In previous posts the "Scope of Work for Transportation Subconsultant" indicated core issues, including: "Whether widening Highway 130 from two to four lanes obviates the need for the Puna makai alternate route."
It seems practicalreasonable to also look at: "Whether the Puna makai alternate route obviates the need for widening Highway 130 from two to four lanes." James Weatherford, Ph.D. P.O. Box 2017 [15-1888 6th Avenue (Hialoa), Hawai'ian Paradise Park] Kea'au, Hawai'i 96749 808-982-5549 -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of [EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, March 06, 2007 10:00 AM To: [email protected] Subject: Puna-wg-evaluation Digest, Vol 2, Issue 3 Send Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list submissions to [email protected] To subscribe or unsubscribe via the World Wide Web, visit https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation or, via email, send a message with subject or body 'help' to [EMAIL PROTECTED] You can reach the person managing the list at [EMAIL PROTECTED] When replying, please edit your Subject line so it is more specific than "Re: Contents of Puna-wg-evaluation digest..." Today's Topics: 1. Re: [Puna-WG-evaluation] TR overview, TR-ER (Dr. Keola G.A. Downing, Ph.D.) 2. Delete the [Puna-WG-evaluation] next time you reply (John Schinnerer) 3. Re: indicating comments (John Schinnerer) 4. Re: TR overview, TR-ER (John Schinnerer) 5. TR: Comments re TR overview (Prema) 6. TR: Scope of Work for Transportation Subconsultant (Prema) 7. TR-AC (John P. Whalen) 8. TR-ER: Traffic Congestion Along Roadways in Puna (Prema) 9. TR-ER: Quality of Existing Roadways in Puna (Prema) 10. TR-ER: Safety Along Roadways in Puna (Prema) 11. Citizens following the evaluation process via the message archives (Prema) 12. Re: TR: Scope of Work for Transportation Subconsultant (Larry Brown) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Message: 1 Date: Mon, 05 Mar 2007 11:14:51 -1000 From: "Dr. Keola G.A. Downing, Ph.D." <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [Puna-WG-eval] [Puna-WG-evaluation] TR overview, TR-ER To: Puna Working Group report evaluation list <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: https://www.hcrc.info/pipermail/puna-wg-evaluation/attachments/20070305/c0ca a6eb/attachment.htm ------------------------------ Message: 2 Date: Mon, 05 Mar 2007 11:43:44 -1000 From: John Schinnerer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] Delete the [Puna-WG-evaluation] next time you reply To: Puna Working Group report evaluation list <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii; format=flowed Aloha, Next time anyone replies to a message on this list please manually delete the extra text [Puna-WG-evaluation] from the subject line or it will keep appearing after the new shorter version of [Puna-WG-eval] mahalo, John S. HCRC/CDP technology services -- John Schinnerer - MA, Whole Systems Design ------------------------------------------ - Eco-Living - Whole Systems Design Services People - Place - Learning - Integration [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://eco-living.net ------------------------------ Message: 3 Date: Mon, 05 Mar 2007 12:07:59 -1000 From: John Schinnerer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [Puna-WG-eval] indicating comments To: Puna Working Group report evaluation list <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii; format=flowed Aloha, Dr. Keola G.A. Downing, Ph.D. wrote: >...Can > you please designate your comments in a specific color (blue for > example) so that it is clear what you are saying? List members please note when considering this suggestion that for those using only plain text e-mail this will not be visible. Additionally the appearance in the archives may differ and thus may not be visible to the general public either. It may also be problematic across different mail programs that do not render HTML or RTF e-mail identically...some will see it, some will not. Standard keyboard characters that will be visible to all readers (including in the archives) are suggested for indicating comments. Square brackets [this is a comment] may be suitable as they are not normally used much otherwise. Up to you all of course. cheers, John S. HCRC/CDP technology services -- John Schinnerer - MA, Whole Systems Design ------------------------------------------ - Eco-Living - Whole Systems Design Services People - Place - Learning - Integration [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://eco-living.net ------------------------------ Message: 4 Date: Mon, 05 Mar 2007 13:04:05 -1000 From: John Schinnerer <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [Puna-WG-eval] TR overview, TR-ER To: Puna Working Group report evaluation list <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=windows-1252; format=flowed Aloha, The "attached letter" referred to by John Whalen below is available for download here: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/report-evaluation/ACT -Letter-traffic-issues.pdf/view Reminder - this list is not intended for sending attachments. Message size is limited to 256KB. Documents relevant to the Puna WG evaluation process will be placed on the hcrc.info site and then you can put a link to them in your messages to the list. This also makes them publicly available, for citizens following the evaluation process via the message