AG - These are my thoughts/comments on comments from
John Whalen, on Agricultural Lands
A Puna CDP glossary of land use terms would be helpful
so that everyone is talking about the same thing,
using the same examples. TMKs matched to terms
defined by HRS, COH and CDP working groups or the
general public would make for a great database. The
ultimate goal is to add one more data fields to the
existing parcel data layer the county real property
office keeps, that labels lands according to approved
land uses, including but not limited to the following
terms (that require definition) for the purpose of
this Puna CDP:
Essential Ag Lands
Important Ag Lands
Extensive Ag Lands
Native Forest Residential
Native Forest Farm
Native Forest Dedication
However, all of this is undergoing transition in the
current legislative session. If HB1901 and SB1219 are
passed, there will be less protection for any lands
now classed agriculture, as they will be further
reduced to rural. Urbanites and commerce, maybe
resorts and golf courses, will sprawl into what is
called by residents now, the ag lands. Farmers will
eventually feel the negative effects of urban
encroachment.
I believe the intent of the ag working group is to
(this may not be accurate, but it was my impression)
protect the small farm lifestyle in Puna, to make Puna
self-sufficient with bountiful harvests and a wide
variety of fresh goods enough to feed all of the
state, and to ensure there are lands and good
educational programs for future farmers, for decades
to come.
It also seems that there is an underlying fear that
there will be more people and less farming if current
trends continue. The small or no land owner
population will eventually become completely dependant
on goods from 2,000 to 3,000 miles away and there will
be less people producing food locally, since land
values will be too high. We are trying to avoid this
certain disaster. Re-classifying native habitat to
rural, upzoning and subdividing carte-blanche is a
huge mistake and it will kill the true definition of
rural once and for all time, but we can prevent it
from happening by maintaining the County (yet to be)
approved land use categories that protect lands in
spite of anything the legislature will do this season
or later on. The database would be helpful here too.
Redup.: Properly define those categories or zones,
and b) identify those lands by tmk.
Then plan farmers market locations, ag-parks,
home-farms, private conservation reserves, and tax
incentives. If we have a good master plan (Puna
CDP), then we can take that to the legislature to
request help in the development of these kinds of (ag
or industrial) parks and training programs, and also
start earning support from other agencies or
organizations too. This ag lifestyle thing in
combination with Land-Use Preserving Land, Air and
Water, and Natural Resources, could make for a great
infrastructure or economic base for Puna, based on
health. It doesnt look like much when its all
apart, but putting the pieces together creates some
grand visions. We need County Council to support the
PCDP and not the State in order to overcome the
effects of these two bills.
Comments welcomed.
Thanks,
Kim (on Agricultural Lands report eval feedback)
--- "John P. Whalen" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> This is the last of comments on the individual WG
> reports. I've lumped
> several together, which are organized in
> alphabetical order of the WG's
> "code" letters.
>
>
>
>
> AG - AGRICULTURE
>
>
>
> Recommendation 2: These are interesting
> suggestions, but all of them have
> island-wide applicability. Proposed changes to the
> valuation methods for
> agricultural land would obviously have significant
> implications for the
> County's tax base and revenue stream. The other
> proposals would probably
> have lesser fiscal impact. As I mentioned in my
> posting a few days ago, I
> will make no unilateral decisions about what should
> or should not be
> included in the CDP, but I question whether the CDP
> should contain such
> specific proposals of island-wide significance.
>
>
>
> Recommendation 3: I'm not sure how "essential
> agricultural land"
> corresponds to "important agricultural land". The
> latter (IAL) is defined
> and mapped in the General Plan. As I read the
> description in AG-WG report,
> "essential agricultural lands" seems to include much
> more area than IAL. I
> am not sure how to develop an accurate map of these
> areas. In any event,
> intent of the CDP is follow the policy guidance of
> the General Plan, so I
> believe the IAL definition prevails unless the
> General Plan is amended.
>
>
>
> Recommendation 4: We are preparing a map that shows
> what areas would be
> candidates for rezoning to implement this proposal.
> I will ask that it be
> posted on the website. I am unclear how the County
> would have the legal
> authority to force the consolidation of two
> adjoining, existing parcels
> (Recommendation 4.2.2.) Am I reading this
> correctly?
>
>
>
> Recommendation 5: Do the three proposed locations
> for farmers' markets
> assume that Maku'u will continue in operation? Did
> the WG have any thoughts
> about how to "leverage private investment in the
> farmers' market sites"?
> Public funds (federal, state, county) could play a
> part, as well.
>
>
>
> Recommendation 6 & 7: These are worthy proposals,
> but the State is a more
> appropriate source of funding than the County
> because it has a much larger
> tax base and is directly responsible for supporting
> agricultural development
> and providing agricultural education and extension
> services.
>
> '''
>
>
>
> Whew!! , John
>
>
>
> PlanPacific, Inc.
>
> 345 Queen Street, Suite 802
>
> Honolulu, HI 96813
>
> Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12
>
>
>
> > _______________________________________________
> Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
> [email protected]
>
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
>
____________________________________________________________________________________
Need Mail bonding?
Go to the Yahoo! Mail Q&A for great tips from Yahoo! Answers users.
http://answers.yahoo.com/dir/?link=list&sid=396546091
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation