Working Paper #2, Section 3, is entitled “Promoting Appropriate 
Agricultural Use.” Regrettably, and unacceptably, this paper does not 
draw to any serious extent upon the Report of the Agriculture Working 
Group. Reading Working Paper #2, Section 3, gives no indication that 
the consultant has even read the Agriculture Working Group Report.

To quote from the Agriculture Working Group Report:
“Food security is the all encompassing issue regarding expansion of 
Puna agriculture in a resource-sustaining and community-empowering way.”
(p.1)
“GOALS, OBJECTIVES, AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Goals for Puna Agriculture
1.Local livelihood opportunities based on wholly-sustainable 
agriculture supplying local markets.
2.Rewarding individual agricultural enterprise.
3.Community land stewardship commitment.
4.Enhanced green infrastructure and a clean rural landscape.
Achieving the forgoing Goals will require, among other things, the 
County Government to take targeted, proactive, and positive measures to 
expand, and ensure the sustainability of, agriculture in Puna. 
Objectives
Action is required on these policy targets: land, infrastructure, 
entrepreneurs, access.
Policy outcomes must include, but not be limited to:
1.Statutory designation of essential agricultural land; with 
establishment of and rigid adherence to robust standards and criteria 
regarding changing zoning of any parcel of essential agricultural land.
2.Development of complementary infrastructure: communications, farm-to-
market roads, post-harvest handling and processing, and value-adding 
capacity.
3.Development of human capital through training of skilled and capable 
agricultural entrepreneurs; and
4.Achievable and equitable access, for skilled and capable 
agricultural entrepreneurs, to agricultural land and complementary 
infrastructure.
In addition to the above policy outcomes, associated beneficial 
outcomes include agricultural lands serving as open space and providing 
environmental services.”(p.10)

The first part of Section 3 of Working Paper #2 is, “Adjust Land Use 
Controls on Agricultural Land,” with several possible options outlined. 
There may be some useful information among these options as to how to 
meet the need stated in the Agriculture Working Group Report: “decouple 
the price of essential agricultural land from the price of land 
dedicated to non-agricultural uses” (p.3). Some further study, 
discussion, and edification will be required to make this 
determination. 

Missing from any discussion in Working Paper #2 is recognition of the 
contribution of agriculture to green infrastructure, open space, and 
environmental services.

Much of the Agriculture Working Group Report seems to have been 
largely dismissed. In addition to the need to prevent agricultural land 
from being irreversibly lost for agricultural uses, the Agriculture 
Working Group Report explicitly identifies and emphasizes the need for 
economic opportunity for local producers to supply local markets. 

In Working Paper #2, agriculture as an economic opportunity is 
narrowly confined to farmers markets in proposed village centers, 
subsidized farm tours, and bio-fuel crops – nothing about developing 
capacity for local producers to supply local markets. 

Farmers markets in village centers may be helpful in growing Puna 
agriculture. However, these would likely be small, for occasional 
sales, with limited or no shelter, water, or other facilities required 
for the type of modern farmers markets recommended in the Agriculture 
Working Group Report. The mention of farmers markets in Working Paper 
#2 is an afterthought to the village centers, not part of a 
comprehensive approach to developing food security. Likewise, the 
subsidized tours and the bio-fuels were plucked from the air as notions 
for filler in Working Paper #2 – neither were from the Agriculture 
Working Group Report; and much in the Agriculture Working Group Report 
was completely absent from section 3 of Working Paper #2. 

Overall, section 3 of Working Paper #2 demonstrates a complete lack of 
interest in the Agriculture Working Group Report, and/or inadequate 
understanding of agriculture in general and agriculture in Puna in 
particular.

It is my understanding that the consultant will be preparing some 
information regarding “Economic Opportunity” since the working group 
for this area never got going. Given the yawning gulf between what is 
needed for agriculture and what has thus far been picked up by the 
consultant, I can only fear the worst for anything further regarding 
economic opportunity coming from the same source. 

If amenable to everybody concerned, I would be glad to work with the 
consultant to ensure he better understands the Agriculture Working 
Group Report. Also, as a trained economist, with education and 
experience in agricultural and rural economic development, I would like 
to also offer to help with drafting any other paper(s) on Economic 
Opportunity.


James Weatherford
PO Box 2017 
Keaau, Hawaii 96749
808-982-5549


_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to