archives. For the moment, send any such documents to me for placement on the hcrc.info site. Going forward, relevant participants will learn how to do this themselves. mahalo, John S. HCRC/CDP technology services John P. Whalen wrote: > INTERSECTION SAFETY > > Issue #1: Up to 16 intersections are listed as candidates for > roundabouts (preferably) or other form of intersection control. That?s > a lot of locations, and the treatment may vary according to the > conditions and opportunities at each intersection. It will probably be > necessary to set some priorities among the intersections. Also, it > would be necessary to build a strong case for roundabouts on Highway 130 > to overcome DOT?s resistance to them (see attached letter.) This is a > major reason for re-focusing the transportation subconsultant?s scope of > work. > > -- John Schinnerer - MA, Whole Systems Design ------------------------------------------ - Eco-Living - Whole Systems Design Services People - Place - Learning - Integration [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://eco-living.net ------------------------------ Message: 5 Date: Mon, 05 Mar 2007 14:14:51 -1000 From: Prema <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] TR: Comments re TR overview To: Puna Working Group report evaluation list <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1"; format=flowed ---------------------------------------------------- Subject was: TR overview, TR-ER ---------------------------------------------------- >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >The first set of comments concern the >Transportation Working Group (TRWG) report ? >starting with the overview and existing roadway >sections. This is will be followed by comments >on the two other sections of the TRWG >report. I?m starting with these because we have >a subconsultant working on the follow-up to the TRWG recommendations. > >Comments below are organized according to section headings: > >Comments re TR overview: > >The breakdown of Small Group Meeting responses >in the overview section among the three Task >Partnerships ? showing that 54% of the comments >related to Existing Roadways, 27% related to New >Alternative Corridors, and 19% related to Mass >Transit ? is a useful way to establish >priorities for a transportation strategy. > >I am a little unclear about whether the >priorities identified within the Task >Partnerships were based on the Small Group >Meeting results or just the views of those who >participated in the Task Partnerships. Would >you please clarify this? I?m not suggesting >that the latter is ?bad?, only that it may not >be as reflective of broad community sentiment as the former. . Aloha John W, The priorities identified within the Puna CDP Transportation Working Group (WG) Task Partnerships were based on the following: 1) 680 transportation ideas, which are documented in the "3,394 Ideas from 130 Small Group Meetings" report* 2) previous development plans (including the Puna Regional Circulation Plan) 3) informal and formal consultations with residents of Puna 4) personal experience as residents of Puna References: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Final Report OVERVIEW Section: IV. Background: Community Issues, Table 4.1, Page 6 of 47 Section: VI. Previous Development Plans, Table 6.1, Page 8 of 47 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportatio n-overview.pdf/view Background: At our October 10, 2006 working group meeting, James Weatherford (our coordinator at that time) presented the enclosed rationale (see enclosure) for our working group breaking up into 5 subgroups, which were named task partnerships, as follows: 1. Existing Roads 2. Non-Motorized Modes 3. Mass Transit: Current Services 4. Mass Transit: New Initiatives 5. New Corridors In November 2006, we re-grouped into the current 3 task partnerships by folding the Non-motorized Modes [2] subgroup into the New Corridors Task Partnership [5] and combining the Mass Transit: Current Services [3] and Mass Transit: New Initiatives [4] into one subgroup, i.e. the Mass Transit Task Partnership. Reference: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Final Report OVERVIEW Section: III. Task Partnership Mission Statements, Page 5 of 47 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportatio n-overview.pdf/view In November 2006, each of our 3 subgroups was assigned the task of prioritizing the transportation themes within each task partnership (see enclosed), i.e. 367 Existing Roadways ideas; 182 New Alternative Corridors ideas and 131 Mass Transit ideas. Reference: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Final Report OVERVIEW Section: V. Background: Transportation Issues, Table 5.1, Page 7 of 47 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportatio n-overview.pdf/view Each of the Puna CDP Transportation WG task partnerships engaged in a formal facilitated process to categorize and prioritize the transportation themes. Reference: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Final Report OVERVIEW Section: VII. Transportation Task Partnership Themes, Table 7.1, Page 9 of 47 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportatio n-overview.pdf/view forward! devotion, prema ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Puna CDP Transportation Working Group October 10, 2006 ADOPTED RATIONALE FOR ORGANIZING INTO TASK PARTNERSHIPS Presented by James Weatherford, Puna CDP Transportation WG Coordinator [Oct. 2006 thru Dec. 2007] THEMES (original) o Safer Roads (paved, roundabouts, speed bumps, reflectors) o Alternate Route for Lower Puna o Widening of Highway 130 to 4 lanes o Alternate Route for Lower Puna o More Traffic Lights o Better Public Transportation Systems o Improved Bus Schedule with More Frequent Stops o Availability of Bus Stops/Shelters o Mini Shuttle Service o Availability of Park & Ride Service o More Sidewalks o Safe Bike Lane/Paths and Multi-mode Trails TASK PARTNERSHIPS (proposed) 1. Existing Roads + Upgrade: paving, speed bumps, reflectors, lines + Intersections: turn and merge lanes, roundabouts, signal lights + Highway Capacity (of 11 and 130): width of corridor and number of lanes + Street Lights 2. Non-Motorized Modes + Bicycle + Walking 3. Mass Transit: Current Services + Scheduling: times, routes + Accessibility: bus stops, shelters, information 4. Mass Transit: New Initiatives + Local and Special Services: feeder bus routes, paratransit + High-Capacity Rapid Transit: busway or rail + High Occupancy Vehicles: ride sharing, van pools + Park and Ride: for users of all categories of mass transit 5. New Corridors + Ala Puna Makai: Pahoa to Hilo + Connectivity: links mauka-makai, subdivisions and towns Notes: 1. The need for, and the County?s role in, maintenance, including paving, of roads in private subdivisions, is frequently mentioned. (There are a few mentions that cinder roads in subdivisions should not be paved so as to limit traffic and speeding). 2. Identification of specific issues regarding the need for more lanes, turn lanes, and better intersections, as well as interest in non-motorized transport, are overwhelmingly focused on Highway 130, emphasizing the critical role of this single corridor in mobility for the Puna District. 3. Emergency access on roads and emergency phones is an issue that occurred within comments on upgrade of existing roads, as well as comments about a new corridor in Puna makai and interconnectivity between subdivisions. 4. Decentralization of public and social services, commercial and cultural activities, and employment, so as to reduce the need for longer distance travel, are not considered here. These may be addressed by the Land Use and Economic Opportunity Working Groups. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ Puna CDP Transportation Working Group October 15, 2006 TASK PARTNERSHIP METHODOLOGY Presented by James Weatherford, Puna CDP Transportation WG Coordinator [Oct. 2006 thru Dec. 2007] Below are the proposed Task Partnerships, with the original ?Themes? provided by the County in brackets below. Note that points given in Theme #1, ?Safer Roads,? are divided between two different Task Partnerships. The objective was to consolidate the twelve Themes in the working group document into subgroups with commonality, as discussed at the working group meeting October 7. The sources used were: + The transportation section of the on-line document with the 3,394 ideas from 130+ small group meetings; + the spreadsheet, ?Themes from 130 Small Group Meetings?; and + the document distributed at the meeting, ?Working Group: Transportation" [Guidelines] First, the Task Partnerships (e.g., ?Existing Roads? and ?New Corridors?) were written to provide more uniform physical descriptions, with initiatives that are ?new? and those for ?current? or ?existing? infrastructure in separate tasks.. The original wording for the Themes was a mixture of physical descriptions, actions (e.g., ?widening?) and descriptions of needs (e.g., ?availability of bus stops.?) Second, the points under each of the five Task Partnerships is drawn substantially from the 679 transportation ideas that came directly out of the small group meetings (e.g., ?connectivity? and ?intersections?), as well as from common and practical terminology used in transportation planning (e.g., ?highway capacity,? ?upgrade,? ?accessibility,? ?feeder routes,? and ?high occupancy vehicles?). Third, the 679 transportation ideas from the small group meetings were carefully reviewed and compared with the ?Preliminary Themes.? Some resorting was done based on this review. Notably, among the ideas that had been categorized as ?Widening of Highway 130 to 4 lanes,? almost half proposed turn and merge lanes at intersections. Also, traffic lights and street lights, which serve entirely different purposes, had been grouped together as ?lights.? Finally, there is no prioritization applied. ------------------------------ Message: 6 Date: Mon, 05 Mar 2007 15:11:00 -1000 From: Prema <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] TR: Scope of Work for Transportation Subconsultant To: Puna WG Evaluation <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="iso-8859-1"; format=flowed ---------------------------------------------------- Subject was: TR overview, TR-ER ---------------------------------------------------- . