working Group thinking that there would be park-and ride facilities at each of these hubs, if feasible?
Yes, and I apologize for my oversight in specifying that in my final report. It was discussed in earlier drafts and emails between members. The larger park&ride facilities should be at each of the hubs, with smaller P&Rs throughout Puna, ideally with at least one in each subdivision. Specific suggestions for P&Rs are listed in Consultant Questions #3. Security was the big issue with P&Rs so we felt they should be located adjacent to well-traveled, publicly visible sites.


Recommendations 6 & 7: Similar to comments on Recommendation 2, I believe these are suggested system-wide changes that should be considered outside the geography-limited context of the Puna CDP. Electronic ticketing systems are convenient for riders, but I am wondering whether existing or potential ridership on the MTA system is large enough to support the start-up cost. Even many much larger transit systems (e.g., Honolulu) have not yet implemented electronic ticketing due to cost constraints.
Obviously, a serious challenge for those recommending electronic ticketing. But it seems it would be easier to implement in a system going through major reconfiguration. And maybe there would be some federal funding available with the current emphasis on getting the American public out of private vehicles and into mass transit.

Marketing campaigns can help increase ridership, but they, too, are costly. Improved service and competitive fares are the best marketing devices of all, so it would be wise to focus resources on those operational aspects to attract riders. In any case, the allocation of transit resources affects service throughout the island, so the decision should be made on a system-wide rather than regional basis.
A absolutely brilliant statement: "Improved service and competitive fares are the best marketing devices of all." Especially in an island community, where word-of-mouth is the best marketing available!

You know, as a journalist, it always blew my mind how readily public officials and consultants felt they needed Madison Avenue-type approaches and massive $$$ for PR firms to convince the public of the validity of whatever was being pushed. Our report contains 16 ideas to help increase ridership (Consultant Question #1: How can people be encouraged to use buses).

Recommendation 8: MTA is charged to – and in fact does – develop transit plans on a continuing basis, so it is not necessary to call for this in the CDP.
Regarding Rec. 8, for months, we asked for immediate, mid- and long- range plans. Not only were these requests for information not forwarded by the liaison we were told to go through for information but after the request was put directly to Mr. Brown, we received a reply of barely more than one page (Appendix J) in which the answer to the MT goals outlined in the PRCP was primarily "ongoing."

If a reasonably feasible proposal is made by a potential private sector partner to develop a people-mover system in Puna to target the eco-tourism market, then MTA or another County agency could respond to the opportunity as it is presented. Honestly, I don’t think such an opportunity will arise in Puna.
We needed this kind of input. Thank you.

The Waikaloa resort represents a very rare combination of circumstances – an ambitious developer with a broad vision to create a unique resort destination on a tract of land under single ownership, using abundant financing at low interest rates from foreign sources.
Regarding the Waikoloa reference, we were not suggesting a Waikoloa type development. We just know from personal experience that when Waikoloa was developed, they brought in Disney consultants who designed the resort's boat system (possibly the train system and the hotel's "zoo" as well....I just didn't have personal knowledge of those features) and trained the personnel in how to maintain and run the system. And that was all the Disney people did...set up the system. Then they were gone. That's what we meant in our Waikoloa reference, using Disney-type professionals to set things up.

Some were looking to someone like Donald Trump seeing the validity of ecotourism attraction (and he was all over TV -- Oprah, Larry King Live, etc. -- a couple of years ago touting the east side of the Big Island as one of the best real estate investments anywhere! In fact, many here attribute our real estate boom (now bomb???) and the attendant inflated land prices to his widely publicized views.

What spurred the concept was a field trip trying to travel from the start of Railroad Avenue in Kapoho back toward Hilo. The trip was very like the Safari Jungle attraction at Disney World in Florida (and probably duplicated in similar attractions at other Disney parks worldwide). We were riding in a 4WD Trooper (4WD being absolutely necessary to the trip!) and going along RR Ave., through the unique terrain of the Kapoho eruption, beautiful ocean views, symmetrical papaya fields, jungle glory, et al. The ride was absolutely a NATURAL incarnation of the Safari Jungles created on a smaller scale at Disney parks around the world! We've got it here naturally and RR provides a readymade foundation for rail (which is what the RR right- of-way legally covers, correct?) and 4WD-type vehicles which the Safari Jungle attractions utilize.

So that's where that came from.

Hope this helps. Sorry to be so long-winded. Have a good weekend...gotta run. A hui hou, Frankie Stapleton


_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to