Aloha,

Mahalo, Rob, for a well stated case for thoughtful design for Puna's future!

I would add this:

Viability of mass transit in Puna depends on creating villages/towns 
with *densities* of people adequate to support large numbers of trips on 
primarily direct routes (empirically, just one transfer required halves 
the number of riders. Two transfers...forget it!).

The current land use pattern in Puna does not support significant trip 
reduction by "the usual" mass transit methods because most of the 
population lives in low-density large-lot suburbs which cannot be 
functionally or economically served by buses (and even less by rail).

Mass transit and development of population density centers can ideally 
progress side by side, or one can lead the other.
That is, existing population density centers can be used to locate key 
transit points, or vice versa, or some of both.
For example, certain points along a proposed rail route should be 
selected because they already are, or are intended to become, population 
density centers that support and are served by the rail line.
Likewise for bus routes, if they are to be truly useful in reducing SOV 
trips. Just because buses can be thrown into service on existing 
SOV-based roads/routes doesn't mean they will be effective or efficient 
there.

Meanwhile, the most immediately useful approach in the short term may be 
organized vanpooling/carpooling/rideshare arrangements. There are 
numerous existing examples to draw on. King County (WA state) provides 
support services:

http://transit.metrokc.gov/tops/van-car/van-car.html

Here's what Dallas regional transit offers:

http://www.dart.org/about/rideshare.asp

Central Virginia:

http://www.rideshareinfo.org/

And so on...there are lots of online services not connected to 
government operations as well, such as:

http://www.rideshareonline.com/

Part of good design is finding near-term options that complement (rather 
than limit or block) preferable long-term solutions.

aloha,
John S.

Rob Tucker wrote:
> PCDP - A case for long term comprehensive planning
...

-- 
John Schinnerer - MA, Whole Systems Design
------------------------------------------
- Eco-Living -
Whole Systems Design Services
People - Place - Learning - Integration
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://eco-living.net
_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to