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >I think it is important for the transportation >subconsultant to focus on the core issues of >highway intersections, alternative corridors and >interconnectivity, which are the priorities >identified by both the Small Group Meetings and >the Working Group. Also, it seems apparent that >this will probably require more than the two >community meetings described in the original scope for this consultant. . Aloha John W, Agreed. Highway intersections along BOTH Highway 130* and Highway 11*; alternative corridors in BOTH Puna Mauka and Puna Makai and interconnectivity between subdivisions throughout Upper Puna and Lower Puna are core transportation issues in the District of Puna. These issues deserve as much time and attention as you can spare in your consultant's budget. * Reference: Puna CDP Transportation WG EXISTING ROADWAYS Report Section: 1. INTERSECTION SAFETY, Page 4 of 28 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportatio n-existing-roadways.pdf/view Note: Item 1.a.i.1.d. (Opukahaia Road & Highway 130) should have been listed under Highway 130 intersections, instead of Highway 11. Also, thank you, very much, for including "modern roundabouts" in the evaluation process for both Highway 130 and the proposed Puna Makai alternative corridor. Please note preferred terminology is: "modern roundabouts" not "roundabouts". forward! devotion, prema +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: The overview section and the executive summaries of the task partnerships emphasize highway intersection controls (especially the use of roundabouts as an alternative to signalization) and connectivity in the circulation system. These are fundamental needs for improving transportation safety and convenience for all modes of travel, and for providing emergency access and evacuation routes, so the emphasis is appropriate. There are also many recommendations for enhancing multi-modal travel, including transit, bicycling and walking. These are all good objectives, but changes to the land development pattern in Puna ? particularly to create walkable ?village centers? ? will be key to making these ideas a reality. The Land Use Working Group report addresses this issue, and we will be following up with a pilot study of a portion of Hawaiian Paradise Park to look at the feasibility of applying ?land pooling? as a method to create village centers within existing, nonconforming subdivisions. Also, between the Puna Regional Circulation Study and the County?s recent paratransit study there are already significant proposed initiatives for multi-modal transportation that have yet to be implemented, so it would be good to start with those. Given the above observations, I think it is important for the transportation subconsultant to focus on the core issues of highway intersections, alternative corridors and interconnectivity, which are the priorities identified by both the Small Group Meetings and the Working Group. Also, it seems apparent that this will probably require more than the two community meetings described in the original scope for this consultant. Therefore, to keep within the budget allotted for this consultant, we have revised the scope as follows (with additions underscored and deletions noted in brackets): I. HIGHWAY 130 AND PUNA MAKAI ALTERNATE ROUTE A. Conduct traffic analyses to recommend: 1. Whether widening Highway 130 from two to four lanes obviates the need for the Puna makai alternate route; 2. If needed, the number of lanes for the Puna makai alternate route and whether the Puna makai alternate route should continue through Hawaiian Paradise Park; 3. Evaluate the need and optimal location for traffic signals and/or roundabouts along Highway 130 to enable turning movements from intersecting streets; 4. If the Puna makai alternate route must traverse Hawaiian Paradise Park, recommend alignment and context-sensitive design. B. Attend at least two public meetings to present findings. II. HIGHWAY 11 A. Evaluation of the cost-effectiveness of alternative connectors between Highway 11 and Highway 130 to alleviate congestion going to Keaau High School and Pahoa; B. Recommended mitigation measures to ease existing and future congestion. III. INTERCONNECTIVITY A. Evaluate existing street network and recommend interconnectivity system and standards. [Multi-modal and commercial center analyses are omitted.] ------------------------------ Message: 7 Date: Mon, 5 Mar 2007 19:45:52 -1000 From: "John P. Whalen" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] TR-AC To: "Puna CDP listserve" <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" As mentioned in my previous set of comments on the TR-ER task group report, the transportation subconsultant will address most of the TR-AC recommendations in his studies and public meetings, so the following are just some my own observations. At Keola's request, I am referencing the comments to the page numbers as well as the section headings in the TR-AC task group report so that it will be easier to follow the comments. Category 1 - Emergency Response Issue #2 (p.12) These recommendations (to increase County influence over decisions by DOT) are more likely to get attention if they are brought by your State legislators rather than made part of the CDP. The CDP holds no sway over the State, especially on matters that have statewide (not just Puna-wide) significance. Issue #3 (p. 14) The Puna Regional Circulation Plan (PRCP) recommended several emergency access routes (Figure 13.1 - Action Plan) that are similar - but not identical - to the ones listed in this section. Is there a reason why these recommendations differ? The transportation subconsultant could consider emergency routes that were not included in the PRCP, but some of the suggested routes could raise other concerns - for example, the alignment next