Aloha Rob, Since responding to your initial idea, I've been reading some of the other comments it has spawned. I see the value in your suggestion in the resulting dialogue and hope that it will progress into some fruitful action.
Too many of us that have embraced this community planning effort and participated enthusiastically in the process repeatedly agree that more participation by more folks is a good thing and that we need to be able to document that our efforts are truly representative of the community as a whole to ensure adoption by the political element. It is true that putting out press releases, doing newspaper and radio interviews, posting flyers all over the district and notifying community associations will not be much more effective in broadening our outreach than what we have achieved so far. What I hoped to convey to the SC and attending public at last week's SC meeting was that we, as truly concerned CDP participants need to do is personally reach out to our family, friends, and neighbors to encourage their participation. Call them on the phone, stop by and visit, bring it up at church or with acquaintances in the grocery store check out line. I think I see enough sincere and capable people actively engaged in the PCDP to make a difference this way. Perhaps some will be more comfortable spearheading a CDP fair, which can also draw more of our neighbors into the process in at least a minimal way. I was very disappointed that more folks didn't jump on the idea of holding a WG Congress. I will always stand ready to provide whatever assistance from the Planning Department that my position will allow when it comes to ensuring that we have a process that is as inclusive as possible. However, I really believe that the community needs to step up to the plate and recognize that government will not always be as responsive as we would like and be ready to forge ahead with ideas and efforts that we know are the right thing to do. Do not underestimate the resources within the community. Thanks again for stimulating discussion and please don't ever hesitate to suggest something new for all of us to consider in making this process as effective as possible. Larry -----Original Message----- From: Rob Tucker [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, April 25, 2007 9:02 AM To: Larry Brown Subject: Re: 2 SC suggestions from Rob Tucker I kind of agree with you on all that. And I am merely proposing a mechanism to try to improve participation. Frankly I do no envision enough money available to actually attract people with a profit motive. My suggestion is primarily intended to place some nominal financial value as prima face proof that the input has value. Remember that input has been gathered before and ignored. More than once. And there is an air of it happening again. There may be other, more effective suggestions on how to improve involvement. If they are free and effective - then wonderful. In the land use group I was confronted with "what about the people who don't show up and participate?" What about those who do? Is their effort and work actually depreciated by the lack of effort on the part of the masses? If so we all wasted our time (again?). My response was that no one was excluded who showed the least interest. People could come to meetings, email, write, ask for a ride, ask for a baby sitter and all would have been accommodated. Those who came came. I've heard it mentioned that participants are "special interests". I suspect each and everyone of fits that term in one way or another. So Larry, please to not take my suggestions personally. They are not intended to offend. They are sincere suggestions intended to, at least, spur thinking. Most likely the result will be the result whatever we do because the percentage of the population which is informed enough and interested enough to take the time have already presented themselves and taken the time. We will see how much traction my suggestion gets with Mainstreet Pahoa Assoc. as we approach the i ssue of a Design District. Don't ask me to predict. Aloha, Rob On Apr 25, 2007, at 8:47 AM, Larry Brown wrote: > Aloha Rob, > > Thanks for your input. I agree that we need to try different things to > broaden our involvement by the community and I am always interested in > hearing about innovative methods we can employ to further engage the > members > of our community in planning for the future of our island. > > However, I must admit that I am initially repulsed by the idea that we > need > to pay citizens to participate in a process designed to make their and > their > children's lives better. Should we also pay citizen's to vote? > > I really believe that much of what is wrong with our society is that > too > many of us expect some immediate reward for every little effort we put > forth. We collectively shirk our responsibility as members of > something > larger than our individual selves and respond almost exclusively to > that > which provides the most immediate gratification. Is catering to such > an > attitude conducive to sincere community empowerment? I would rather > put > whatever additional funding and effort we can muster into promoting a > community planning or CDP fair where families can gather to engage > their > neighbors in assessing the progress of the CDP process and provide > input on > the developing product. I also believe that this sort of event should > be > primarily a citizen effort with some financial and logistical support > from > the government to facilitate its success. > > Larry > > -----Original Message----- > From: Rob Tucker [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Saturday, April 21, 2007 10:39 AM > To: Kim Tavares; Larry Brown > Subject: 2 SC suggestions from Rob Tucker > > Aloha Kim and Larry, > > I am writing you because I believe you both have an objective ear. I > have two suggestions to make for the SC/County CDP. > > 1. Letter to Council on up zoning: I haven't read the draft but I > recommend using the work "defer" in lieu of "moratorium". > > 2. This next round of "community input". It appears that there is > danger that all t his CDP effort will be diluted by lack of broad > participation. That is the impression I get from the planned 2nd round > of input and a call for new faces. > > I think that putting up posters for the upcoming three input sessions > and, as Larry said, wanting to see people other than the same faces > will produce marginal results. I am launching a Pahoa CDP and we need > extensive participation too. What I will be proposing in Pahoa Village > is to pay people to respond. It might be $2 or it might be $5 for a > completed questionnaire. COuld be ten questions, could be fifty, > could be a fill in the blanks.... whateva > > This is an 'out out of the box' suggestion. This is a "put your money > where your mouth is" suggestion. If the county needs and values > community input then pay people for their input. It produces a number > of impacts.... it shows people that their input is not just someone > else's grant fulfillment project... it shows that their opinion is > valued even it it is just $2 cash, it gets a lot of press and > attention. If you can only come up with $20k say the first 10k(?) > people get the money. It is trickle down. I intend to try to try it > in Pahoa. I think the county should try it. If you want different > results you need to try something different. > > Spend a nickel. > > Aloha, > > Rob > > > _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
