James,  I can't seem to find the link to the Plan Pacific working  
paper...  if they distilled our report as you report, this is really  
pretty dismissive...  I would like to read it and support you  
position.  Any direction would be helpful!

Jane


On Jul 21, 2007, at 1:11 PM, james weatherford wrote:

> Working Paper #2, Section 3, is entitled “Promoting Appropriate
> Agricultural Use.” Regrettably, and unacceptably, this paper does not
> draw to any serious extent upon the Report of the Agriculture Working
> Group. Reading Working Paper #2, Section 3, gives no indication that
> the consultant has even read the Agriculture Working Group Report.
>
> To quote from the Agriculture Working Group Report:
> “Food security is the all encompassing issue regarding expansion of
> Puna agriculture in a resource-sustaining and community-empowering  
> way.”
> (p.1)
> “GOALS, OBJECTIVES, AND RECOMMENDATIONS
> Goals for Puna Agriculture
> 1.Local livelihood opportunities based on wholly-sustainable
> agriculture supplying local markets.
> 2.Rewarding individual agricultural enterprise.
> 3.Community land stewardship commitment.
> 4.Enhanced green infrastructure and a clean rural landscape.
> Achieving the forgoing Goals will require, among other things, the
> County Government to take targeted, proactive, and positive  
> measures to
> expand, and ensure the sustainability of, agriculture in Puna.
> Objectives
> Action is required on these policy targets: land, infrastructure,
> entrepreneurs, access.
> Policy outcomes must include, but not be limited to:
> 1.Statutory designation of essential agricultural land; with
> establishment of and rigid adherence to robust standards and criteria
> regarding changing zoning of any parcel of essential agricultural  
> land.
> 2.Development of complementary infrastructure: communications, farm- 
> to-
> market roads, post-harvest handling and processing, and value-adding
> capacity.
> 3.Development of human capital through training of skilled and capable
> agricultural entrepreneurs; and
> 4.Achievable and equitable access, for skilled and capable
> agricultural entrepreneurs, to agricultural land and complementary
> infrastructure.
> In addition to the above policy outcomes, associated beneficial
> outcomes include agricultural lands serving as open space and  
> providing
> environmental services.”(p.10)
>
> The first part of Section 3 of Working Paper #2 is, “Adjust Land Use
> Controls on Agricultural Land,” with several possible options  
> outlined.
> There may be some useful information among these options as to how to
> meet the need stated in the Agriculture Working Group Report:  
> “decouple
> the price of essential agricultural land from the price of land
> dedicated to non-agricultural uses” (p.3). Some further study,
> discussion, and edification will be required to make this
> determination.
>
> Missing from any discussion in Working Paper #2 is recognition of the
> contribution of agriculture to green infrastructure, open space, and
> environmental services.
>
> Much of the Agriculture Working Group Report seems to have been
> largely dismissed. In addition to the need to prevent agricultural  
> land
> from being irreversibly lost for agricultural uses, the Agriculture
> Working Group Report explicitly identifies and emphasizes the need for
> economic opportunity for local producers to supply local markets.
>
> In Working Paper #2, agriculture as an economic opportunity is
> narrowly confined to farmers markets in proposed village centers,
> subsidized farm tours, and bio-fuel crops – nothing about developing
> capacity for local producers to supply local markets.
>
> Farmers markets in village centers may be helpful in growing Puna
> agriculture. However, these would likely be small, for occasional
> sales, with limited or no shelter, water, or other facilities required
> for the type of modern farmers markets recommended in the Agriculture
> Working Group Report. The mention of farmers markets in Working Paper
> #2 is an afterthought to the village centers, not part of a
> comprehensive approach to developing food security. Likewise, the
> subsidized tours and the bio-fuels were plucked from the air as  
> notions
> for filler in Working Paper #2 – neither were from the Agriculture
> Working Group Report; and much in the Agriculture Working Group Report
> was completely absent from section 3 of Working Paper #2.
>
> Overall, section 3 of Working Paper #2 demonstrates a complete lack of
> interest in the Agriculture Working Group Report, and/or inadequate
> understanding of agriculture in general and agriculture in Puna in
> particular.
>
> It is my understanding that the consultant will be preparing some
> information regarding “Economic Opportunity” since the working group
> for this area never got going. Given the yawning gulf between what is
> needed for agriculture and what has thus far been picked up by the
> consultant, I can only fear the worst for anything further regarding
> economic opportunity coming from the same source.
>
> If amenable to everybody concerned, I would be glad to work with the
> consultant to ensure he better understands the Agriculture Working
> Group Report. Also, as a trained economist, with education and
> experience in agricultural and rural economic development, I would  
> like
> to also offer to help with drafting any other paper(s) on Economic
> Opportunity.
>
>
> James Weatherford
> PO Box 2017
> Keaau, Hawaii 96749
> 808-982-5549
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
> [email protected]
> https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

_______________________________________________
Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation

Reply via email to