to Wao Kele 'o Puna and the new corridor from Kalapana to Hilo could have unintended impacts on natural areas, in addition to being more expensive than the routes proposed in the PRCP. Category 2 - Aesthetics Issue #2 (p. 19) I'm not sure I understand the relationship between roadway connectivity and parks and open space acquisition. Does this refer to multi-modal, recreational trails? Issue #3 (p. 20) If a pedestrian/bicycle path could be located within a utility easement without burying the line, would this be acceptable? If burying utility lines is a mandate, then the high cost would likely delay indefinitely the implementation of the shared use of the easement for a walking/bicycling trail. Category 3 - Safety Issue #4 (pp. 26-27) What is the Puna Mauka Alternate Route and where would it go? There is no mention of it in the PRCP. Instead, the PRCP proposes several connections between the subdivisions. As noted in the PRCP report, even some of these "scaled-down" proposed connections were opposed by residents of the affected subdivisions. With respect to a referendum, does this suggest a non-binding measure? I don't believe there is legal authority to hold a binding referendum in a limited geographic area. Also, how would that area be defined? Issue #5 (p. 28) What is meant by "No Left Turn" corridor? If this means no left turns at successive intersections, then many drivers will have to make long, circuitous routes to reach a destination. Perhaps it would be better to create safer intersections with the use of signals or modern roundabouts, as suggested elsewhere in this report and in the TR-ER report. Category 4 - Connectivity and Efficiency Issue #2 (p. 33) It is highly unlikely that the County will ever derive enough tax revenue from the Puna district to purchase and improve all of the substandard roads in Puna's subdivisions. However, it may be feasible to improve some of the roads and provide additional infrastructure improvements in sections of these subdivisions through the creation of village centers via land pooling. We are conducting a pilot study of a section of Hawaiian Paradise Park to investigate the potential for using this approach. We expect to have the results in about a month or so. Also, the County could possibly acquire and improve sections of roadway that are necessary to promote connectivity. Issue #3 (p. 35) I suggest that the recommendation re bus stops be expressed in a positive manner: "Provide pull-overs on major highways for school and Hele-On buses" rather than "The County Council shall propose and enact legislation making stopping of any bus on major highways a traffic offense." Issue #7 (p. 42) How was the proposed compensation of 150% of fair market value derived? The procedures for determining value when government acquires property through eminent domain are well-established in statute and legal precedent. It is highly unlikely that this could be adjusted for a particular area or a particular purpose. Also, it assumes that all owners have the same degree of attachment to their property. Do absentee owners and investors have the same attachment as an owner-occupant? Does length of occupancy affect one's emotional attachment? Does the age of the occupant? There are many variables to consider other than monetary value. Also, there are many potential alternatives to direct compensation. For example, many vacant lots are available in Puna's subdivisions. It is quite possible that an owner might be happy if their house were relocated, especially if the new site had better access to services and infrastructure improvements. Land pooling is a potential method to accomplish this without using eminent domain. PlanPacific, Inc. 345 Queen Street, Suite 802 Honolulu, HI 96813 Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12 -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: https://www.hcrc.info/pipermail/puna-wg-evaluation/attachments/20070305/57b7 0348/attachment.html ------------------------------ Message: 8 Date: Mon, 05 Mar 2007 21:03:39 -1000 From: Prema <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] TR-ER: Traffic Congestion Along Roadways in Puna To: Puna WG Evaluation <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"; format=flowed ---------------------------------------------------- Subject was: TR overview, TR-ER ---------------------------------------------------- All references to the Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Existing Roadways Task Partnership Report can be accessed at the following URL: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Existing Roadways Task Partnership Report Section II. PRIORITY #2 TRAFFIC CONGESTION Page 12 of 28 thru Page 14 of 28 <http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportati on-existing-roadways.pdf/view> . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >TRAFFIC CONGESTION DUE TO COMMERCIAL ACTIVITY > >Recommendations ii and iii: I believe that elsewhere it has been >recommended that no new commercial uses be permitted direct access >to Highways 11 and 130. . Aloha John W, The Existing Roadways Task Partnership has not mentioned new commercial uses anywhere else in our report. Are you referring to another working group report, e.g. Land Use WG, perhaps? . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >Do these recommendations refer to new developments that are using >existing access driveways or roads? . Our recommendations refer to future development, build-out of existing subdivisions and new commercial activity in the District of Puna. . