Aloha Rob, Thanks for your commitment to this process. In one of your responses you said: "Most likely the result will be the result whatever we do because the percentage of the population which is informed enough and interested enough to take the time have already presented themselves and taken the time."
I don't agree with this. In fact it is statements such as this that have been interpreted as arrogance. There are those that have lived here many years. I consider myself somewhat of an expert witness on puna. (My niche of it, and some other places.)There are those in puna that have lineage back to times when my great great great granparents were still farming in the old country of russia. Just because they aren't coming out, doesn't mean they are not informed or that they are uninterested. If i wasn't actively involved in this process and read the above statement you made...whoa! that would keep me away for sure. I believe that i have insights into what some people want just by my living here in Puna as i have.(That doesn't mean what i believe is true for others.) I think about what is happening with the new folks? For purpose of discussion, lets say we are focusing in on those who have made their homes in Puna in the past 3-5 years.I observe that some were never taught stuff, they aren't bad people, they just don't understand the ways of Puna. They don't understand about simple things like how to locate a house on the land so you don't need the ceiling fan on all the time to stay cool. I've been here about half my life, in a sense i grew up here., and I am still learning. Yes some are uninformed. Local folks have shared with me that some people involved in the PCDP are actually the uninterested and an uninformed. They think these people know what is best for the aina...for Puna... yet they haven't lived here in some cases more than a few seasons. They come here and start planning what is "best". They think Aloha means hello, love and goodbye. A little knowledge can be dangerous. So where are we? We live in Puna. We are priviledged. I believe it is our sacred responsiblity to be stewards to this place we call home. It is our sacred responsibility to honor and respect those who came before us...the culture and hertiage....the people...the trees..the water. It isn't easy to invest hours into outreach....but ya know...we do it everyday. At the Keaau farmers market, talkin to a hitchhiker, as i help a mom juggle groceries as she manages her two tired hungry keikis. We all do it! Some of us have extending out of my niches. I have spoken to folks whose home /frontyards ARE 130. They haven't been to any meetings but i have listened to them (filipino, japanese,hawaiian) They have spoken in their own way, and in their own time. Others have done the same. Keep the faith Rob! Do what you can. If we all do our part in the outreach...off line...things will continue to gel. Have the people that hang out in pahoa at the bar and on the street been outreached to?..How about the druggies? they are all part of our Puna! Now thats a target audience...:)... Two questions: what does prima faca mean? I couldn't find it in pidgin to da max...:) Second who is offering babysitting for free for those who might have asked for babysitting so they can come to meetings? Be well Rob....your effort are noticed-stephanie On 4/27/07, Larry Brown <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
In order for any of our CDPs to be truly effective, community outreach and widespread participation needs to be an ongoing process. Even if government is capable of implementing all of the recommendations in a CDP, is that really what we want? It will take more than the "squeeking wheel" of a few voices to ensure that government does its part in implementing OUR plan. One way for the community to effectively engage in implementation is to ensure broad-based support and participation. One way to create and sustain that is through the creation, maintenance and frequent use of a comprehensive communications network that is not dependent on government or the bureaucracy that can be effective despite whomever the next CDP Project Manager, Planning Director or Mayor might be. The main reason this outreach push is happening at this time is due to the recognition that some really significant decisions need to be made regarding our transportation needs in Puna. Previous efforts to address these needs were effectively minimized primarily through the successful misrepresentation that widespread community input was not sought out and considered. The reality is that too many folks won't participate until they perceive a negative impact on their lives is immanent. Whatever is decided about future roadways and issues about connectivity will require consensus because many of those folks that will experience the negative impacts of those decisions are going to object loudly. And, in my opinion, the political reality is that without consensus government is unlikely to embrace any plan, especially an expensive one, regardless of how great the need being addressed or how much sense it makes. Mahalo, Larry ------------------------------ *From:* [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto: [EMAIL PROTECTED] *On Behalf Of *JoAnne Backman *Sent:* Friday, April 27, 2007 9:42 AM *To:* Puna Working Group report evaluation list *Subject:* Re: [Puna-WG-eval] 2 SC suggestions from Rob Tucker I completely agree with having an inclusive process and outreach, however, I am wondering what the objective of the push is at this point in the process. If, more people from different segments of the community were reached and provided new input significantly different from what has already been gathered and from which the WG reports were drafted what would be the end result? Would the new data be factored into the Consultants final package? Would the working groups reports be revised? It might motivate SC and WG members, who also have limited time and resources, to get more involved in outreach efforts if they knew it would be beneficial to the process and not just an exercise in futility resulting in wasted time and effort. Aloha, J. ----- Original Message ----- *From:* Larry Brown <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> *To:* 'Puna Working Group report evaluation list'<[email protected]> *Sent:* Friday, April 27, 2007 9:19 AM *Subject:* Re: [Puna-WG-eval] 2 SC suggestions from Rob Tucker Thank you Prema. You make an excellent suggestion. However, we need the SC & WG members and others that sincerely want to ensure this process is as inclusive as possible to take a more active role in following through on these ideas. It would be great if we had the staff resources in the Planning Dept. to do that, but the reality is that we don't. HCRC did a commendable job in our initial outreach efforts, but their resources are also limited, especially when we acknowledge that CDP efforts are ongoing in five districts. I will provide all the support I can for legitimate outreach efforts, including, but not limited to, having letters and invitations going out on County letterhead, printing notices, etc. Larry -----Original Message----- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Prema Sent: Wednesday, April 25, 2007 10:03 AM To: Puna Working Group report evaluation list Subject: Re: [Puna-WG-eval] 2 SC suggestions from Rob Tucker >At 09:35 AM 4/25/2007, Larry Brown wrote: > >Too many of us that have embraced this community planning effort and >participated enthusiastically in the process repeatedly agree that more >participation by more folks is a good thing and that we need to be able to >document that our efforts are truly representative of the community as a >whole to ensure adoption by the political element. It is true that putting >out press releases, doing newspaper and radio interviews, posting flyers all >over the district and notifying community associations will not be much more >effective in broadening our outreach than what we have achieved so far. >What I hoped to convey to the SC and attending public at last week's SC >meeting was that we, as truly concerned CDP participants need to do is >personally reach out to our family, friends, and neighbors to encourage >their participation. Call them on the phone, stop by and visit, bring it up >at church or with acquaintances in the grocery store check out line. I >think I see enough sincere and capable people actively engaged in the PCDP >to make a difference this way. Perhaps some will be more comfortable >spearheading a CDP fair, which can also draw more of our neighbors into the >process in at least a minimal way. I was very disappointed that more folks >didn't jump on the idea of holding a WG Congress. Aloha Larry, Like Stephanie, I was very pleased to see Uncle Sam at the last CDP Steering Committee meeting. The problem is that the people who are not being reached are not within the circle of family, friends and neighbors of the majority of the CDP participants. I would just like to say that we need to reach beyond the circle of family, friends and neighbors to spread the word. >At 09:35 AM 4/25/2007, Larry Brown wrote: > >Thanks again for stimulating discussion and please don't ever hesitate to >suggest something new for all of us to consider in making this process as >effective as possible. Suggestions: Reach out to the non-white communities, i.e. Filipino, Hawaiian, Chinese, Japanese, Tongan, Fijian, Korean, African. Find out where their circles of influence exist and meet in their communities. Reach out to public and charter schools, specifically youth. forward! devotion, prema _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation _______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
