In case you have not checked the website recently, I prepared responses to comments on Working Paper #1 (Growth Management), which are posted on the website at http://www.hcrc.info/hawai-i-island-plan/puna/consultant-working-papers/grow th-management/comments/Response-to-comments-on-WP-1.pdf/view . WP #2 and the related PowerPoint presentation notes pages have also been posted. Below are responses to comments on Working Paper #2, which I am sending to Larry and John to be posted on the website.
Reponses to Comments on Working Paper #2 (Mālama I Ka `Aina) Comment 1. Need to look into the Highway & Trails Act of 1892 to help identify legitimate public rights-of-way. Response: Trails declared as public right-of-way under the Highway & Trails Act of 1892 are under the jurisdiction of the state Department of Land and Natural Resources (DLNR), unless they were created by a particular county or were disposed of under another state statute (Chapter 171, HRS). While the 1892 law is a good starting point, the actual alignment of the right-of-way has to be determined by reconciling historic documentation with an on-the-ground metes and bounds survey. This is often a complicated, costly process because trails migrate over a period of years for a variety of reasons and landowners adjacent to the route may challenge the alignment determination. Once the alignment has been determined, the next set of decisions concerns design and form of improvements and access. DLNR’s Na Ala Hele program has lead responsibility for determining, documenting and maintaining state trails. Section 4c of Working Paper #2 describes the present status of three components of Puna’s proposed trail system: Old Puna Trail, Old Volcano Trail, and the former Railroad Right-of-Way. The CDP can identify steps toward making those trails a reality, but there is not enough information available at this time to propose specific use agreements and improvements. Comment 2. A native vegetation element should be included in the purview of a historic/cultural preservation commission. Response: The suggestion inclusion of people having expertise in native vegetation – especially the traditional use of native plants in Hawaiian cultural practices – on the proposed county Historic and Cultural Preservation Commission definitely has merit. However, there is also a need for a separate body to advise the county on matters concerning native forest preservation as it relates to development activity, such as grading. The first body would include people who are knowledgeable about architectural history and preservation and archaeology, as well as cultural practices. The second body would include people knowledgeable about local ecology and assessment of potential impacts on the natural environment. From an organizational management standpoint, it would be difficult to combine these two functions into a single body because the membership would have to be fairly large to cover the broad scope of topics. Another consideration is that the membership of the Historic and Cultural Preservation Commission must meet certain criteria to qualify for Local Certified Government status, and therefore federal and state funds. Botanists and ornithologists, for example, would not be considered qualified members, although they would certainly be valuable members of a Forest Preservation Commission. Comment 3. Plan to preserve the water table in undeveloped areas of Puna from further contamination by individual waste water systems. Potential well sites shown in Figure 12 (of Working Paper #2) should be omitted because it seems to imply an endorsement for the future development of those wells. Response: Neither the county Department of Water Supply (DWS) nor the state Water Resource Management Commission were able to provide advice on a potential groundwater protection area. Figure 12 was based on an interpretation of information contained in two DWS documents: the Water Use and Development Plan Update (2006) and the Central Puna Water Master Plan (1999). The latter included information on the test well sites indicated in Figure 12. The inclusion of the test well sites was not meant to recommend that these sites be developed as water sources, but the point is well taken that their appearance on the map could be misconstrued, so they will be omitted from the working paper document to be referenced in the CDP. Also, at the suggestion of Rick Warshauer, I am seeking additional advice from geologists at the Volcano National Observatory to help determine whether the groundwater protection area shown in Figure 12 can be better defined. Comment 4. DOH and DHHL have failed to listen to the people regarding waste water disposal in Puna. Response: The county may choose to establish wastewater treatment requirements that are stricter than the state Department of Health’s (DOH) as condition to the issuance of building permits for private development. However, the county has no regulatory authority over the waste disposal methods employed by the federal or state governments or the Department of Hawaiian Home Lands. Comment 5. The use of composting toilets with gray water disposal is another alternative to cesspools and septic tanks that should be considered. This method may be a good alternative, although ironically it is harder to get approval from DOH for this method than for a conventional cesspool. Unless the state Legislature decides to transfer responsibility for approving individual wastewater disposal systems to the county or there are significant policy changes within DOH, alternative methods that are often more effective or environmentally-friendly than conventional cesspools will continue to be subjected to a higher degree of scrutiny by DOH. Unfortunately, the CDP has little influence with respect to this issue. Comment 6. Some recommendations of the Agricultural Working Group were not addressed in the presentation; other elements (e.g., bio-fuels and farm tours) did not come from the Agricultural Working Group recommendations. [Note: This was followed by additional email comments from the primary author of the Agricultural Working Group report.] Response: The Agriculture Working Group (WG) report listed 7 recommendations. Below is a table that shows how Working Paper (WP) #2 responds to each of these recommendations. WG recommendation WP responses 1. General Policies and Principles The WG listed 7 policy statements in this recommendation that seemed to form the basis for actions that are listed more specifically in the other 6 recommendations. Therefore, WP #2 did not respond directly to this first recommendation. 