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >Would a roadway impact fee system fulfill the intent of these recommendations? . Our intent is to discourage and/or prohibit commercial development that would require ingress/egress along Highway 11 and Highway 130. We did not discuss roadway impact fees in our task partnership. My limited understanding is that roadway impact fee systems are an attempt to see that "the growth pays for the growth" and that such fees are based on "the amount of roadway capactiy used by a development, measured in Vehicle Miles Traveled (VMT)" and the "developer's share of the average cost of capacity." I am not qualified to say whether or not a roadway impact fee system would fulfull the intent of our recommendations or whether there are other means that would be superior to a roadway impact fee system. Perhaps the Land Use WG has also addressed this issue. . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >TRAFFIC CONGESTION DUE TO ROADWAY DESIGN > >I'm not sure how these recommendations would work, in practice. At >present, the STIP is supposed to be based on County land use plans >and is reviewed by the County. What County agency would have this >oversight authority, and would it necessarily result in better >highway planning? County engineers may be just as resistant to >roundabouts as the DOT engineers, for example. . On November 3, 2006, members of the Puna CDP met with former County Council Member, Gary Safarik to discuss his perspective on transportation issues in the District of Puna. Prior to that meeting, I would guess that most of us knew nothing about the STIP. Mr. Safarik explained to us that the STIP is "basically a project list, prioritized for the different islands." He offered suggestions on how the County of Hawai`i could work in partnership with the State to make the STIP voting/allocation of resources protocols more equitable for the Big Island, specifically Puna where roadway safety issues and potential growth are serious concerns. He pointed out to us that a single vote for each island in making STIP decisions does not address the potential for a significant increase in population density and traffic volume on the Big Island. He talked about how we need more meaningful representation on the STIP to ameliorate the disparity in the State's voting/allocation procedures. Rather than me trying to interpret everything that Mr. Safarik suggested, may I send you a copy of the audio transcript of the "talk story" meeting on CD? I think you will find it informative with respect to the STIP, as well as other transportation issues. forward! devotion, prema ------------------------------ Message: 9 Date: Mon, 05 Mar 2007 21:07:40 -1000 From: Prema <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] TR-ER: Quality of Existing Roadways in Puna To: Puna WG Evaluation <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"; format=flowed ---------------------------------------------------- Subject was: TR overview, TR-ER ---------------------------------------------------- All references to the Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Existing Roadways Task Partnership Report can be accessed at the following URL: Puna CDP Transportation Working Group Existing Roadways Task Partnership Report Section III. PRIORITY #3: QUALITY OF EXISTING ROADWAYS Page 15 of 28 thru Page 16 of 28 <http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportati on-existing-roadways.pdf/view> . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >ROADSIDE AMENITIES > >These suggestions would likely need to be part of a statewide >highway program, but I believe their implementation in Puna would >get very low priority compared to the need for highway intersection >improvements and the creation of alternate routes, which have high >capital costs. Among these suggestions, I would guess that >emergency phones in remote stretches of highway, especially in high >hazard areas, would be most likely to get priority. . Aloha John W, We were not actually advocating that structures be built on Highway 11/130, which would likely contribute towards traffic congestion and unsafe driving conditions. The amenities would be included as part of the off-highway bus terminals, bus stops and/or park/kiss and ride locations on County property near main bus routes. . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >ROADSIDE AMENITIES > >Recommendation ii is missing; was this a typo? . Yes. . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >Where would the lockable bike racks and pumping stations be >located? Why would they be located along the highway instead of, >say, in a village center? . Indeed, they could be located at village centers, too. We were considering bicyclists who use mass transit on existing roadways. The lockable bike racks and pumping stations would be provided as a public service to encourage multi-modal transportation and provide people who use bicycles with a safe place to store their bicycle. These services would be located on County property at bus terminals, bus stops and/or park/kiss and ride locations throughout the District of Puna. . