On Apr 30, 2007, at 7:56 PM, John Schinnerer wrote:

>
> I suggest that the first need for transportation work, specifically  
> mass
> transit, is the basic facts on what potential if any mass transit  
> has in
>   such a large-area low-density region as Puna, all else equal.
>
> To quote Brittanica:
> "In low-density settings, traditional fixed-route, fixed-schedule  
> bus or
> train operations cannot meet market needs."
>
> As an experienced mass transit rider in multiple large urban/suburban
> areas, I see a lot of very fundamental questions and research being
> completely ignored and assumptions being made that if we just do "mass
> transit" as it is done in urban areas it will somehow automatically be
> effective.
> Given our particular land use context, I am extremely dubious that the
> urban-density methods applied so far will do any good.

Good morning, all...

First, I would like to ask how many of you have read the Mass  
Transportation report? If you read it, did you read it in its  
entirety, its executive summary or other parts of it? I would  
appreciate any feedback on these questions any of you can offer.

Second, I would like to explain that members of the Transportation WG  
were aware, and even pointed out to some of those who attended our  
meetings and tried to compare a Big Island version of mass transit  
with urban systems in place in San Fran, Seattle, D.C., N.Y., Mexico  
City, London, etc., that we were a unique, very LOW DENSITY area  
approximately the size of the state of Connecticut (with MILLIONS of  
people in its tax base). An incredible hurdle for those seeking mass  
transit options on the Big Isle!

However, during the course of our investigation, we learned there are  
already systems and legislation in place to help us develop RURAL  
MASS TRANSIT.

John, with all due respect, when you quote Brittanica, are you  
quoting an encyclopedia? Quoting a harbound, printed resource of all  
general information in this respect is analogous with doing the Puna  
CDP work based on the 2000 census (when there are more current,  
valid, pertinent government census figures available).

When our group of volunteers started tackling the issue of mass  
transit on the Big Island (an overwhelming expressed desire of people  
in the 130 small group meetings), we saw the priorities expressed by  
people (NOT numerically in this order) as #1, safety; #2,  
connectivity; #3, the environment.

In 2005, Pres. Bush signed into law the SAFETEA-LU Act and placed it  
under the purview of the Federal Transit Administration. One of the  
participants in our Mass Transit subcommittee informed us of this  
act, Margaret Dohanos. The 2005 Safe, Accountable, Flexible, and  
Efficient Transportation Equity Act--A Legacy for Users (SAFETEA-LU  
Act) provides massive coverage for all the things we're talking about  
in Puna related to transportation issues, including provisions for  
such public transportation costs as bus stations, etc., with  
"guaranteed funding for highways, highway safety and public  
transportation totaling $244.1 BILLION..." http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ 
safetealu/summary.htm

The act was designed "to meet the Nation's CHANGING transportation  
needs..." Its priorities are the same ones we addressed in our MT  
report: safety, connectivity, the environment. I do believe EVERYONE  
considering transportation needs -- citizens, public representatives,  
bureaucrats, consultants, etc. -- needs to familiarize themselves  
with this law. It was an oversight on my part not to list it in our  
subcommittee's list of references.

In addition, Margaret informed us of a organization known as The  
Association of Programs for Rural Independent Living (APRIL) which  
has been working for some time, apparently, on rural transportation  
issues.  APRIL's website  (1st reference below) sorely needs updating  
but the second URL below has a very comprehensive list of pertinent  
transportation sites and the FTA's own website is given as well.  
Please check some of these sites out.

http://www.april-rural.org/transportation.html

http://april.espacecommunications.com/transportation_resources.html

Federal Transit Authority
http://www.fta.dot.gov/


So before jumping to conclusions about our MT report and its lack of  
realistic practability, please read our report through in its  
entirety and understand that there are other areas in our country  
dealing with urban and suburban problems in rural settings. And that  
there may even be legislation to help us tackle those 21st century  
problems. And if there's something you don't see specified in our  
report, check the list of appendices and see if what you're looking  
for might be included. Then call or email me and I would be happy to  
make the file available to you to check the specifics.

Thanks for your attention. Aloha, Frankie











_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to