Aloha John,

Aloha, Keola Downing here,

John,  I want to respond to your comment concerning the attached appendix document on the Puna Trail Historic Corridor, and the concept of a Scenic Byway.

[ The Cultural Resources Working Group report contains documentation and recommendations for the Puna Trail Historic Corridor.  Would this be the leading candidate?]

I want to insure you understand that we included that document in both the Culture and Historic Preservation Working Group and the New Alternative Corridors Task Partnership by request of the concerned citizens who support that document.  This courtesy was made for these folks to include their mana`o as additional material added to our appendix, and does not represent any recommendation from either the New Alternative Corridors Task Partnership or Na Pua Ho`omalu.  We felt that you needed to know about this project since they have gone to DLNR and other government entities with their proposal several times in the past.  They are likely to do so again if they feel that the Puna CDP will impact their project negatively.

I felt that the information and strong feelings from these individuals was important to include in the appendix of our report.  I do not agree with all of their points of view, and personally feel the importance of getting a Scenic Byways program off the ground may indeed include paving the entire Government Beach Road in a very limited and environmentally appropriate way.  This is completely at odds with the program to prevent paving the Puna Trail Historic Corridor.  That 3.7 mile stretch of roadway will either require lots of continuous grading and quality road care, or else it should be paved to allow for emergency access in times of natural disaster or roadway closure on Hwy 130 and 132.

As a Scenic Byway, Government Beach Road would allow access to several locations that were mentioned as possible new Park and Recreation areas along the shoreline.  I'm sure that you can see the inevitable conflict that could arise, and that is why their material was included in our reports.  Although the whole of Government Beach Road has great potential as a prime connector route between the subdivisions and a beautiful drive along the ocean front, the Puna Trail Historic Corridor may well be an area that requires special consideration.  Visitors, local fishermen and all kinds of people who want to use the public access to the sea cliffs along Government Beach Road deserve to have the whole of that historic roadway opened up all the way to the sea port at Hilo bay.

Along with the development of a Scenic Byway program, we will also have to insure that there are access points and public pathways to the shoreline, including rest stops with bathrooms and telephones much like they have elsewhere throughout the State.  With our wonderful weather,  the opportunity to go to the ocean side Parks and be able to go to the bathroom or shower will bring a little bit of "recreation equity" for the citizens of Puna.  This will help to make a level playing field in that regard with the rest of the Big Island locations that already have such amenities.

I may want to respond to other comments that were made, but will hold off on that for the time being.  I wanted to just mention that I find it very cumbersome
to read your comments and know what you are mentioning from the report or from some other documentation and what you are just saying from your own point of view.  Would it be possible to have a protocol to allow anyone who is reading the posts to this list know "who" is talking?  Can you please designate your comments in a specific color (blue for example) so that it is clear what you are saying?  That would help a lot to make the discussion more understandable to those who are signed up to follow your ongoing work.  Clear reference by page number would also aid the reader in understanding which areas of the report you are mentioning.  Most of us will have to open up a second window to reference the area of the electronic version of the report you are talking about.  I know that I was in attendance at all three Task Partnerships at one point or another, and could really use a quick quote or reference to a specific page when you are asking questions or making comments that require a response.

Mahalo,
Keola Downing
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to