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >ROADWAY AESTHETICS > >DOT has an "Adopt-a-Highway" program for public-private partnerships >to beautify highways. Unfortunately, DOT has lagged behind most >other states in getting a Scenic Byways program off the >ground. Once implemented, this would make designated scenic >roadways eligible for aesthetic enhancement funds. What particular >stretches of roadways in Puna do you think would be the best >candidates for Scenic Byway designation? The Cultural Resources >Working Group report contains documentation and recommendations for >the Puna Trail Historic Corridor. Would this be the leading candidate? The Puna Trail Historic Corridor application addresses a limited section of roadway 3.7 miles long. We are recommending that the full length of the old Government Beach Road be the leading candidate for a scenic byway designation. Please refer to Keola Downing's message: 2007/03/05 SUBJECT: Re: [Puna-WG-eval] TR overview, TR-ER Dr. Keola G.A. Downing, Ph.D. http://mail-archive.com/[email protected]/msg00026.html Our recommendations for improving the aesthetics of existing roadways are not limited to scenic byways. Aesthetic improvements are suggested for all major existing roadways, including Highway 130. For example, greenscaped medians separating opposing lanes of traffic and green barriers at the edge of highway right-of-ways would constitute aesthetic improvements. Reference: Puna CDP Transportation WG EXISTING ROADWAYS Task Partnership Report Section: IV. CONNECTIVITY, Page 17 of 28 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportatio n-existing-roadways.pdf/view forward! devotion, prema ------------------------------ Message: 10 Date: Mon, 05 Mar 2007 21:20:36 -1000 From: Prema <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] TR-ER: Safety Along Roadways in Puna To: Puna WG Evaluation <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"; format=flowed ---------------------------------------------------- Subject was: TR overview, TR-ER ---------------------------------------------------- Aloha John W, My responses to your questions regarding SAFETY issues will be sent as soon as the attachments are posted to the HCRC.info.site by John S. and I am able to link to them. forward! devotion, prema ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ >At 01:04 PM 3/5/2007, John Schinnerer wrote: > >Reminder - this list is not intended for sending attachments. >Message size is limited to 256KB. > >Documents relevant to the Puna WG evaluation process will be placed >on the hcrc.info site and then you can put a link to them in your >messages to the list. This also makes them publicly available, for >citizens following the evaluation process via the message archives. > >For the moment, send any such documents to me for placement on the >hcrc.info site. Going forward, relevant participants will learn how >to do this them ------------------------------ Message: 11 Date: Mon, 05 Mar 2007 21:38:55 -1000 From: Prema <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] Citizens following the evaluation process via the message archives To: Puna WG Evaluation <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"; format=flowed ------------------------------------------------ Subject was: Re: TR overview, TR-ER ------------------------------------------------ >At 01:04 PM 3/5/2007, John Schinnerer wrote: > >Documents relevant to the Puna WG evaluation process will be placed >on the hcrc.info site and then you can put a link to them in your >messages to the list. This also makes them publicly available, for >citizens following the evaluation process via the message archives. Aloha John S., Has anything been done to inform citizens of Puna about the existence of this mailing list? I am asking because I've spoken with residents who say that they are confused about what we are doing or they don't understand why they can't post or they are having trouble finding the archives. I am afraid that the general population is not aware of this mailing list and/or finding it difficult to access the message archives. ------------------------------------------------------------ SUGGESTION #1: Add a note on the HCRC.info Reports Webpage, located at <http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/>, which explains: 1) this phase of the Puna CDP process 2) the purpose and function of the Puna WG Evaluation mailing list archive. For example, citizens need to know that they cannot post messages but they can monitor the discussions. Also include the hyperlink: Puna WG Evaluation Mailing List Archives http://mail-archive.com/[email protected]/maillist.html ------------------------------------------------------------ SUGGESTION #2: Add another link, as suggested above, to: What's New? http://hawaiiislandplan.com/puna.asp ------------------------------------------------------------ SUGGESTION #3: Insert a note in the copies of the Puna CDP reports that are available at the libraries and County Planning Department to inform citizens, as suggested above. forward! devotion, prema ------------------------------ Message: 12 Date: Tue, 6 Mar 2007 08:17:35 -1000 From: "Larry Brown" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [Puna-WG-eval] TR: Scope of Work for Transportation Subconsultant To: "'Puna Working Group report evaluation list'" <[email protected]> Message-ID: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" I think that it is important to make sure that the recommendation by Parsons Brinckerhoff