This is the last of comments on the individual WG reports. I've lumped several together, which are organized in alphabetical order of the WG's "code" letters.
AE - ALTERNATIVE ENERGY Overall comment: There were several proposals to promote the use of renewable energy sources, but I am curious about the omission of geothermal energy. Did the WG cover this topic? AG - AGRICULTURE Recommendation 2: These are interesting suggestions, but all of them have island-wide applicability. Proposed changes to the valuation methods for agricultural land would obviously have significant implications for the County's tax base and revenue stream. The other proposals would probably have lesser fiscal impact. As I mentioned in my posting a few days ago, I will make no unilateral decisions about what should or should not be included in the CDP, but I question whether the CDP should contain such specific proposals of island-wide significance. Recommendation 3: I'm not sure how "essential agricultural land" corresponds to "important agricultural land". The latter (IAL) is defined and mapped in the General Plan. As I read the description in AG-WG report, "essential agricultural lands" seems to include much more area than IAL. I am not sure how to develop an accurate map of these areas. In any event, intent of the CDP is follow the policy guidance of the General Plan, so I believe the IAL definition prevails unless the General Plan is amended. Recommendation 4: We are preparing a map that shows what areas would be candidates for rezoning to implement this proposal. I will ask that it be posted on the website. I am unclear how the County would have the legal authority to force the consolidation of two adjoining, existing parcels (Recommendation 4.2.2.) Am I reading this correctly? Recommendation 5: Do the three proposed locations for farmers' markets assume that Maku'u will continue in operation? Did the WG have any thoughts about how to "leverage private investment in the farmers' market sites"? Public funds (federal, state, county) could play a part, as well. Recommendation 6 & 7: These are worthy proposals, but the State is a more appropriate source of funding than the County because it has a much larger tax base and is directly responsible for supporting agricultural development and providing agricultural education and extension services. CH - CULTURAL/HISTORIC PRESERVATION Overall comment: This report proposes several ambitious organizational changes at the County level that will probably encounter resistance due to cost and/or overlap with State responsibilities - i.e., creation of a County Department of Antiquities and Aesthetics, a Puna Cultural Council, and two Puna Community Council (mauka and makai). While I understand that members of the three new councils would be volunteers, some staff support would be necessary. I am not suggesting that the intent and purpose of these proposed bodies be abandoned, only that there are alternatives that have a greater chance of being implemented. For example, the County Department of Parks and Recreation's existing culture and arts unit could be expanded to include new activities and responsibilities proposed in the WG's recommendations for an education program. Eventually, as public support for this program builds, a new agency could be created to administer it, if necessary. Similarly, the County could take the first step toward creation of a cultural council by applying for Certified Local Government (CLG) status with the State Historic Preservation Division, as the counties of Kaua'i and Maui have. This would also give the County access to a small amount of federal funding, via the State. One of the pre-requisites for CLG status is the formation of a County-level historic and cultural preservation advisory body. More information on CLGs can be found at the following link: http://www.hawaii.gov/dlnr/hpd/hpgreeting.htm PI-MD - PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE-MEDICAL FACILITIES Overall comment: I agree that Wai'anae Coast Comprehensive Health Center (WCCHC) may be a good model for Puna. The population sizes and characteristics of these two districts are somewhat similar. WCCHC is also a good example of starting small on site that is publicly owned. At the time it was established, however, it had sources of funding (e.g., Model Cities) that are no longer available, so some new source would have to be found. I appears that the WG favors Hawaiian Homelands (DHHL) properties in the Maku'u and Volcano areas. Has anyone from the WG contacted DHHL about the potential availability of a site for this purpose at either location? PK - PARKS AND RECREATION Overall comment: This report does a good job of providing a policy framework for the park system, followed by recommendations for specific parks projects. The parks typology is useful, covering a good range of recreational opportunities. Prioritized Projects: Hawaiian Paradise Park could certainly use a park, but it may not be practical to provide a swimming pool there. Swimming pools are costly to build, operate and maintain, so it would be appropriate to locate them where they are readily accessible to most Puna residents and would get a lot of use. Alternative locations to consider would be Keaau and/or Pahoa High Schools, where the pools could by used jointly by school and the community under a cost-sharing agreement between DOE and the County. SS - SOCIAL SERVICES Sections 1 (Substance Abuse Treament/Prevention) and 2 (Housing): Would the County-owned site in Pahoa be a good location for the One-Stop Center? Any thoughts about other potential locations? Are there any special considerations about the location of the residential treatment homes, given that neighbors sometimes fiercely object to having these homes nearby? If the homes were small - no more than 5 residents - and licensed by the State, they could be established without a public hearing or special permit from the County. Whew!! , John PlanPacific, Inc. 345 Queen Street, Suite 802 Honolulu, HI 96813 Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