2. Valuation Reform and Tax Relief The WG recommendation did not acknowledge that the county already offers substantial property tax relief for parcels that are dedicated to agricultural use or forest preservation. As noted in the powerpoint presentation for WP #2 (see slides 24 & 25) assessed land valuations for properties that are in the dedication program are much lower than the assessed market value of agricultural-zoned properties of similar size that are used for only for residential purposes. This results in considerable savings for landowners who are agricultural producers, especially on smaller parcels. 3. Essential Agricultural Land Policy WP #2 proposes that both the state and county agricultural land classifications be recognized as part of the green infrastructure plan (i.e., land to be protected set aside for a particular purpose), and that the General Plan be amended to delete the designated urban expansion area next to Keaau because it would reduce the amount of this agricultural land by nearly 2,900 acres. This inherent conflict in General Plan land use policy was overlooked in the WG report. 4. Rezoning and Subdivision Amendments WP #1 suggested two alternatives for a growth management strategy: district-wide rezoning and “one-time” subdivision. WP #2 recommends district-wide rezoning to match zoning categories to existing lot size as the preferred of these two alternatives to discourage subdivision for agricultural lands into small lots. This initiative would be much more comprehensive than the approach recommended in the WG report, and would also help dampen the per-acre market value of agricultural-zoned land throughout the district over the long-term, as indicated in slide 23 of the WP #2 powerpoint presentation. 5. Farmers Markets The WG report recommended farmers markets at 3 village center locations, one of which, in HPP, is not an actual “village center” at present. WP #2 supports this recommendation and lists several reasons why they play a symbiotic role with the village centers and support other objectives of the CDP. WP #2 takes the WG recommendation a couple of steps further by suggesting that the county take a direct role in facilitating the farmers’ markets and the state support their operation by reducing the excise tax rate for the sale of products, both of which would yield substantial benefits for both producers and consumers. The City and County of Honolulu, which has operated the “People’s Open Market” program for 34 years, now has 25 market sites throughout the island. County staff not only provide the space and organize the set-ups, but also oversee the quality and pricing of produce. They report that sales prices are usually 35% lower than in retail stores. The markets also offer many ethnic fruits and vegetables not normally found in the large retail stores. More information on the Honolulu program is available at http://www.honolulu.gov/parks/programs/pom/index1.htm . The CDP could certainly propose an expanded role for the county based on the Honolulu (or even Kauai County) farmers’ market experience, if that is the intention of both the WG and the SC. 6. Puna Agricultural Scholarship Both of these recommendations involve the expenditure of county funds to support state (UH) programs and operations. For example, the proposed scholarship could be provided by UH through its tuition waiver program or other scholarship sources. UH also has access to a much larger pool of funding for research and development, such as federal and state agencies and special appropriations. County officials are very likely to resist providing financial support for these much wealthier public institutions and levels of government, especially since agricultural education and research are direct responsibilities of these entities, not the county. To put this in perspective: * The county’s revenue in 2006 ($292M) was about 30% of the 2006 revenue of the University of Hawai'i alone ($975M) and only about 4% of the 2006 revenue of the state government ($7,030M). On a per capita basis, county revenue was about $1,708 per resident of the Big Island, while state revenue was $5,467 per capita statewide. As for the feds, they spend far more per day fomenting havoc in Iraq than the county spends in a year providing public services. * Over half of the county’s revenue comes from real property taxes, while the state has a much broader tax base and sources of revenue. As noted above, the county already provides a significant contribution to agriculture by reducing agricultural land valuation assessments for property tax purposes. * In 2006, over 38% of county revenue was spent on the core function of public safety (police, fire, civil defense, emergency services). The balance was spent on government operations; sanitation; highways and streets; health, education and welfare; culture and recreation; and debt financing; in that order. There is not much available for discretionary spending. * If the WG and SC would like to have the county take a more proactive role in research and development for agriculture, this could be accomplished through the county’s Department of Research and Development, which taps state and federal sources for this purpose. This department is also a conduit for direct grants to non-profit organizations for this purpose. More information on current grant opportunities is available at http://www.hawaii-county.com/rd/noa0708grants.pdf 7. Sustainable Agriculture Research and Development Fund PlanPacific, Inc. 345 Queen Street, Suite 802 Honolulu, HI 96813 Tel 808.521.9418 ext 12
_______________________________________________ Puna-wg-evaluation mailing list [email protected] https://www.hcrc.info/mailman/listinfo.cgi/puna-wg-evaluation