regarding whether or not the widening of Hwy 130 to 4 lanes obviates the need for a PMAR is not based solely on the level of service improvement of Hwy 130 due to widening. Adequate consideration needs to be given to the escalating need for redundancy as subdivision build-out increases. Larry -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Prema Sent: Monday, March 05, 2007 3:11 PM To: Puna WG Evaluation Subject: [Puna-WG-eval] TR: Scope of Work for Transportation Subconsultant ---------------------------------------------------- Subject was: TR overview, TR-ER ---------------------------------------------------- . >At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: > >I think it is important for the transportation >subconsultant to focus on the core issues of >highway intersections, alternative corridors and >interconnectivity, which are the priorities >identified by both the Small Group Meetings and >the Working Group. Also, it seems apparent that >this will probably require more than the two >community meetings described in the original scope for this consultant. . Aloha John W, Agreed. Highway intersections along BOTH Highway 130* and Highway 11*; alternative corridors in BOTH Puna Mauka and Puna Makai and interconnectivity between subdivisions throughout Upper Puna and Lower Puna are core transportation issues in the District of Puna. These issues deserve as much time and attention as you can spare in your consultant's budget. * Reference: Puna CDP Transportation WG EXISTING ROADWAYS Report Section: 1. INTERSECTION SAFETY, Page 4 of 28 Web: http://www.hcrc.info/cdp-documents/puna/working-groups/reports/Transportatio n-existing-roadways.pdf/view Note: Item 1.a.i.1.d. (Opukahaia Road & Highway 130) should have been listed under Highway 130 intersections, instead of Highway 11. Also, thank you, very much, for including "modern roundabouts" in the evaluation process for both Highway 130 and the proposed Puna Makai alternative corridor. Please note preferred terminology is: "modern roundabouts" not "roundabouts". forward! devotion, prema +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ At 02:30 PM 3/3/2007, John P. Whalen wrote: The overview section and the executive summaries of the task partnerships emphasize highway intersection controls (especially the use of roundabouts as an alternative to signalization) and connectivity in the circulation system. These are fundamental needs for improving transportation safety and convenience for all modes of travel, and for providing emergency access and evacuation routes, so the emphasis is appropriate. There are also many recommendations for enhancing multi-modal travel, including transit, bicycling and walking. These are all good objectives, but changes to the land development pattern in Puna - particularly to create walkable "village centers" - will be key to making these ideas a reality. The Land Use Working Group report addresses this issue, and we will be following up with a pilot study of a portion of Hawaiian Paradise Park to look at the feasibility of applying "land pooling" as a method to create village centers within existing, nonconforming subdivisions. Also, between the Puna Regional Circulation Study and the County's recent paratransit study there are already significant proposed initiatives for multi-modal transportation that have yet to be implemented, so it would be good to start with those. Given the above observations, I think it is important for the transportation subconsultant to focus on the core issues of highway intersections, alternative corridors and interconnectivity, which are the priorities identified by both the Small Group Meetings and the Working Group. Also, it seems apparent that this will probably require more than the two community meetings described in the original scope for this consultant. Therefore, to keep within the budget allotted for this consultant, we have revised the scope as follows (with additions underscored and deletions noted in brackets): I. HIGHWAY 130 AND PUNA MAKAI ALTERNATE ROUTE A. Conduct traffic analyses to recommend: 1. Whether widening Highway 130 from two to four lanes obviates the need for the Puna makai alternate route; 2. If needed, the number of lanes for the Puna makai alternate route and whether the Puna makai alternate route should continue through Hawaiian Paradise Park; 3. Evaluate the need and optimal location for traffic signals and/or roundabouts along Highway 130 to enable turning movements from intersecting streets; 4. If the Puna makai alternate route must traverse Hawaiian Paradise Park, recommend alignment and context-sensitive design. B. Attend at least two public meetings to present findings. II. HIGHWAY 11 A. Evaluation of the cost-effectiveness of alternative connectors between Highway 11 and Highway 130 to alleviate congestion going to Keaau High School and Pahoa; B. Recommended mitigation measures to ease existing and future congestion. III. INTERCONNECTIVITY A. Evaluate existing street network and recommend interconnectivity system and standards. [Multi-modal and commercial center analyses are omitted.] _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation ------------------------------ _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation End of Puna-wg-evaluation Digest, Vol 2, Issue 3 ************************************************ _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
