PCDP - A case for long term comprehensive planning
With the arrival of the transportation consultant,
Wayne Yoshioka, I see the need to express the case for
long term comprehensive solutions for Puna. Kim
Tavares is correct when she says that, as currently
discussed, transportation issues are driving land use
issues and it should be the other way around. It is
also true that long term solutions should be
considered ahead of short term solution solutions. I
will try to expand these issues here.
1. It is not just us. - What is the goal?
It is not just us that we are attempting to plan for.
It is for the aina and it is for future generations
now in our schools and yet to be born. It is often
stated that the thousands of empty lots in Puna will
someday each have a home and family are as stated the
implication is that the stated goal is to speed that
future.
That is not the goal.
The common theme of the CDP is to keep Puna a rural
district. The simplistic view of adding more lanes
to our highways is merely adding capacity. Music to
the ears of developers who care not for lifestyle much
less sustainability. If the overriding goal is to
preserve the character of Puna I say that the 20th
century transportation model is the wrong way to go.
Saying that a PMAR is projected to be fifteen years
away and is, by implication, not worthy of much
attention now is very dangerous. If this subject was
not ignored ten or fifteen years ago we would be
having alternative routes available to us now. It is
stupid and short sighted to not be willing to
undertake such long range planning. It is not just
about us today. It is about everyone forever.
2. Transportation science is about to change....
change it in Puna.
Our modern transportation system has in many ways been
a wonder of the world. It was build and developed,
after World War II, on a basis of cheap gas, big
engines and fast cars. Does anyone really think that
that formula will persist into the next fifty years?
Gas prices are at record highs, oil regions are
extremely unstable, emerging technologies are moving
to lighter, more fuel efficient technologies, climate
issues are speaking of carbon threats, Puna is located
in one of the most remote places on earth. More cars
moving faster? Really?
Should we not think hard about the next fifty years in
our planning and dial in these issues?
More cars moving faster is the model that present day
transportation theory computes on. Wayne Yoshioka
explained that not long ago aesthetics were not even
on a traffic engineers agenda. They are now. I
suggest that sustainability and fuel efficiency soon
will be on the agenda and should be today.
Mass transit can a be improved and implemented fairly
quickly according to Franki Stapleton of the
Transportation Working Group. That is good news.
That is opportunity knocking. Will we be smart enough
to open the door?
Once in past history there was rail service through
Puna. Will we be smart enough to develop capacity for
rail in the future? Believe it or not other countries
and cultures have experienced these issues before us
and implemented progressive solutions. Europe has
$8.00 gas now. That is our future. Look at it.
In an era of declining petroleum prices will rise.
While gas as a fuel phases out and more fuel efficient
systems take their place should we really be building
more lanes for more cars to move faster?
Keola Downings group proposes that better
transportation safety can be achieved with slower
speeds and roundabouts? Slower speeds also steer us
to a more fuel efficient future. A major roadway
without electrically controlled intersections will
function when the power is off. Isnt the
overwhelming message from the community that they want
safety for themselves and their neighbors? Wouldnt
short term improvements of acceleration and exit
lanes, realigning intersections, roundabouts and
lower speed limits cost less and take affect sooner?
Might that route of highway development cost less and
free up funding to initiate a PMAR?
3. One thing affects another.
Simply following short term thinking that we need more
lanes and signals now and dont bother about long
range thought ignores the effect that other, non
transportation, proposals offer. Into the calculation
should go the village center theory put forth by the
Land Use WG. These are not vague and wacky ideas. It
has been done and it is doable. Reduce the traffic
trips by moving jobs, goods and services closer to the
neighborhoods. Will people still go to Hilo? Of
course they will. Would they need to go daily?
Probably not if good land use planning is adopted.
Land Use proposals include no commercial use of Punas
main roadways. Preserve the rural character of the
district as much as possible. Avoid the creation of
commercial strip malls which would forever alter
Punas sense of self.
4. Winners and losers.
We have to think beyond our own self interests and
consider the whole community. We cant plan
effectively if every idea is viewed through a lens of
would I or my friends benefit? Or would we be hurt?
Trying to pick winners and losers in the planning
process is a path to failure and a path to unintended
consequences. There are people in HPP who hate the
idea of a route through that subdivision. There are
others in HPP who would welcome one if it was well
planned. Who is right? Who is looking to the next
generation?
If Puna truly builds out fully and mass transit,
village centers, alternate routes and sustainable,
connective roadways are not in place then Puna will
have become the San Fernando Valley of Hawaii. It
would be sad to see choked traffic where drivers are
cursing those ahead of them and not hearing the curses
of those behind them. Is that a harsh view of the
future? Look at L.A. Look at Dallas. Do we want to
be them?
5. Shortchanging everybody, everywhere, all the time.
This is my weakest argument. Not usually a great idea
to end a presentation with your weakest argument. I
cant pull up traffic counts or clear data to support
this conclusion of mine. I base my thinking on
observations I have made and researched and positions
expressed in the paper.
Our engineering and public project contractors are
seriously gouging us throughout Hawaii and perhaps the
nation. When HDOT reports in the newspaper that all
roadwork bids are coming in 100% over projected costs
I feel like I am the only one who notices. The HDOT
estimators, I believe, know their trade. If that
statement is true, and I believe it is. Then HDOT is
poised, within the STIP, to spend $60 million to do
$30 million worth of work on Hwy. 130.
I have seen this on a local scale too. When a sign
went up in front of the Pahoa Neighborhood Center
announcing a $1.1 million renovation I had to go to
the counter of Parks & Rec. to see these plans. I
understand contracting. Parks & Recs estimator
explained that he had the work estimated at $600k but
the all bids came in at near twice that figure. His
hands were tied by procurement laws.
Can anyone sense just how darkened our future becomes
if, by simple greed and lobbying one half of our
public infrastructure budget is wasted and given away?
I do not suggest that the Puna Community Development
Plan can solve this one with a recommendation to
council. But we, as citizens, need to pay attention.
The civil servants know what is happening. It is
going on right over their desks. I think it likely
that a skilled auditor could find evidence of crime.
I think it possible that changes in our procurement
laws could increase competition and accountability.
Aloha and best wishes,
Rob Tucker
Pahoa Village
____________________________________________________________________________________Sick
sense of humor? Visit Yahoo! TV's
Comedy with an Edge to see what's on, when.
http://tv.yahoo.com/collections/222
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation